Hardy Z derivative condition for Lehmer pairs

edit · history · discussion · files · long url · inequality L-function special values number theory
Numbers
$n$ 
$\widehat g_n$
1:
7.197567376316428259170692204963523439006995289691413652496615216758516701089372192490877664270611992
2:
2.727187084195953749171672417657893563858945472098296391715794725945905802654398273414363625245817889
3:
10.84416020620441665176449936730666263819606572933852801942083765364158579955874768381704425651379484
4:
1.588463514332022524906352414351765270651685285402282985647280147919662973495453314478039240746196832
5:
9.755626016505332466933521964727048853801475644336667813455782944468499560847413827272982297182480156
6:
4.901770634905637123947306365267210828539483707787050449262082840455824106644851558586820403574361321
7:
2.167393486196818498851192016009119959629412829085991309541298232338221372311856906643927941109873247
8:
16.75075359802481663091394525354840093580676164068492875376759561290203772950981699376328678573599224
9:
1.318022832013714915158864444017047559240839243783694542531899957247711919930565810848336154748501288
10:
7.083322468632976257582565839225219210020198722871964628557544911783568741343500441465562156312940492
11:
6.595098179436650012312927796644596922065542899115170835821407300484690251055141909045303140319746595
12:
7.276776675709450767415241147349229930938474503023834773028102054204939308590102966630992709331455489
13:
1.127863947948568482785001854163350832512024069784966238347803152198846747112643822132840652678942131
14:
19.91445094130013824169267352299582741170855741630143028557388586034682416181078404421847844194443568
15:
2.284346821379919187236869256791450122929709246862806065271722064264227652162248567415583455615771337
16:
4.784589295345749625083467005537792572518689016030667886437474705901292221644189270029889532463047803
17:
4.035409855099471930264728364500572443027342172890735340236293730937545416222144651948509228466825914
18:
14.13376909638654286804692135689870930932861036378058629655870275991830574767571749586677493036553222
19:
1.460676815917537305748230411590382803900162343137467732237332856570744585579886457048124571684615753
20:
4.773240091190255880237190342319139069564980752413017413140179855437486709820981613129763384353794428
21:
12.35499116522262855719613780252900839318350019309788082741915824802019488971117869377146801839096872
22:
2.217689577348341777137363569215911786141014302543702154561510160029219330239237407405673035345088292
23:
9.220614605862602303214723332454939848800407247206581066210784796156659653518753935635876419423612024
24:
1.292190031043081560087235221101497496579150343451882522139068670878263976176337337708081816630622757
25:
16.92327434344128325455800099735649417732171505262646266696476167966265937532203856562501214798794784
26:
5.845257107418296328257464466126939206159302090826459773910751122693079822150997764143819928940057197
27:
1.233160202094018940141917669389399665408330986415936918938286317415382998586889469659736876797735500
28:
11.89283890798824259240240699479834653163371480663180431505521972563276115059570200596975834029755369
29:
4.927917674870180359093117028950032489464079591716889114901509327380149825375857941837181152990555583
30:
5.977948307933146704843646271849532151872696995456124163027831652156262000380277364467146014288825145
31:
3.077484370761658917820842204721923108178050706028232914276137999426350768441552457841353711590163300
32:
2.819900755099501622760177145112189073845319856368668769231627543986062078228846218309587263952932493
33:
34.76574428228101438440034175954542345685068376954551319613192121149919836646254096346736957990370334
34:
0.5696721990726871291837576161794230606136976229419444356587352553190967772676710728893801426842653136
35:
13.41181085690313217138825235759414952189697874991315346903087880870111083210448725694041513464939169
36:
3.256776179287394422204666328919527851063050773930410473748094188933412957900024751253462636068935859
37:
6.481265078314320380435567858407236487411838919078890554243813680911770101404448061867109748491691053
38:
7.804785312023138560160236546316108803105227399750913109396770249648034075253005159506925343608706311
39:
3.337883602871204608815842969720711820629966891455744239939392306142177630521001114538874619711235080
40:
1.910953526917105874196779643312535612765113506535946527923455319496996590445285218240399634207334212
41:
15.61738243016448240954416249868192843400793682486223332349564370107156066624764467037068211460541030
42:
4.841100577749942237753879511776697844616017476204597146539962610729978173175439839203073470157165099
43:
2.340021165807272256228881603511369085514302675736738904027045089080143034628635569264966497201961253
44:
9.867731325851780680573860811300082245531001103498000171337977371747136944139608109513492526955680970
45:
1.386504342259133154139968718833311302322546189330017408150458185772301227969877423034833048952149887
46:
18.97989421273611287844704470229301229340530514533828446011294207867213469337077690577323775193910687
47:
3.364480942809061175467801744532430785900721232898897197803733409852248945131289823569169283248058857
48:
2.491500614248661727881065977322664361431833993329559608743751061820996795380455691611482311738808009
49:
5.236463287880807483037860673059310948909832849707489407613407064415110473927838499784809452400267288
50:
11.73841258951798245978414171153304216367113301221884459433030289443830116959653816611129410270492294
51:
1.849275566919098783137173892263317339235384339938909346019855730985443438088012392453049408828757581
52:
17.39788895193352650624926173254172425564281012062811333804165330304007171377087470116164307205297045
53:
0.8112027601003299218674680262836242078462450339989233262954108616129657964759808327535691689883299606
54:
9.344628301048604376124419527410086017201149748062543659744088625816217345798320807231337666004413182
55:
13.71962538644402217347583085802353519403947725591278534789366550166279242999557846135345209935797830
56:
3.220711780784561754690369598817771131358607369408545775063604166279720604523679430802322598575342958
57:
2.133826454243756642103596246130962629683719606883788620707578706302593823823589423894878081468035637
58:
9.147027296617815719429404190082614645297343310939814874251772036233704410811532614906226502715319660
59:
3.474227435490565725413942257572134945327191170882739110428732689759470260063175836399414185486133006
60:
8.530380225561673180614661693175221293530880877430226242834986283427453666579657725555764773289683845
61:
3.238384654724678050702526838926481320858164000745917370655982706464845824444142475769471841895858905
62:
9.531178990896557928966710752029471268103875800768321144182362133330497748015125251516770824838334654
63:
0.7444642084281116058177178797385230211522218115545954096406614803031254331604513367003779889794978961
64:
34.95134287482690711101102445841891970399558820736142965000003697751967491110713381819993106503867391
65:
2.111678659860963823173870725075594041864020850238743701707036452251995460935201332251354978226022783
66:
4.477861614034733893402047578443695278309953760318516764570663360717196141337469878028459326115047418
67:
5.799629953493996183736738384354587817566659156179720364706081655752630401376680469086743115921853555
68:
2.808124066100519318970077557279028943516337269563558415310415975458048244227561611402085779566797785
69:
6.876335522927740777816585795721185183481721297099278086947148605898040255617749801310982470544779091
70:
20.94300906247397314056164372257856931716798637289086848585673016616209332120545753699773882182518721
71:
0.7089209321316750340978126692008723395793636527704966378011049023359997643265389843825548726212505329
72:
7.836174052604158322904067159549162026433482448757315282002734466069696214586407547518503985105009137
73:
6.547407849921916887610355383250734606947149438251437987657127112867480710767087799137892123222102427
74:
12.82409259312919993141654644903238052244994928882355856374504811467318504457716724256578269117049056
75:
1.241748128925008134051349009427548383231981253127483599137158548586074072394171826523765435077274009
76:
10.13274844708304123274544564657089608717946906853554813152874384045221775586125135456555683082884137
77:
4.669870382350478834717677583100512891852356092081791139353765801380450326940033570510855985680670846
78:
1.652499037246419896464821720281153199608185639273896553519962493517682247387320034323236695270895774
79:
24.18976460636393991657352041826135607338100586755585304736176396088477520378471254331648243986212283
80:
1.932754189300526643618012260720650908467745342877022365581448930952917394432409578212615550051898303
81:
6.278374062552199016493923941644293948945091511220336479817795477738751931132814245400555579317870885
82:
1.977539821954912345396079503727038542258987891006555751813091045700592713960032607819055058897007021
83:
11.80633009376046333837941309455341385622608815225788159156786908148618223168124705809251833529130768
84:
3.228424445027427107645039663643809466474639784834989840993267243425152304232788652118413169635210928
85:
6.924437856948940835257226197298830320636390463612566698701036542635066078921998713933280462476230249
86:
4.939710981325888631508856498935107632089148834491951935065491446773021161589743789914661876930171162
87:
2.302652567837056927099211121073803085699948242403797419871723200371928821991346258139296422316624432
88:
4.412679991563439917896299369793236889509485106702376297550535552531819738361946746402477735625969173
89:
14.08387127237182418387227264462216142671639810289361599392303919597182626998508444012740261520442252
90:
8.041582251873191688251219264166069940065457234178272805822220618817068250715771954943470374547478987
91:
0.7314822325983030642323511329460584745725861527858553236565722330628070946678535658757456417128336239
92:
26.14823688592911826875197647723285781878144550358347264939842826347319186868828984555857349402710885
93:
1.104030050075514296892272937725837808451290175364558441888639068566423338390512364987275066440833360
94:
12.76333824255322090576880951198698568156563229940661648698296589099574886214381862993060255416300788
95:
4.876504260117420372014703713619953533097904198157529818273691108963616844639304035652970547022687457
96:
11.21268649352827360207679578574810483186313722453949766681936761527948914011187910983951267639186436
97:
0.8459921376857909625797621750386292146215793855695960697384305119845485252232966198309787158782747597
98:
8.499886827750407063164876156183190923081906662863242391198711733193622241211741235049138885931987245
99:
15.41592673186649797780568404453301840514787611364646706009334384317987617847150636640178493434835637
100:
2.004874732598932072924134488865567730901659167314212176166437874276973130441359147142568041605217976
6707:
26.92588648467317531593461121326778893849100257321691296650455537139264956243569188817513283932936992
6708:
735.3492543812364579703972776518986572770085761177212658027831747785028008093775660766529782161993635
6709:
0.006933229828940296364843649241122966160543410305370530800177031539271031203963330862296135109204491462
6710:
1901.562010515293015937290278665062408794481552585692230838007134659294479075978090251328370297733661
6711:
10.89616434098232711079532995453893528353760946853121436560497432437092689123418271255670551055775512
Definition
The table holds $\widehat g_n=\tfrac13\Delta_n^2(F_Z(\gamma_n)+F_Z(\gamma_{n+1}))-2$, where $\gamma_n$ and $\gamma_{n+1}$ are consecutive positive simple zeros of the Hardy $Z$-function, $\Delta_n=\gamma_{n+1}-\gamma_n$, and $F_Z(t)=-Z^{\prime\prime\prime}(t)/Z^{\prime}(t)+\tfrac34(Z^{\prime\prime}(t)/Z^{\prime}(t))^2$ [1].
Parameters
$n$
—   lower positive zero index ($n\geq1$, with both $\gamma_n$ and $\gamma_{n+1}$ simple)
Formulas
(1)
Under the Riemann hypothesis, $\widehat g_n<\tfrac45-3\Delta_n^2(\gamma_n^{-2}+\gamma_{n+1}^{-2})$ is sufficient for $(\gamma_n,\gamma_{n+1})$ to be a Lehmer pair [1], Corollary 1.
Comments
(2)
The Hardy Z-function, also called the Riemann-Siegel Z-function, is $Z(t)=e^{i\theta(t)}\zeta(1/2+it)$, where $\theta(t)=\operatorname{Im}\log\Gamma(1/4+it/2)-(t/2)\log\pi$. The log-gamma branch is analytic on the right half-plane and real at $1/4$, so $\theta(0)=0$. All derivatives are with respect to the real height $t$ [1].
(3)
The positive real zeros of $Z(t)$ are ordered increasingly from $n=1$, with multiplicity. They agree with the usual positive nontrivial-zeta-zero ordinates throughout the computed range: finite zero isolation and counting certify that every nontrivial zero there is simple and on the critical line. The parameter chooses an adjacent pair, not two independently selected endpoints.
(4)
The numbers are the left-hand sides of Simonič’s derivative condition, rather than indicators that a pair passes. Under the Riemann hypothesis, the sufficient inequality in Formulas implies that the pair is a Lehmer pair, in the sense of [1], Corollary 1. The numerical definition itself only requires the two selected zeros to be simple; it assumes neither global simplicity nor the Riemann hypothesis.
(5)
The indices $n=34$ and $n=6709$ give the first Lehmer pair and Lehmer’s historical pair in [1], Tables 1–2. The neighboring high indices are comparison gaps, and ordinary low-height gaps are retained even when the sufficient condition fails.
Programs
(P1)
Python
from mpmath import mp
mp.dps = 130
def ghat(n):
    a, b = (mp.im(mp.zetazero(j)) for j in (n, n+1))
    def F(t):
        d1, d2, d3 = (mp.siegelz(t, derivative=k) for k in (1,2,3))
        return -d3/d1 + mp.mpf(3)/4*(d2/d1)**2
    return (b-a)**2*(F(a)+F(b))/3 - 2
# Approximate the reference selection; no rigorous bound is claimed here.
indices = list(range(1, 101)) + list(range(6707, 6712))
for n in indices:
    print(n, mp.nstr(ghat(n), 100))
# For another pair, evaluate ghat(n) at its lower zero index.
References
[1]
Aleksander Simonič, Lehmer pairs and derivatives of Hardy’s Z-function, arXiv version 2 (2017), Theorem 1, Corollary 1, equation (19), and Tables 1–2. (arXiv) (doi)
Links
Similar tables
Hardy Z-function derivatives at Riemann zeta zeros —   stores the signed first three derivatives at individual endpoints, which enter this nonlinear pair diagnostic
Zeros of the Riemann zeta function —   stores the zero ordinates whose adjacent gaps enter this diagnostic
Values of the Hardy Z-function —   stores signed values at intrinsic landmarks of the same function and uses the same phase convention
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
digits: 100 (Unknown key)
Table is complete: no (it holds all lower pair indices $1\leq n\leq100$ and $6707\leq n\leq6711$; the low-height prefix supplies consecutive reference coverage including comparison gaps, and the higher window contains the historical pair and two neighboring gaps on each side; the prefix cutoff and comparison window are noncanonical cost-bounded reference choices)
How they were obtained:

FLINT's certified numbered zeta-zero enclosures and Hardy Z Taylor jets [2] are computed in ball arithmetic at 533 working bits. Each zero's entire enclosing ball is propagated through the first three signed height derivatives, the gap, both ratios and the final subtraction. Taylor coefficient $k$ is multiplied by $k!$. The first derivative excludes zero at every selected endpoint. All 105 outputs are finite and retain at least 496 relative accuracy bits; each stored 100-significant-digit decimal interval contains both the original ball and its 599-bit recomputation.

more

The finite indexing certificate isolates 6712 distinct critical-line roots at 96 bits and verifies $N(T)=6712$ at an exact rational height $T$ strictly between the 6712th and 6713th root enclosures. Here $N(T)$ counts all nontrivial zeros with $0<\operatorname{Im}(s)\leq T$, with multiplicity. This proves the critical-line property, completeness and simplicity in that finite range without assuming RH. Counts immediately before and after each of the 107 selected endpoints are also checked.

All 105 pair values agree, inside their stored intervals, with independent mpmath roots and Hardy Z derivatives at 130 and 165 decimal digits [3]. Analytic Cauchy contour extraction, [1], equation (19), separately checks lower indices $1,34,100,6707,6708,6709,6710,6711$ at 130 and 165 digits with respectively 96 and 128 contour points. These numerical agreements supplement the rigorous ball bounds; they are not themselves certified remainder estimates. The first 101 overlapping roots agree with the stored zero ordinates at their stored precision, and all 306 overlapping signed derivatives agree with the stored Hardy Z derivatives.

Exact polynomial controls, the nonzero origin value, zero-count controls and the coarse published values for pairs 34 and 6709 pass. Deliberately wrong Taylor-factorial conversion, a perturbed decimal and a wrong pair index are rejected. The attached generator and checks reproduce the selection and numerical evidence.