Resistance of infinite simple, body-centered and face-centered cubic lattices

edit · history · discussion · files · short url · graph theory electrical networks lattice sums integral random walks physics special values
Numbers
$L$, $l$, $m$, $n$ 
$r_L(l,m,n)$
sc, 1, 0, 0:
1/3
bcc, 1, 1, 1:
1/4
fcc, 1, 1, 0:
1/6
sc, 1, 1, 0:
0.3950791523418513720189141611670123842226379945390116944305503060757609020490882676606468005076783124
sc, 2, 0, 0:
0.4196833906325945119243433553319504631094480218439532222777987756969563918036469293574127979692867503
bcc, 2, 0, 0:
0.2755756753192514665404109570000451193345041833995673100090564070641816281293125837585632506703306519
bcc, 2, 2, 0:
0.2909012284086709930226024323251877653194644839173486389380560036235975000577862956443943271764869485
bcc, 2, 2, 2:
0.3005692888162326213109598320243013460380939980492521531586627679366626154387033617911272664595471990
fcc, 2, 0, 0:
0.1857875214630658225339367528380653011991145049150342021261261829696413097912310712159879640534302473
fcc, 2, 1, 1:
0.1915324125172978858315640610255065634072220602528397233978976994339437268648181273770284377874139844
fcc, 2, 2, 0:
0.1956286403380101449392035835551764773062160824919060354894901696582758062915986813932436540768169014
sc, 1, 1, 1:
0.4183053109218749540756368647037619436363010378263242427321615166584161938287152321101042933782746073
sc, 2, 1, 0:
0.4335988127703458286477722854639418756982796124573775072261560682355331789852162375385027748114269966
sc, 3, 0, 0:
0.4503717593808504236216376568026019425302363479008759714288350479062723015476832926571323552366791819
bcc, 3, 1, 1:
0.3011513506385029330808219140000902386690083667991346200181128141283632562586251675171265013406613038
bcc, 3, 3, 1:
0.3113022123576781059287659013005705839398412020711253157159983862376634877138948475433243060246251863
bcc, 3, 3, 3:
0.3171936215413178534589152102924283004782032777832374180669685423952206915920668491476657095805181218
fcc, 2, 2, 2:
0.2010496668389358810779676924310975214315799600605471879579591497183809277460116556704686638910224602
fcc, 3, 1, 0:
0.1991634852052329151035795308220226735234547878255962163138141828083135358422084196042687877062100908
fcc, 3, 2, 1:
0.2027846762255788506424183014490855882244255317922390034774748116924515067549955057777347665151499092
fcc, 3, 3, 0:
0.2052816920074822965006878244530371074344263794046984190780969591104350026688461382246667896324603938
sc, 2, 1, 1:
0.4415314695018985361323595682405115030499640811136367910337727272410714856083421965595617862488709022
sc, 2, 2, 0:
0.4493516745223898891694765364335179809179738484276404315686963728254968968000278087160040911082501003
sc, 3, 1, 0:
0.4544157201214421265091805233701474198396896477063861130123455003328419120418500263778293867856050124
sc, 4, 0, 0:
0.4648842851667395237687604920030715127132114747357581542458295104093097693150527210740637863083682911
bcc, 4, 0, 0:
0.3096008732634837464853880578500818317016624927812484175498403626400720027944525845952549621906243458
bcc, 4, 2, 0:
0.3129749650288769734659822080498332520989002011273668672326251250971306336026451616602845206986054465
bcc, 4, 2, 2:
0.3157125808339596973326471843762515774410768900735780670859807179445335363856698953827088356546034436
bcc, 4, 4, 0:
0.3200074288499634375662061073018586012881568437401003773111309810165519618022445459767397641550503343
bcc, 4, 4, 2:
0.3215646610608844539331000539010472997930601084604114876829256512411674844357944628483463776994992281
bcc, 4, 4, 4:
0.3251479578297777525631201354832284260851212286146785270703664636679998548334383566970327701222897603
fcc, 3, 3, 2:
0.2070969023872879371954701058007123458702467164048710214789892760546769706092374837493766847463760379
fcc, 4, 0, 0:
0.2043876038993327654626985182436123924564351783414728699719715557706592541542524243711811240185157642
fcc, 4, 1, 1:
0.2054291486195971913397151597753154790066895079853306051991998427745726516773385271594373988618718916
fcc, 4, 2, 0:
0.2063386116269725624725614090835573029961079124467303914014092118826232175906976984338739285844664249
fcc, 4, 2, 2:
0.2078473727398014778616951075470437867011748528727403429469469025399505339063764863050794198610040598
fcc, 4, 3, 1:
0.2084788299751702141017385399973866245671370581771300915109447229433426943528218398599039000038568476
fcc, 4, 4, 0:
0.2100204156948360291473001259282653547484342855935378306911767773585209861218901978844552982677479473
sc, 2, 2, 1:
0.4531445487919103271607209200088862827567956027572930651845783325323991314981556787842905326841690496
sc, 3, 1, 1:
0.4573967829650039511015341337936507577533330184261553586490060452521480988545941146016798091237587133
sc, 3, 2, 0:
0.4613116620049135116999364038277257842988463300682507222953547177085583799167115098252189658291542546
sc, 4, 1, 0:
0.4664185206425350928826685265393134010041095589595017598257150776423914140923008890427626065888522149
sc, 5, 0, 0:
0.4732598690494463474602511890585735297325942646756659147432817039800206579734294776161999362581217050
bcc, 5, 1, 1:
0.3180503958884645598899542017000734247343166187633622150815679111517807493302800016733834230405873878
bcc, 5, 3, 1:
0.3213959012308622949643868151985987610524346168758453181148213888707150411077806299073038523885479083
bcc, 5, 3, 3:
0.3239090514263114304451807160190819656625352193489490158595569256641465362610361898222387344487145459
bcc, 5, 5, 1:
0.3259357005804510544072848975096662991079169391375855572988827600871142772795220765490270458184803345
bcc, 5, 5, 3:
0.3274758486932811668506993596703517613885797762417549424327988921396182641632382900876687864978452740
bcc, 5, 5, 5:
0.3298353407381263751584056465050979270494215643620789236188957135374837458026165646988738885581205010
fcc, 4, 3, 3:
0.2104362487791483333742430287106911770225611972292278125215032494245210722640730745662429352454792206
fcc, 4, 4, 2:
0.2108251015945457389165434101676115842402899238454885259181942376278571637898293688053761403217578440
fcc, 5, 1, 0:
0.2085701778731681899448008641334990248391612392134917884029006417290915749432103263498371854874653102
fcc, 5, 2, 1:
0.2096004524670635082127340402684001948781825610268196251401409793796511809026047574527794529381797024
fcc, 5, 3, 0:
0.2104617698629678195284566066137530568033832249539396223665780453636024302585862365280033435493446022
fcc, 5, 3, 2:
0.2111906766843355946608305635236746386524318972281031072137800790700339888478935301278415479087863060
fcc, 5, 4, 1:
0.2118194584360005399804264451361119096894043543792631169076046722969666564300828351697555277171520959
fcc, 5, 5, 0:
0.2128466029599313978813405329246468989138529475843034708086706975033745671450450632141523915977899956
sc, 2, 2, 2:
0.4601592876622074971886633712783651254189677674744265043356936409413199073911297425231016648868561980
sc, 3, 2, 1:
0.4631466957815337521707332379302057920519519192072089365677672634727175067905460641737569338060830976
sc, 3, 3, 0:
0.4680324365929419403095156543695923479092285075971994616021495135285369713360185305442825754156246553
sc, 4, 1, 1:
0.4677243964821734131170177119206866196867508956161052617000380166606982698544303099473444273103051576
sc, 4, 2, 0:
0.4697767492296396098699792329326853730222821382638604544534023926190394857412805649656838740532795645
sc, 5, 1, 0:
0.4739855763730424709140554870886028610759723018187953138426370291717607777467614019443097377652501063
sc, 6, 0, 0:
0.4787326236377686773365246939939582213784649060430560788433125967837710675384785368458968801793615135
bcc, 6, 0, 0:
0.3221198718646388254240273461720751617856185008263430922391453676439572281385583910616663430185685636
bcc, 6, 2, 0:
0.3233182335171265244224557650334446962317399423297127550596207264603118945983224286973276956705690214
bcc, 6, 2, 2:
0.3243834440536272141006950790356229302848947795115688991930851378707981709216239616322128107225538134
bcc, 6, 4, 0:
0.3262181836975293208909808389761776318732325954858163782265841068721703647869566925426362467606801949
bcc, 6, 4, 2:
0.3269877128049307380030272849145540994084155742782077131266186644630562823289878905181745677468217845
bcc, 6, 4, 4:
0.3289236809614963956927286516263499930862374911145282319079344544213931944179925981329135681976273247
bcc, 6, 6, 0:
0.3295060428950828848338067437954458185832851949214478408615775182364622145891094322720536802151366545
bcc, 6, 6, 2:
0.3299956788327575411371500272975152106355370264506765698290223875322792631771390051734549154631525000
bcc, 6, 6, 4:
0.3312757042899753197807127875992149696056137156228010648109703969066005573655735186803399568089224856
bcc, 6, 6, 6:
0.3329366123208181022838007188808601022346976660699649717240846906478888562367958104541977633230248167
fcc, 4, 4, 4:
0.2126059437911691928513525174584911834722826046265169497597471521411402604971338054659423246448565576
fcc, 5, 4, 3:
0.2128419049640870607418472515586898312631087199180477616432056270294918408716498442631094309975456063
fcc, 5, 5, 2:
0.2132700790697774440848791583575183026239459158774475099452648739508964893356726939414303153690779374
fcc, 6, 0, 0:
0.2108959270247376909738135607182924072998694589475606112240276503433521563466355464114202622802126190
fcc, 6, 1, 1:
0.2112348471223495658236602110925169654233105059232480981958871628151064538518508680228146319547767907
fcc, 6, 2, 0:
0.2115507397626183497867163310170628670228346925283573543611420293556205484769292890118335724818015245
fcc, 6, 2, 2:
0.2121216825933551599281886946837274387942603874019797805194200966877934277774474035295081315455042056
fcc, 6, 3, 1:
0.2123811202773624648917109554848649588535168925639646944233420380144254682455001266524409220810987629
fcc, 6, 3, 3:
0.2132752393213092999399644526744091387636307197461308985497240035075076061459090523566490183803066828
fcc, 6, 4, 0:
0.2130717489599934385616814515626237808967400765842948359811437004976924110514985347361177177775445121
fcc, 6, 4, 2:
0.2134700323798477433200442725314843804034842023483415292705543403188662326405340424454121479047643379
fcc, 6, 5, 1:
0.2139976653372380546901652794054014258802314734153430678540018826180207889416395526721770801069039620
fcc, 6, 6, 0:
0.2147268268113994896230564678761965281457776210710894080041579720266392160287639398454075340544187436
Definition
The dimensionless effective resistance is $r_L(l,m,n)=R_{\mathrm{eff}}(0,(l,m,n))/R_0$ in the infinite nearest-neighbour simple cubic, body-centred cubic or face-centred cubic resistor network, with every edge resistance equal to $R_0>0$ [1].
Parameters
$L$
—   cubic network (The identity is sc, bcc or fcc, with vertex and edge sets in (7).)
$l$
—   largest displacement coordinate ($l\ge m\ge n\ge0$, $l>0$, with the parity conditions in (7).)
$m$
—   middle displacement coordinate ($l\ge m\ge n\ge0$, with the parity conditions in (7).)
$n$
—   smallest displacement coordinate ($l\ge m\ge n\ge0$, with the parity conditions in (7).)
Formulas
(1)
Let $\langle f\rangle=\pi^{-3}\int_{[0,\pi]^3}f\,d\theta_1d\theta_2d\theta_3$, $c_j=\cos\theta_j$ and $C_r=\cos(l\theta_1)\cos(m\theta_2)\cos(n\theta_3)$. Put $\phi_{\rm sc}=(c_1+c_2+c_3)/3$, $\phi_{\rm bcc}=c_1c_2c_3$ and $\phi_{\rm fcc}=(c_1c_2+c_2c_3+c_3c_1)/3$. Then $r_L(r)=\dfrac{2}{q_L}\left\langle\dfrac{1-C_r}{1-\phi_L}\right\rangle$ [1].
(2)
Define $G(r)=\langle C_r/(3-c_1-c_2-c_3)\rangle$, $B(r)=\langle C_r/(1-c_1c_2c_3)\rangle$, $F(r)=\langle C_r/(3-c_1c_2-c_2c_3-c_3c_1)\rangle$, and $g_0=G(0)$, $b_0=B(0)$, $f_0=F(0)$ [2]. The electrical conversions are $r_{\rm sc}=g_0-G(r)$, $r_{\rm bcc}=(b_0-B(r))/4$, $r_{\rm fcc}=(f_0-F(r))/2$. The Watson integrals are $W_{\mathbb Z^3}=3g_0$, $W_{A_3^*}=b_0$, $W_{A_3}=3f_0$.
(3)
The origin constants are $g_0=\dfrac{(\sqrt3-1)\Gamma(1/24)^2\Gamma(11/24)^2}{96\pi^3}$, $b_0=\dfrac{\Gamma(1/4)^4}{4\pi^3}$ and $f_0=\dfrac{3\Gamma(1/3)^6}{2^{14/3}\pi^4}$ [2]. Here $\Gamma$ is the gamma function. Also $f_0=\sqrt3\,K((2-\sqrt3)/4)^2/\pi^2$, where $K(m)$ uses the parameter $m$, the square of the elliptic modulus.
(4)
The adjacent values are $r_{\rm sc}(1,0,0)=1/3$, $r_{\rm bcc}(1,1,1)=1/4$ and $r_{\rm fcc}(1,1,0)=1/6$. Indeed on an edge-transitive periodic quotient with $N$ vertices, summing the edge resistances gives $N-1$, so each edge resistance tends to $2/q_L$.
(5)
In the preceding normalization, $r_{\rm sc}(1,1,0)=7g_0/12+1/(2\pi^2g_0)$ and $r_{\rm fcc}(2,0,0)=2f_0/3-1/(2\pi^2f_0)$, by [2], section 3 and equation (23).
(6)
For sc, $G(l,m,n)=\int_0^\infty e^{-3t}I_l(t)I_m(t)I_n(t)\,dt$, where $I_j$ is the modified Bessel function of the first kind of integer order $j$ [2]. Consequently $r_{\rm sc}(l,m,n)=\int_0^\infty e^{-3t}\bigl(I_0(t)^3-I_l(t)I_m(t)I_n(t)\bigr)\,dt$. The Green integrand has an algebraic $t^{-3/2}$ tail; the exponential factor does not imply an exponentially small tail.
Comments
(7)
Coordinates are integer Cartesian coordinates in a cubic frame. For sc the vertices are $\mathbb Z^3$ and edge differences are signed permutations of $(1,0,0)$, giving degree $q_{\rm sc}=6$. For bcc all three vertex coordinates have the same parity and the eight edge differences are $(\pm1,\pm1,\pm1)$, giving $q_{\rm bcc}=8$. For fcc the vertex coordinates have even sum and edge differences are signed permutations of $(1,1,0)$, giving $q_{\rm fcc}=12$ [2]. Signs are independent. The bcc and fcc networks have no additional edges along cube sides.
(8)
The infinite network is the limit of increasing connected periodic quotients with source and sink fixed. The positive unit-edge Laplacian is $\Delta_L=q_LI-A_L$, where $A_L$ is adjacency. This convention gives nearest-neighbour resistances $2/q_L$. It concerns the infinite periodic network rather than a finite crystal with an open boundary.
(9)
Independent sign changes and coordinate permutations preserve resistance. Every nonzero displacement therefore has one representative $l\ge m\ge n\ge0$, $l>0$, subject to the network vertex condition. The coincident-endpoint value $r_L(0,0,0)=0$ is omitted.
(10)
Writing $P_L=A_L/q_L$ for the simple-walk transition operator, the transient Green function $(I-P_L)^{-1}$ satisfies $r_L(r)=2\bigl((I-P_L)^{-1}_{0,0}-(I-P_L)^{-1}_{0,r}\bigr)/q_L$, where $r=(l,m,n)$. The three-dimensional origin Green integrals and all displayed resistance integrals converge without regularization.
(11)
The Green-function differences tabulated as resistance in [3] and [4] are respectively $4r_{\rm bcc}$ and $2r_{\rm fcc}$ for the edge sets defined here. The conversion in (2) follows from the stated Laplacian. In particular their adjacent entries $1$ and $1/3$ convert to $1/4$ and $1/6$.
Programs
(P1)
Sage
# Compute r_fcc(2,0,0); the attached generator covers all selected shells.
import numberdb.sage as numberdb
from sage.rings.rational_field import QQ
from sage.rings.real_arb import RealBallField
R = RealBallField(numberdb.bits(100, losing=256))
pi = R.pi()
f0 = 3*R(QQ(1)/3).gamma()**6 / (R(2)**(QQ(14)/3)*pi**4)
r = 2*f0/3 - 1/(2*pi**2*f0)
print(r)
References
[1]
J. Cserti, Application of the lattice Green's function for calculating the resistance of infinite networks of resistors, American Journal of Physics 68 (2000), 896–906, sections II and II.D. (arXiv) (doi)
[2]
M. L. Glasser and J. Boersma, Exact values for the cubic lattice Green functions, Journal of Physics A 33 (2000), 5017–5023, equations (1), (4), (16), (17), (23)–(28), Tables 1–2. (doi)
[3]
J. H. Asad, A. A. Diab, R. S. Hijjawi and J. M. Khalifeh, Infinite Body Centered Cubic Network of Identical Resistors (2013), section 2 and Table 1; the tabulated Green difference is four times the physical resistance used here. (arXiv)
[4]
J. H. Asad, A. A. Diab, R. S. Hijjawi, A. J. Sakaji and J. M. Khalifeh, Infinite Face Centered Cubic Network of Identical Resistors: Application to Lattice Green Function (2012), section III; the tabulated Green difference is twice the physical resistance used here. (arXiv)
Links
Similar tables
Watson integrals of the cubic lattices —   the origin constants $3g_0,b_0,3f_0$, at identities $(Z,3),(A*,3),(A,3)$
Resistance of the infinite square lattice —   the same edge-resistance normalization on a two-dimensional degree-four network
Resistance of infinite triangular and honeycomb lattices —   planar nearest-neighbour analogues with different vertex and edge sets
Kirchhoff indices of connected graphs —   the sum of pairwise effective resistances in finite connected graphs
Complete elliptic integral of the first kind —   the parameter convention for $K(m)$ in the origin formula
Pólya's random walk constants —   The simple-cubic return probability $p(3)$ determines the origin constant by $3g_0=1/(1-p(3))$; the off-site subtraction in $r_{\rm sc}(l,m,n)=g_0-G(l,m,n)$ supplies its displacement dependence.
Body-centred cubic lattice Green function —   Its normalized diagonal Green function $W(k)$ has $W(8)=b_0$, so $r_{\rm bcc}(l,m,n)=(W(8)-B(l,m,n))/4$, with $B$ defined here. That table varies the spectral parameter $k$ at the origin; these resistances fix the critical operator and vary the source/sink displacement.
Bessel moments —   Both families integrate products of modified Bessel functions. The simple-cubic representation here has the exponential weight $e^{-3t}$ and displacement-dependent integer orders in $I_l(t)I_m(t)I_n(t)$; the Bessel moments use the power weight $t^k$ and order-zero factors $I_0(t)^aK_0(t)^b$.
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
Table is complete: no (it holds all nonzero signed-permutation displacement orbits through graph distance six: 22 sc, 29 bcc and 36 fcc, with $l\ge m\ge n\ge0$ and the network parity conditions. Distances are $l+m+n$, $l$, and $\max\{l,(l+m+n)/2\}$ respectively. This noncanonical finite reference extent covers complete short-separation directional shells across the three topologies before deepening individual axes)
How they were obtained:

Exact Fourier tangent and Laplacian identities, with the cited exact seed formulas, determine rational coefficients in the basis h, 1/(pi^2 h), 1. The attached derive.py solves the finite rational system and checks that its entire right kernel vanishes on the selected coordinates; this proves uniqueness there without imposing a zero boundary condition. Arb evaluates the gamma products and all propagated arithmetic at numberdb.bits(digits, losing=256) bits. Three adjacent values are exact rationals; the remaining 84 entries record 100 significant digits.

more

The executed evidence checks every selected graph orbit by breadth-first search, harmonicity at all 87 sites including boundary helpers, all 29 BCC coefficient triples against the primary paper after normalization conversion, and the three origin constants against elliptic formulas. Independent original-symbol quadrature checks all 87 entries at ordinary precision and all 41 entries in shells one, two and six at high precision, with known-answer and deliberately wrong controls. Quadrature order agreement is a numerical check, not a certified quadrature error bound. See numerical-evidence.json, method.md and the executable checks for actual errors, precision and limitations.