audit-assessment.md

back to table · edit · history · where entries came from · files · download

1308 bytes, as of the version from 2026-11-15 19:16 (current). Recorded here, not run.

# T716 authenticated audit assessment

The audit returned one finding: the selected rational arguments have a median
reported denominator of 16 and maximum 16, requiring a family-specific
selection rationale. It reported no arithmetic, schema, prose, link or tag
fault. The finding is retained verbatim in audit.json, whose clean flag is false.

The two argument groups already have explicit source-based rationales in
Comments, complete-note and argument-selection.md. CGLXZ (1.1)-(1.2) selects
exactly v=1/16 and -1/16 through its Apéry-like sums; its z=1/4 maps to our
v=+/-z^2. The other two arguments are exactly both real convergence boundaries,
v=+/-1/4, and Lemma 2.2 includes both signs at z=1/2. These four values form
no denominator-bounded grid. Every selected identity belongs to one of these
two disjoint exhaustive groups. The p prefix is a discrete moment order,
with a clearly noncanonical finite cutoff, rather than an invented coupling.

Disposition: the numerical denominator screen calls for mathematical judgment;
its requested explanation is already supplied. No entry or sound prose was
changed merely to suppress that diagnostic. A fresh independent critic must
assess the stated justification and sources. This builder assessment is not
the independent argument-selection verdict.