Chandrasekhar H-function moments for conservative isotropic scattering

edit · history · discussion · files · short url · integral special functions physics
Numbers
$d$
$n$ 
$\alpha_n(d)$
2
2:
1.157264939265100559178443957608219330617123012666084349374058604611095604590576691924235156040861957
2
3:
1.003830756257168574647880927298127391346619990591819490450176488688800380972216920891511067122511261
2
4:
0.8988685187516668107029123454543851937068372753506225354077964376725352851758770109394303895024344858
2
5:
0.8212274009080272310562383918943651214900808533270609605652891237161030057876181146930131680354745496
2
6:
0.7607831097163193462303286583541411955425203237573862038885609884758611962538395448506198842889689716
2
7:
0.7119940227831891284875200810383305751143959493753586762757472115712007591415064613748752771879140076
2
8:
0.6715363169156321399005421849744142444898726769138434259538825094364609266727986872269685176872838012
3
2:
0.8203524821491256899841800790249751342327159550960421351622082002159625984765559571362790865570058876
3
3:
0.6378182680315181757825147018717296699565971174618350132221784012619426302939326641573641649886427177
3
4:
0.5222273037919459839683091208717417822586558199148931939458224491311675823681023060860071187804297789
3
5:
0.4422953502953595685297779218073800671262009547821343346500295788745076952873391884081758032476490989
3
6:
0.3836694071439263226675417785126228867813820524354840888161382629275120430534468643764940712734250851
3
7:
0.3388090537964698469067749677756435217682750301386531414066704857275797279545962546764325600002817446
3
8:
0.3033644980635779523349948533989487599575859618542063165695343765373839430624138783074685963330767229
4
2:
0.6366197723675813430755350534900574481378385829618257949906693762355871905369061403604552110650123438
4
3:
0.4526423672846755428877589264194552778087175493444930976912180637883462419244708823824185478512436752
4
4:
0.3436280495289571753648987343995009353002860012619440610583695017320282557017552189989599583045654113
4
5:
0.2725678543397031282426011099693675167950501660583234929865690123898895542312505040427278017386052516
4
6:
0.2231412914531911420014676102155961223186897054220597563961483965333398129240302339436986555577199825
4
7:
0.1870955175482485439635141039984848452924918787437276832745067604300848875697904885629279656292009458
4
8:
0.1598395758058019476137911361344353531631154360270484047292968997339790259972646132751503714330189229
5
2:
0.5205081124263467482757462330831324359558148685307640117618985200375673720456259760123684728244655183
5
3:
0.3431167143256264278033340314439186925107037549552042570286649241811642237507183857566039096583180722
5
4:
0.2439612519531507772546773153709875885847241966591010879355885649513805622942806328152906724765955938
5
5:
0.1826390876936194843397163618999348076438458755249161585663751486680760592243574922307118548496824754
5
6:
0.1419758777614793037337785829602048310903227006807630953008307642915105586181656240252804352336952708
5
7:
0.1135896586357035079734717901307327214048054110105985777706776288447105295109312086169505738884089494
5
8:
0.09297277835154643000436673600743775209440694033756965932317037237328746456170828402240733440130808593
6
2:
0.4403650532979050881804378514702728307241932105049257016687996155010431861758879133540516979712342958
6
3:
0.2718452168297330895901449516685016261006769276588156228039291877011236065939419294977116021697221346
6
4:
0.1824214142933270402703397774013977095637549643708719088752698394757690531679246805436506682228354613
6
5:
0.1296785649133419607003582380416898827191930448971549973205043590348837134231510647213123150032738611
6
6:
0.09619228614251406363719418575025960068831106670635006410765829431788529465532201268369113244761887948
6
7:
0.07373496050439770636793487009916458031589369914132494903531280612245552564482493089812611546184615825
6
8:
0.05801963761093393901394590202227634956813167673586713834066424794462548366659735712942742571743969211
7
2:
0.3816750891175199023303991157179888137811557445022624478575314133469973779411813077651568325440440600
7
3:
0.2223436910966303786287926815870366938366690019422392802893705722818530425035480474477483035548199576
7
4:
0.1416702244333361077393899059206131062230772999672225093343245079545504569085338606267679921865476805
7
5:
0.09609855625098070062713944922988600159401089099523266513343898569405241728255798121765532617137397115
7
6:
0.06829665358150094564525185605804687351714318772967384163864363583701136377067463365633773347485975836
7
7:
0.05032943028859483098552692254093224259858299377129237573037196774149945543464218602864914611392830621
7
8:
0.03818312458448318803004964286020408598346809462172029223644161309818174294212429647342979286648118718
8
2:
0.3368229083651073238799281544853589143127989270602069993876039576283099787707726240036265614191878967
8
3:
0.1862870492893962994750462875812503272190600417563762473773796151179008580021601767633299082608554592
8
4:
0.1132557612165831831711594424516148640509483002994622136960095403417385688207435372774218144589827435
8
5:
0.07360373836079517830408402411067023429265887895920349972362941621726038288526592480944481603847899052
8
6:
0.05028854478344904902862083274246545261296259401707536433822505949435595680255576316846198313446948017
8
7:
0.03573059270834142169074406963556018290190072037085118026665683075005943211015357714729796620492639302
8
8:
0.02620140982611108759731396924082455414348037818110238553881953546311545767221665332612585988698736244
9
2:
0.3014222091578641500468724951288499298627676062104579856863780244874081072782516039348712245403498532
9
3:
0.1590506020392963111031535498462265422284951340682096390170658817474278156195086557164349123852431735
9
4:
0.09263869215223593959443878412829142087864632382214590050728613502480027644367738367207369426497289847
9
5:
0.05787725332127138352752246002917889010542360419090433560253706748841501907947927482422978544055168201
9
6:
0.03812596425205664599518955477744210781838998310187411428690595230926644593893486077874316162529840063
9
7:
0.02618336235877326420678163351806106936931424792358415770323017114865161223581140555379485549893321617
9
8:
0.01859905476243339941347534965942046903143534812116329445621726556650458983136416948608268761604197047
10
2:
0.2727659679593391658712230418788916880077990652798003440827177213958499796050394978991863006860354522
10
3:
0.1378763125970325387829662846055242357475613342954420534754126162175277346569004498546196722171403618
10
4:
0.07719728157219938535587352743529553719489105398275448421503728374827458327390041691348388007306790456
10
5:
0.04649970442470608971415469197758584539829495997402461269657310513798611200905575381681695926358801134
10
6:
0.02960675097528377842267479922560867167831227226467356784297780687134713976715990013014518880944508535
10
7:
0.01969579806818645887860025905247167333499032277200400332860934006458986873706367559095665980698418714
10
8:
0.01357848074897976474718772771126548764350664292367216965826911564442206144553116906156608001215561818
Definition
The raw angular moments of the conservative isotropic Chandrasekhar $H$-function are $\alpha_n(d)=\int_0^1\mu^nH_d(\mu)G_d(\mu)\,d\mu$, where $H_d$ is the physical positive solution and $G_d$ is the normalized angular weight [1].
Parameters
$d$
—   Spatial dimension ($d\geq2$)
$n$
—   Moment order ($n\geq0$)
Formulas
(1)
$G_d(\mu)=\dfrac{2\Gamma(d/2)}{\sqrt\pi\,\Gamma((d-1)/2)}(1-\mu^2)^{(d-3)/2}$ for $0<\mu<1$, with $\int_0^1G_d(\mu)\,d\mu=1$ [1].
(2)
$\dfrac1{H_d(\mu)}=1-\dfrac\mu2\int_0^1\dfrac{H_d(v)G_d(v)}{\mu+v}\,dv$ for $0<\mu\leq1$ [1].
(3)
$\alpha_0(d)=2$ and $\alpha_1(d)=2/\sqrt d$ [1].
(4)
$z_0(d)=\alpha_2(d)/\alpha_1(d)=\sqrt d\,\alpha_2(d)/2$, where $z_0(d)$ is the Milne extrapolation distance [1].
(5)
$\alpha_2(2)=\sqrt2(1/2+1/\pi)$ and $\alpha_2(4)=2/\pi$, where $\pi$ is the circle constant [1] [2].
(6)
$\dfrac1{H_d(z)}=1-\dfrac12\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}(-1)^n\alpha_n(d)z^{-n}$ for $|z|>1$ [1].
(7)
$\lambda_d(t)={}_2F_1(1,1-d/2;1/2;t^2)$, $\theta_d(t)=\operatorname{Arg}(\lambda_d(t)+i\pi tG_d(t)/2)$, and $H_d(z)=\sqrt d(1+z)\exp[-\pi^{-1}\int_0^1\theta_d(t)/(t+z)\,dt]$ for real $z>0$. This is the conservative limit of [1], equation (68).
(8)
Let $J_k(d)=\pi^{-1}\int_0^1t^k\theta_d(t)\,dt$, $\ell_j=(-1)^{j-1}(J_{j-1}(d)-1/j)$ for $j\geq1$, $e_0=1$, and $e_j=j^{-1}\sum_{k=1}^j k\ell_k e_{j-k}$. Then $\alpha_n(d)=2(-1)^{n+1}e_{n-1}/\sqrt d$ for $n\geq1$, by expanding (7) and (6) at infinity.
(9)
$4g_{2m}(d)+\sum_{k=1}^{2m-1}(-1)^k\alpha_{2m-k}(d)\alpha_k(d)=0$ for $m\geq1$, where $g_{2m}(d)=\Gamma(d/2)\Gamma(m+1/2)/(\sqrt\pi\,\Gamma(d/2+m))$ is the even angular-weight moment [1].
Comments
(10)
The medium occupies the half-space $x>0$. Particles have one speed, independent exponential free paths of mean one, and uniformly distributed scattering directions. The boundary has no incoming radiation or internal reflection. The single-scattering albedo is exactly $c=1$. Plane-parallel symmetry reduces the depth coordinate without changing the spatial dimension.
(11)
The defining equation is (2), with angular weight (1). The direction cosine is $\mu\in[0,1]$. The physical solution has $H_d(0)=1$ and is the limit of the isotropic $H$-function as $c\to1$ from $c<1$. These are raw moments with $\alpha_0(d)=2$. They are neither divided by $\alpha_0(d)$ nor weighted by an additional outgoing-current factor $\mu$. The characteristic function is $\Psi_d=G_d/2$; that factor of one half is not part of the moment measure.
(12)
The case $d=2$ is Flatland [2]; $d=3$ is the usual three-dimensional transport problem, with independent numerical values in [3]. Dimensions greater than three are members of the same mathematical model. The separate one-dimensional rod uses only directions $+1$ and $-1$; its moments are all 2 and are not represented by the Gamma-density formula.
(13)
The angular-weight normalization uses $\Gamma$. The dispersion function $\lambda_d$ in (7) uses the Gauss hypergeometric function. The phase $\theta_d$ is the continuous argument in $[0,\pi]$ with $\theta_d(0)=0$, so it stays on the physical branch when $\lambda_d$ becomes negative.
(14)
The second moment determines the Milne extrapolation distance $z_0(d)$ in mean-free-path units through (4). Higher angular moments carry additional information about the emerging angular distribution.
Programs
(P1)
Python
import mpmath as m
m.mp.dps = 150
d, n = 3, 2                  # dimension >= 2, moment order >= 2
half = m.mpf(1)/2
c = m.sqrt(m.pi)*m.gamma(m.mpf(d)/2)/m.gamma(m.mpf(d-1)/2)
def phase(t):
    if t == 0: return m.mpf(0)
    if t == 1: return m.pi/2 if d == 2 else m.pi
    real = m.hyp2f1(1, 1-m.mpf(d)/2, half, t*t)
    imag = c*t*((1-t)*(1+t))**(m.mpf(d-3)/2)
    return m.atan2(imag, real)
J = [m.quad(lambda t: phase(t)*t**k, [0, half, 1])/m.pi
     for k in range(n-1)]
L = [m.mpf(0)] + [(-1)**(j-1)*(J[j-1]-m.mpf(1)/j)
                  for j in range(1,n)]
e = [m.mpf(1)]
for j in range(1,n):
    e.append(m.fsum(k*L[k]*e[j-k] for k in range(1,j+1))/j)
alpha = 2*(-1)**(n+1)*e[n-1]/m.sqrt(d)
print(m.nstr(alpha,100))
References
[1]
E. d'Eon and N. J. McCormick, Radiative transfer in half spaces of arbitrary dimension (2019), equations (7), (40), (50)-(52), (56)-(68), (179)-(181), and Appendix B. (arXiv)
[2]
E. d'Eon and M. M. R. Williams, Isotropic Scattering in a Flatland Half-Space (2018), Sections 3 and 4. (arXiv)
[3]
K. Kawabata, 15-Digit Accuracy Calculations of Chandrasekhar's H-function for Isotropic Scattering by Means of the Double Exponential Formula (2016), equations (11)-(13) and Table 6. (arXiv)
Similar tables
Milne extrapolation distances (Hopf constant in three dimensions) —   holds $z_0(d)=\sqrt d\,\alpha_2(d)/2$ for the same conservative isotropic transport model
Values of the Gamma function at rational numbers —   holds Gamma values used to normalize the angular weight $G_d$
Values of the Gauss hypergeometric function ${}_2F_1(a,b;c;z)$ —   holds values of the function defining the dispersion function $\lambda_d$
Pi —   holds the circle constant in the two- and four-dimensional second-moment formulas
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
How well the digits are known: heuristic (agreement-checked)
How they were obtained:

Computed by expanding the reciprocal conservative phase factorization at infinity, with mpmath tanh-sinh integration at 150 and 200 decimal working digits and different interval subdivisions. Across all 63 moments, the largest absolute change was less than $1.3\times10^{-151}$. Values are stored to 100 significant digits only after at least 120 digits of relative agreement. This is an agreement check, not a rigorous quadrature error bound.

more

Independent direct angular quadrature evaluates $H_d$ from the Fock integral in [1], equation (52), without using the phase-series generator. Two quadrature refinements agree with every stored moment to an absolute error less than $8\times10^{-15}$. The known zeroth and first moments provide controls, with errors less than $1.1\times10^{-14}$. The sine-integral control and the independent Flatland value of $H_2(1)$ precede these comparisons. These double-precision checks validate normalization and coefficient extraction; they do not establish 100-digit accuracy.

The Busbridge identities, the relation to the companion extrapolation distances, the exact two- and four-dimensional second-moment formulas, and the published three-dimensional moments in [3], Table 6, are also checked. The attached generator, independent checks, argument-selection note and numerical evidence preserve the computation and its limitations.

Table is complete: no (it holds every integer spatial dimension $2\leq d\leq10$ at every moment order $2\leq n\leq8$, covering Flatland, physical three-space and initial even- and odd-dimensional extensions before extending the moment hierarchy more deeply. These noncanonical bounds keep independent checks practical across both discrete indices. Orders zero and one are given by exact identities instead of repeated rows; the one-dimensional rod has all moments equal to 2 and is omitted. Absorption, anisotropic scattering, other free-path laws and direct angular values of $H_d$ are outside this family)