README-evidence.md

back to table · edit · history · where entries came from · files · download

3942 bytes, as of the version from 2026-11-16 11:55 (current). Recorded here, not run.

# T725 reproducibility and scientific-check evidence

Quantity and selection: argument-selection.md. Definition and references: document.json (before API fill) and stored-table.json (authoritative API readback). Source HTML is retained in this work directory, indexed by sources-manifest.json. The coordinated canonical instruction bundle is in ../20261116T111656Z-build-skills; skill-manifest.json records matching complete local/live bundle hashes.

Requires SageMath 10.9, numberdb 0.1.10, and mpmath 1.4.1 (measured versions are in numerical-evidence.json). On an ordinary Sage installation, place the attachments in one directory. No credentials are required for offline numerical checks.

- `sage -python compute.py > compute.log` computes every defining moment and determinant once, exercises the existing dry_run.py/check.py checks, and emits exact binary rational endpoints. Its initial controls are M(0,1;1)=1 and M(0,2;1)=1/2. To resume, materialize saved records with `python3 harvest.py` first, keeping the exact same generator bytes; compute.py reads only matching-hash checkpoints.
- `python3 harvest.py` materializes moments-checkpoint.json and, on successful completion, entries.json and numerical-evidence.json. It refuses changed generator hashes and a partial default selection. Endpoint comparisons use exact_rational(), not conversion of a binary float to an approximate rational.
- `sage -python checks.py > independent-check.log` independently recomputes every even determinant using mpmath, direct-t tanh-sinh quadrature and signed permutation expansion. It checks the five-factor Gamma evaluation, reflection identities for every odd 5<=n<=15 with freshly integrated odd matrices, nonzero controls, and invalid controls. The calibrating two moment integrals use 50 working digits; all table comparisons and identities use 130 digits after clearing those caches.
- `python3 check_evidence.py` collects actual completed independent-check output into check-results.json, refusing incomplete or failing runs.
- `python3 serialization_check.py` checks exact containment of the full certified ball in every 100-significant-digit last-place interval. Its controls reject unrelated and vacuously wide intervals.
- `python3 stored_check.py` compares API readback values with the certified binary endpoints and independent decimal results. It does not re-integrate.
- `sage -python verify_stored.py < private-key-file` checks every stored entry through Generator.verify(sample=None), replaying exact matching-hash moment balls to avoid another costly quadrature run. This is a reproducibility check, distinct from checks.py. The private key is used only for authenticated NumberDB API reads and is never part of the attached source or evidence.
- `sage -python generate.py` independently of local checkpoints recomputes and verifies the entire table against the website. For this private draft it needs the author's own configured API key. The explicit --publish option uploads entries additively; it does not publish or offer the draft. The controller alone handles later review offering.

Campaign execution uses agents/sage.sh and all numerical artifacts reside in this run's isolated work directory. The durable compute log is itself a per-moment checkpoint, even before harvest.py is rerun. For runtime mounts, include the main Python source and its sibling .py/JSON inputs when invoking agents/sage.sh.

Presentation checks use browser_check.py with the shared browser installation. Exact readback sections are rendered through the live preview renderer because no authenticated website session cookie is available; canonical private-page access is separately recorded as unavailable. All intended Similar tables records must actually render. No independent scientific or argument verdict is issued here: a fresh critic must bind both verdicts to the final live revision and attachments before the controller offers it.