# Contributor lesson proposals, artifacts only

## A rational-string conversion can need explicit real_mpfr initialization

What happened: in this modular Sage runtime, numberdb.sage followed by the
rational_field.QQ import left QQ('-1/4') raising AttributeError that sage.rings
had no attribute real_mpfr. Importing sage.rings.real_mpfr.RealField fixed it.

What the skill says now: initialize Sage with numberdb.sage before named ring
imports. It warns that modular environments may lack sage.all.

What it should say: if a named ring conversion encounters an uninitialized
Sage module, explicitly import that module before replacing exact arithmetic
or resorting to float parsing. A small QQ('-1/4') probe discriminates this case.

Evidence: T738, generate-original.py's explicit RealField import. The initial
compute_all.py attempt failed at its first argument before any value was
computed; subsequent 17/17 checks passed. No pipeline/source/skill was edited.

## Check complex-ball finiteness componentwise in the actual API

What happened: ComplexBall.is_finite() was absent. Real components supplied
is_NaN() and is_infinity(); those plus accuracy()>400 rejected nonfinite and
vacuous results. The initial checker probe failed before its first table check.

What the skill says now: require finite, narrow enclosures before comparison.
An existing unpromoted proposal also discusses componentwise finiteness.

What it should say: use the actual real-component finiteness API supplied by
the Sage version, and separately require useful accuracy. This is additional
evidence for the existing proposal, not a request to duplicate it.

Evidence: T738, checks-first-probe-failure.log, check_values.py and the finite
Arb enclosures in check-results.json. No successful check was fabricated.

## General pFq support need not include the required continuation

What happened: Arb's generic _5F4 routine at five repeated half parameters
returned an unbounded ball for z=-4 and z=-1024, while its interior values
were finite. The builder retained heuristic agreement-checked mpmath values
and checked the six outside-disk arguments with the separate Barnes formula.

What the skill says now: prefer ball arithmetic, but do not certify a value
merely because its representation carries an interval.

What it should say: probe required branch/parameter regimes, including repeated
parameters and outside-disk arguments, before choosing a library as a certified
continuation method. Unsupported continuation is a reason to use and accurately
label a checked alternative, not to present an unbounded ball as agreement.

Evidence: T738, eval_probe.py/eval_probe.log, generator and Barnes checks.
These are proposals for human consideration, not changes to the live skill.
