lessons-proposal.md

back to table · edit · history · where entries came from · files · download

1887 bytes, as of the version from 2026-11-19 23:07 (current). Recorded here, not run.

## Normalize Sage's higher-weight Atkin-Lehner operator before taking a sign

What happened: at (N,k)=(3,12), the exact modular-symbol operator had scalar
243, while PARI's analytically normalized Fricke operator had eigenvalue 1.
The checker initially refused to interpret 243 as a sign. Sage's documentation
states that its operator is N^(k/2-1) times the Atkin-Li operator. Dividing
exactly by this factor reconciles the definitions; all selected rational
forms then agree with the independent PARI action.

What the skill says now: fix normalization, verify substantive identities,
and interpret certificates and software outputs from their documentation.

What it should say: consider adding this higher-weight modular-symbol example
to the normalization regression cases, with a nontrivial-level test.

Evidence: probe-fricke.log, checks.py, checks5.log; SageMath 10.9 / PARI 2.17.1;
https://doc.sagemath.org/html/en/reference/hecke/sage/modular/hecke/module.html#sage.modular.hecke.module.HeckeModule_free_module.atkin_lehner_operator.

## Convert components before constructing NumberDB's ComplexInterval

What happened: numberdb.ComplexInterval(Sage_interval,0) was refused. The
record constructor accepts its own RealInterval or exact Python rationals.
Converting both Sage endpoints to exact Fractions in a numberdb.RealInterval
preserves the complete nonzero-width interval and the other exact component.

What the skill says now: it gives a mixed exact/interval ComplexInterval example,
but does not distinguish a Sage interval from the package record constructor.

What it should say: specify numberdb.RealInterval for component arguments,
or demonstrate an explicit exact endpoint conversion when starting in Sage.

Evidence: sample.log refusal; generate.py endpoint conversion; sample-final.log
and the complete successful numerical checks. No live skill change is made.