{
  "Title": "Riemann xi pre-Schwarzian condition for strong Lehmer pairs",
  "Definition": "The table holds $S_n=\\Delta_n^2(-Q_\\Xi(\\gamma_n)-Q_\\Xi(\\gamma_{n+1}))$, where $\\gamma_n,\\gamma_{n+1}$ are consecutive positive simple zeros of $\\Xi(t)=\\xi(1/2+it)$, $\\Delta_n=\\gamma_{n+1}-\\gamma_n$, and $Q_f(t)=(f^{\\prime\\prime}/f^{\\prime})^{\\prime}(t)=f^{\\prime\\prime\\prime}(t)/f^{\\prime}(t)-(f^{\\prime\\prime}(t)/f^{\\prime}(t))^2$ CITE{Stopple}, equation (9).",
  "Parameters": {
    "n": {
      "type": "Z",
      "constraints": "$n\\geq1$, with both $\\gamma_n$ and $\\gamma_{n+1}$ simple.",
      "title": "lower positive zero index",
      "display": "$n$"
    }
  },
  "Comments": {
    "normalization": "The Riemann xi function is $\\xi(s)=\\tfrac12s(s-1)\\pi^{-s/2}\\Gamma(s/2)\\zeta(s)$ CITE{Stopple}, §2. All derivatives of $\\Xi$ and $Q_\\Xi$ are with respect to the real height $t$. The ordinates $\\gamma_n$ enumerate the positive real zeros of $\\Xi$, counted with multiplicity from one; see HREF{T3}[the nontrivial zeta-zero ordinates]. The finite range computed here has certified agreement with the usual nontrivial-zero numbering, without assuming RH.",
    "criterion": "Under the Riemann Hypothesis, Stopple calls the pair strong when $S_n<42/5$ and proves that this condition implies it is a Lehmer pair CITE{Stopple}, §4, Theorem 1. The same expression is restated in CITE{Simonic}, §4. The table stores the left-hand side for every selected pair, including failures of the inequality. Its finite numerical definition requires only the selected simple zeros; it does not establish RH or a value of the de Bruijn–Newman constant.",
    "notation": "Stopple writes $Pf=f^{\\prime\\prime}/f^{\\prime}$ and $Pf^{\\prime}=(f^{\\prime\\prime}/f^{\\prime})^{\\prime}$, with $P$ taking priority over the prime CITE{Stopple}, §4. Here $Q_f$ makes this derivative explicit."
  },
  "Formulas": {
    "expanded": "$S_n=\\Delta_n^2\\displaystyle\\sum_{t\\in\\{\\gamma_n,\\gamma_{n+1}\\}}\\left[-\\frac{\\Xi^{\\prime\\prime\\prime}(t)}{\\Xi^{\\prime}(t)}+\\left(\\frac{\\Xi^{\\prime\\prime}(t)}{\\Xi^{\\prime}(t)}\\right)^2\\right]$ CITE{Stopple}.",
    "envelope": "Write $Z(t)=e^{i\\theta(t)}\\zeta(1/2+it)$, with $\\theta(t)=\\operatorname{Im}\\log\\Gamma(1/4+it/2)-(t/2)\\log\\pi$, using the analytic log-gamma branch real at $1/4$. Then $\\Xi(t)=a(t)Z(t)$, where $a(t)=-\\tfrac12(t^2+1/4)\\pi^{-1/4}|\\Gamma(1/4+it/2)|$. If $\\ell=a^{\\prime}/a$ and $r=Z^{\\prime\\prime}/Z^{\\prime}$, product differentiation at a simple zero gives $-Q_\\Xi=-Q_Z+\\ell r-3\\ell^{\\prime}+\\ell^2$. Thus the xi condition is not a fixed rescaling of HREF{T727}[the Hardy Z pre-Schwarzian condition]."
  },
  "Keywords": [
    "Stopple",
    "strong Lehmer pairs",
    "Lehmer pairs",
    "Riemann xi",
    "pre-Schwarzian",
    "Hardy Z",
    "Riemann-Siegel Z"
  ],
  "Tags": [
    "L-function",
    "number theory",
    "special values",
    "inequality"
  ],
  "Similar tables": [
    {
      "table": "HREF{T3}[Zeros of the Riemann zeta function]",
      "relation": "The indexed zero ordinates determine the adjacent pair and its gap."
    },
    {
      "table": "HREF{T584}[Hardy Z-function derivatives at Riemann zeta zeros]",
      "relation": "Signed height derivatives combine with the gamma envelope to compute the xi derivative ratios."
    },
    {
      "table": "HREF{T660}[Zeros of derivatives of the Riemann xi function]",
      "relation": "Roots of xi derivatives, rather than derivative ratios evaluated at zeta zeros."
    },
    {
      "table": "HREF{T726}[Hardy Z derivative condition for Lehmer pairs]",
      "relation": "A different published sufficient condition on the same selected adjacent pairs."
    },
    {
      "table": "HREF{T727}[Hardy Z pre-Schwarzian condition for Lehmer pairs]",
      "relation": "The corresponding Hardy Z condition differs by explicit gamma-envelope and signed derivative-ratio terms."
    }
  ],
  "Links": {
    "FLINT": {
      "title": "FLINT certified Hardy Z Taylor jets",
      "url": "https://flintlib.org/doc/acb_dirichlet/acb_dirichlet_hardy_z.html"
    },
    "zeros": {
      "title": "FLINT certified zeta zeros",
      "url": "https://flintlib.org/doc/acb_dirichlet/zeta-zeros.html"
    },
    "counts": {
      "title": "FLINT zeta zero counting",
      "url": "https://flintlib.org/doc/acb_dirichlet/acb_dirichlet_zeta_nzeros.html"
    },
    "mpmath": {
      "title": "mpmath zeta derivatives and Hardy Z",
      "url": "https://mpmath.org/doc/current/functions/zeta.html"
    }
  },
  "References": {
    "Stopple": {
      "bib": "J. Stopple, Lehmer pairs revisited, Experimental Mathematics 26 (2017), 45–53.",
      "arxiv": "1508.05870v2"
    },
    "Simonic": {
      "bib": "A. Simonič, Lehmer pairs and derivatives of Hardy’s Z-function, Journal of Number Theory 189 (2018), 451–460.",
      "arxiv": "1612.08627v2"
    }
  },
  "Programs": {
    "mpmath": {
      "language": "Python",
      "code": "import mpmath as mp\nmp.mp.dps = 165\n\ndef minus_q(t):\n    s = mp.mpf(1)/2 + mp.j*t\n    d1, d2, d3 = [mp.zeta(s, derivative=k) for k in (1, 2, 3)]\n    u = 1/s + 1/(s-1) - mp.log(mp.pi)/2 + mp.digamma(s/2)/2\n    up = -1/s**2 - 1/(s-1)**2 + mp.polygamma(1, s/2)/4\n    v, w = d2/d1, d3/d1\n    return w - v*v - u*v + 3*up - u*u\n\ndef strong_pair_lhs(n):\n    a, b = [mp.im(mp.zetazero(k)) for k in (n, n+1)]\n    s = (b-a)**2 * (minus_q(a)+minus_q(b))\n    assert abs(mp.im(s)) < mp.mpf('1e-140')\n    return mp.re(s)\n\nprint(mp.nstr(strong_pair_lhs(101), 100))\n# Approximation only; this program supplies no rigorous error bound."
    }
  },
  "Data properties": {
    "type": "R",
    "digits": "100",
    "rigour": "proven",
    "complete": "no",
    "complete-note": "contains $n=1,\\ldots,100$ and $n=6707,\\ldots,6711$: a consecutive low-zero reference prefix, the published first and historical examples $n=34,6709$, and the noncanonical exploratory window of two neighboring gaps on each side of the historical example; the prefix cutoff is practical, and every selected pair is retained regardless of the inequality",
    "rigour details": "FLINT's certified numbered zeta-zero enclosures CITE{zeros} and Hardy Z Taylor jets CITE{FLINT} are evaluated at 533 working bits. The entire root enclosure propagates through the first three signed height derivatives, the gamma-envelope logarithmic derivatives, the gap and both ratios. Taylor coefficient $k$ is multiplied by $k!$. Both $Z^{\\prime}$ and $\\Xi^{\\prime}=aZ^{\\prime}$ exclude zero at every selected endpoint. All 105 outputs are finite and retain at least 504 relative accuracy bits. Each stored 100-significant-digit decimal interval contains both the 533-bit ball and its 599-bit recomputation.\n\nThe finite-indexing input retains 6712 certified, distinct critical-line root enclosures from a preceding computation, with its source hashes and provenance in the attached finite-prefix-origin.json. This build checks their ordering, all 107 selected endpoint overlaps, counts immediately before and after those endpoints, and the total count $N(T)=6712$ at an exact rational height $T$ between roots 6712 and 6713 CITE{counts}. Since $N(T)$ counts all nontrivial zeros with positive ordinate at most $T$, with multiplicity, these inputs exhaust that finite range and establish simplicity and numbering without assuming RH. The input computation is shared; a companion table is not an independent numerical oracle.\n\nAll 105 values lie inside their stored intervals when checked with the independent mpmath zeta derivatives and gamma logarithmic derivatives at 130 and 165 decimal digits CITE{mpmath}. The check differentiates $\\xi=h\\zeta$ in the complex variable $s$, using the full factor $h(s)=\\tfrac12s(s-1)\\pi^{-s/2}\\Gamma(s/2)$, and explicitly bounds the numerical imaginary discrepancy. It uses mpmath root refinement seeded from certified root centers, so the finite-indexing inputs are shared.\n\nA second derivative construction uses Cauchy contour extraction on the analytic function $\\Xi$, scaled by a fixed nonzero factor to avoid tiny gamma-envelope amplitudes. It checks $n=1,34,100,6707,6708,6709,6710,6711$ with 96 points at 130 digits and 128 points at 165 digits, radius $1/4$ in height. All 16 comparisons lie inside the stored intervals. These agreements supplement the ball bounds; the contour discretization is not asserted to be a rigorous remainder bound.\n\nExact polynomial controls give $8$ for $f(t)=t(t-1)$ and $82/9$ for $f(t)=t(t-1)(t-3)$ at the pair $0,1$. The gamma-envelope product rule is separately checked with an exact nonconstant polynomial envelope. Wrong Taylor factorials, a perturbed decimal and a wrong pair index are rejected. Attached executable checks and numerical evidence record the complete comparisons, finite radii, dependencies and selection."
  },
  "Display properties": {
    "number-header": "$S_n$"
  },
  "Numbers": {
    "1": "72.37117635013381936107069974639625031297070070143884614037831576703337216094487334410041714868364294",
    "2": "29.03341248799999053922073754878605798807407692950960931790058804518414803281221633983360107586212066",
    "3": "75.76042705297304402666285422272052350612920118486544816444794268440208248748394981175742535716491248",
    "4": "17.94838043443182130113726194459682115442035244016216674891095107979011741376490493182858724879011509",
    "5": "55.35411916292479188437160388842759444013856698309581197309884931287282938606649896820464705213779254",
    "6": "36.75822519497929241471523005866981715857112989025515994221123218002541103937419270538403965575381360",
    "7": "17.97220286786671840776760074047740825033892700906571658725402764047953895531781679139662871076996973",
    "8": "92.21597118556789067094164932917324089772196316705941661451503682729740085212588736496008478517108372",
    "9": "15.02681845222272269823953783256648894645606547591346284022683897314069341477801256484313305804869416",
    "10": "33.50093083709722933825410090347384331973967220734449172916603018793778198109185423818840250339044241",
    "11": "40.45588376190439189511572185965744375784329395630807531534365207053987273598250702433993494019218881",
    "12": "45.11940892004379808470106957050666819355358939820183659119999000694791612107295457067115016720745868",
    "13": "12.23077864985111027879028811953275591813491974910305832889358218066158492236085307242237604937137291",
    "14": "89.96727863208095345732608813289088457245834559991397689770955452453034095215436276961296323744625344",
    "15": "19.57420685487232163118731164382252381638245143410357843584238075339209452772795472061737375878426013",
    "16": "25.70844917335560073366282293715310612727588452579620772491381128438388852172991337159012838625715806",
    "17": "23.10809278469251352087581655116552751391470165016249830000231350164056466481565766785218080746250648",
    "18": "77.74036858524075061128211522278621750275661110366378664631376353648904568494598810006016487731353766",
    "19": "14.70155277166912221825027648423917446341170363591521453613303851420083153918195860945959365819608722",
    "20": "22.17288416656612333121708347887296180211292037341278305761330015169350586003110784115165735239719696",
    "21": "62.01506041582173624451575832666160576652597927906227359007981999594290887525952450136141885865588365",
    "22": "18.28558537094932866921161483977047439114284758810612611612108108235743830281092522033839572637414894",
    "23": "45.52848233533101963621657256525711370279942291528876156991908431852307287995638053208221753630717648",
    "24": "12.31596686947695678801274775671508422026151098813118050752574588447030715275754778282569332326310693",
    "25": "74.13768993857245351440826295282555379652310790082708916032518207597304830634196494773817103667018928",
    "26": "36.48077407250088020723167754961533675182520994038517567986438235971570133289099955549973792031881064",
    "27": "11.95491999141524494730312349700059508066358624289203138065607559955164725085277753116742414022387715",
    "28": "47.13398707364089864493965062569688800993468438434508728464577866386990644643717244813798714980152677",
    "29": "29.16102951913837658609098669276513639493850863928001224053287860130796060721602491543169029850679289",
    "30": "34.69209877403632693201415498285624850183107279366399178969098465936873750502898623949636761022158891",
    "31": "19.93398504462587886731841406588223668897743429843566410493816458383238711511574361498269676144051035",
    "32": "16.04418576959169998008153639467713080722724839760014912719688129655817235169621314410515067624273365",
    "33": "169.5136094769074703190011729750820617283935593263247157721636094928555412082258342379013751854586221",
    "34": "10.50257308570272202432661825569219395554141008866130761495002069174760941723719972296952711821158090",
    "35": "50.01008863620108532820926700920477272214810498083677591122566993339332425881801844787421002221420846",
    "36": "19.04150493441370062181778823128864483791720678014087250659754025783422153313977667249002231457929462",
    "37": "31.54138483669372145052691433083135502269771892508804060293426894765308944137277753374849439957157511",
    "38": "44.08154537763384793119173762023767978863873678934122489501550391481353495337776383531093877287072622",
    "39": "21.76938987818142705233814254830655574253209191705356804306269325730020938882224185434269016750820055",
    "40": "13.04702413683212432444213470422688506659348785225827925269626284371989721788764329826189892685089416",
    "41": "64.83849402416866238810260432627991830133337074471526447911427613528230355704868715737968761817688927",
    "42": "30.28173886612896041104758290144138787510782670874492940552595014131854420014274180167822680891256239",
    "43": "16.18569900538577209164644281353915149892296194562095442886485415095441253187381113033778702400833096",
    "44": "44.31835809714004591050243420686641015515783653055270159152273218129801261447322659042063913007350382",
    "45": "12.19260958952863064728270776892218528895080208553079324844140115319163062474604533151808926645089954",
    "46": "83.14409217072701749417718112360511346902952450107111809137511029402694453212526209220699410957940151",
    "47": "23.39052486527664169870444927393450457745511471984135773798026468287759595568456954562878056225126803",
    "48": "15.64461606882950706638062142366625585221891901290520652119531869868447304149039777949111166601523847",
    "49": "23.02528321394495959532900139263312451412734691302638120919051825981203403307686780075669475972117979",
    "50": "56.40039683884986544445296506511693162705018423652587250950056256068070388945787409709950146759752468",
    "51": "15.29594876038805753200053069814443990038802780512075220713773892831288406827837666995268803822202159",
    "52": "80.43019907754051742744085052759239128079236442022628866944484763357938718919499524242104263283176253",
    "53": "10.70684240483665333436353866454698911112515511389050535126529855762927250240593227929060546569555908",
    "54": "34.88063172651810518337058522143484046611221719041327593438961837815428747783776826310177597901873520",
    "55": "68.16601229404053519891390875085721418014129810781447329971884909789555185444098584303217235688263832",
    "56": "22.34593981827713623885015011333102913715157110209118455381257337245005905524065235202254696984818322",
    "57": "14.03333242063668669539211481854327377976398230246985175847795673973028531332509663155375867187533684",
    "58": "37.17672224713861031831729892328706890672290947968812583653654183696358442472904552517446053051210259",
    "59": "19.78884331279975497814280749601088479623746168312422882822098716414244606181029009051849608251292748",
    "60": "42.08145796571207386259109822609394405976105229883719889969289336491866398330812854581164912465997135",
    "61": "21.18633369199479886261955109554162075478776268558516661398973578526311113174240404568626636599666819",
    "62": "44.87065548923419110932671629650977565010547624019497416664810235927530538475374562006164694865782138",
    "63": "9.854734877727697550192782501545560816032606119852147904322300124733699331690023557611826176314959782",
    "64": "141.0394072279144840883828864477697019694059423499619594304603000101068605173516410824253079517903070",
    "65": "17.15029908733273408851468721722820084883922014770661213400755180439884414385932349320158910233091267",
    "66": "22.04753301385343243958828588296049508952741051507783399918156438230942720594812033337940525182104819",
    "67": "27.69208765674935674846820389373848787509995267777907528027761118483756232514687472092928097636603317",
    "68": "16.52291798346472133057011165560612118200985456217771166464493759944563124446220175417131459071387821",
    "69": "30.53730828807626879329212874433406070132400870885139178439298028758614041264376484537379213298643486",
    "70": "107.2900477204351148959679280802489798374965638871159596187024390022813469305131855721846791766990121",
    "71": "10.65769490845690429733102173936261434924211629856543281277637578227001961796709571550097675651488443",
    "72": "29.76085095528279114251485803902255002904943098559087997933054296495135523046025489350298181315433939",
    "73": "28.00679668086018090805275370619266778157799708487378198884014204976498270822913892201995033342650855",
    "74": "64.41862401464835040988576629460774191746006214499716557921703510298673231842815590764053156589155497",
    "75": "12.59086702805045390022776867186117111318032618341441587823771324842549829902808117540875584069049125",
    "76": "41.69205889288545451895420684004143178638806602690583760637688196414842507149734662465057093934752214",
    "77": "25.15745144759376029760348575244171002301297013799050841119624218969849774013230227367234022141255325",
    "78": "12.19243006648264524910891754582035067050449894828475718785966646840316480520211178114713913005986994",
    "79": "105.1752159699512580813753218250517125380653380297865103721038449278987492346659125673397157683138783",
    "80": "16.30563234103393541960341655453159561525250302801354299247107459874685490964224062356373921173196936",
    "81": "28.85286840247709648215784625586006672683106177230920521699511022080975601418820175367714631676968355",
    "82": "13.27454137753421047285949776796086451735846628603142784273901765722529322001260282856221415610115682",
    "83": "47.66115508533018473426954109295170883522571777474400730104676227319346467700361647065305425914881662",
    "84": "19.74896503489003674087823827736599689168302061169591902521478602151713082242684150369554252402854988",
    "85": "34.24737629160973892045432356206289662050438051230065599880469886485240221538630726332559434523062444",
    "86": "27.59366133492254358731220640999130861253847610999204539104429409888044068860835950569900725293946998",
    "87": "14.88834070520303509997463681748844865234344229267310768347040488309503138524025585718652236467857567",
    "88": "19.67985053016057033369709333429010150224642069099374956741665153029251522074605082482543298295156885",
    "89": "64.65404887245841316861807001241342350892479567528025554935484782769002189258250397160493124423195128",
    "90": "43.97386813922862546007468936836687714256070062328992299706556684695898488731334564916019605507764798",
    "91": "9.970378290761823105158187903403375173061976826378927841661864413698354911198347312573916040522345486",
    "92": "99.88291934638887136019809391149825470162590571342567137084705768301904203564991101537269927350611453",
    "93": "11.28658878681093416902733836967061154116827674127771739316744746550129490704894268063780647419055763",
    "94": "49.40446945865242285473414144051741691547035994947446834908705258846547898127067370937186092296641490",
    "95": "27.53743502139776597021892249091179058696195147770301283543200142373282727942787955914224886023547758",
    "96": "56.20301799200338885066935205401260237283639579744040802643937635452565025409588614333879293682185391",
    "97": "10.48592079172926556196233232233147477858800244118794453171326408414527396315803077446046181598905975",
    "98": "31.88266690142640071194989376141306275184267675201937646900266288798426111750883771087031379362076580",
    "99": "69.86146240176259749731526320771939411542979211777127599579748590626974701370850471031310506942445771",
    "100": "15.94003328829732689226308316339658807068812466385638842729530256127519174510381393906166929783322527",
    "6707": "102.3510409451831121676329228069431304289270827213856378656622824935148816778465293312129011038476116",
    "6708": "2941.831715741986584561787860319632051694078965480289160902254422533162779868912617707669510473090186",
    "6709": "8.013874657211648655900894717314645028439778305790588998629955019733917878098203851538218378688515500",
    "6710": "7596.579892852209821045540740024950039913212255489576318893075354460446540687971432157373062853785835",
    "6711": "51.09235562551568229809821703694967153474793403900709196423734158631433464113085770988394683653655233"
  }
}
