argument-selection.md

back to table · edit · history · where entries came from · files · download

2606 bytes, as of the version from 2026-10-31 12:30 (current). Recorded here, not run.

# Argument selection for T637

The sole free parameter is the integer spatial dimension d >= 1. It is a
`discrete_index` of the arbitrary-dimensional Euclidean transport model, not a
sampled continuous coupling. Plane-parallel symmetry reduces the depth variable
without changing the spatial dimension. The d=1 member is the two-direction rod;
d>=2 uses uniform directions on the unit sphere. All members use independent
exponential free paths of mean one, single-scattering albedo c=1, a vacuum
boundary without internal reflection, and one particle speed.

We select every dimension 1 through 10 in increasing order. This includes the
rod, two-dimensional Flatland, and physical three-dimensional model, and gives
initial coverage of both even and odd higher-dimensional geometries. The upper
bound 10 is a noncanonical computational choice: it permits high-precision
quadrature, independent recomputation, and checks of every entry while extending
beyond the eight dimensions tabulated in the source. It is not a claim that
higher dimensions describe ordinary laboratory space, or that every dimension
has a separately documented application. Breadth across geometries is chosen
before extending any one dimension into absorption, anisotropy, or alternate
flight laws. Those change the model and are not parameters of this table.

There is no continuous reference sample or Cartesian mesh here. The fixed c=1
is the intrinsically conservative case. The definition and parameter constraint
remain d>=1; only the completeness note and generator default impose d<=10.
The moment order belongs to the separate proposed H-moment table, not to this
one. The three-dimensional Hopf constant is the d=3 entry, not a duplicate
singleton or a second convention.

Checked sources: d'Eon and McCormick, arXiv:1905.07825v1, Sections 2 and 3
(angular measure and transport model), Section 6.1, equations (175)-(184) and
Table 2 (dimension-indexed distances); d'Eon and Williams,
arXiv:1802.02120v3, Section 3.1, equation (57) and its conservative limit
(Flatland); Kawabata, arXiv:1611.10197v1, equations (11)-(13) and Appendix A
(the three-dimensional normalization and Hopf constant).

This is the builder's rationale. The required independent argument-selection
review belongs to a separate critique actor. No acceptance sidecar is produced
by this build.

Instruction evidence: ../20261031T110316Z-build-skills/manifest.json. Both
archived skill-local.md and skill-live.md have SHA-256
`a2b28d9953264d7b0ca62663785c2952190c5be6d6d3597fd695d9a54d606278`;
the source snapshot's canonical skill has the same digest.