Riemann xi pre-Schwarzian condition for strong Lehmer pairs

edit · history · discussion · files · long url · inequality L-function special values number theory
Numbers
$n$ 
$S_n$
1:
72.37117635013381936107069974639625031297070070143884614037831576703337216094487334410041714868364294
2:
29.03341248799999053922073754878605798807407692950960931790058804518414803281221633983360107586212066
3:
75.76042705297304402666285422272052350612920118486544816444794268440208248748394981175742535716491248
4:
17.94838043443182130113726194459682115442035244016216674891095107979011741376490493182858724879011509
5:
55.35411916292479188437160388842759444013856698309581197309884931287282938606649896820464705213779254
6:
36.75822519497929241471523005866981715857112989025515994221123218002541103937419270538403965575381360
7:
17.97220286786671840776760074047740825033892700906571658725402764047953895531781679139662871076996973
8:
92.21597118556789067094164932917324089772196316705941661451503682729740085212588736496008478517108372
9:
15.02681845222272269823953783256648894645606547591346284022683897314069341477801256484313305804869416
10:
33.50093083709722933825410090347384331973967220734449172916603018793778198109185423818840250339044241
11:
40.45588376190439189511572185965744375784329395630807531534365207053987273598250702433993494019218881
12:
45.11940892004379808470106957050666819355358939820183659119999000694791612107295457067115016720745868
13:
12.23077864985111027879028811953275591813491974910305832889358218066158492236085307242237604937137291
14:
89.96727863208095345732608813289088457245834559991397689770955452453034095215436276961296323744625344
15:
19.57420685487232163118731164382252381638245143410357843584238075339209452772795472061737375878426013
16:
25.70844917335560073366282293715310612727588452579620772491381128438388852172991337159012838625715806
17:
23.10809278469251352087581655116552751391470165016249830000231350164056466481565766785218080746250648
18:
77.74036858524075061128211522278621750275661110366378664631376353648904568494598810006016487731353766
19:
14.70155277166912221825027648423917446341170363591521453613303851420083153918195860945959365819608722
20:
22.17288416656612333121708347887296180211292037341278305761330015169350586003110784115165735239719696
21:
62.01506041582173624451575832666160576652597927906227359007981999594290887525952450136141885865588365
22:
18.28558537094932866921161483977047439114284758810612611612108108235743830281092522033839572637414894
23:
45.52848233533101963621657256525711370279942291528876156991908431852307287995638053208221753630717648
24:
12.31596686947695678801274775671508422026151098813118050752574588447030715275754778282569332326310693
25:
74.13768993857245351440826295282555379652310790082708916032518207597304830634196494773817103667018928
26:
36.48077407250088020723167754961533675182520994038517567986438235971570133289099955549973792031881064
27:
11.95491999141524494730312349700059508066358624289203138065607559955164725085277753116742414022387715
28:
47.13398707364089864493965062569688800993468438434508728464577866386990644643717244813798714980152677
29:
29.16102951913837658609098669276513639493850863928001224053287860130796060721602491543169029850679289
30:
34.69209877403632693201415498285624850183107279366399178969098465936873750502898623949636761022158891
31:
19.93398504462587886731841406588223668897743429843566410493816458383238711511574361498269676144051035
32:
16.04418576959169998008153639467713080722724839760014912719688129655817235169621314410515067624273365
33:
169.5136094769074703190011729750820617283935593263247157721636094928555412082258342379013751854586221
34:
10.50257308570272202432661825569219395554141008866130761495002069174760941723719972296952711821158090
35:
50.01008863620108532820926700920477272214810498083677591122566993339332425881801844787421002221420846
36:
19.04150493441370062181778823128864483791720678014087250659754025783422153313977667249002231457929462
37:
31.54138483669372145052691433083135502269771892508804060293426894765308944137277753374849439957157511
38:
44.08154537763384793119173762023767978863873678934122489501550391481353495337776383531093877287072622
39:
21.76938987818142705233814254830655574253209191705356804306269325730020938882224185434269016750820055
40:
13.04702413683212432444213470422688506659348785225827925269626284371989721788764329826189892685089416
41:
64.83849402416866238810260432627991830133337074471526447911427613528230355704868715737968761817688927
42:
30.28173886612896041104758290144138787510782670874492940552595014131854420014274180167822680891256239
43:
16.18569900538577209164644281353915149892296194562095442886485415095441253187381113033778702400833096
44:
44.31835809714004591050243420686641015515783653055270159152273218129801261447322659042063913007350382
45:
12.19260958952863064728270776892218528895080208553079324844140115319163062474604533151808926645089954
46:
83.14409217072701749417718112360511346902952450107111809137511029402694453212526209220699410957940151
47:
23.39052486527664169870444927393450457745511471984135773798026468287759595568456954562878056225126803
48:
15.64461606882950706638062142366625585221891901290520652119531869868447304149039777949111166601523847
49:
23.02528321394495959532900139263312451412734691302638120919051825981203403307686780075669475972117979
50:
56.40039683884986544445296506511693162705018423652587250950056256068070388945787409709950146759752468
51:
15.29594876038805753200053069814443990038802780512075220713773892831288406827837666995268803822202159
52:
80.43019907754051742744085052759239128079236442022628866944484763357938718919499524242104263283176253
53:
10.70684240483665333436353866454698911112515511389050535126529855762927250240593227929060546569555908
54:
34.88063172651810518337058522143484046611221719041327593438961837815428747783776826310177597901873520
55:
68.16601229404053519891390875085721418014129810781447329971884909789555185444098584303217235688263832
56:
22.34593981827713623885015011333102913715157110209118455381257337245005905524065235202254696984818322
57:
14.03333242063668669539211481854327377976398230246985175847795673973028531332509663155375867187533684
58:
37.17672224713861031831729892328706890672290947968812583653654183696358442472904552517446053051210259
59:
19.78884331279975497814280749601088479623746168312422882822098716414244606181029009051849608251292748
60:
42.08145796571207386259109822609394405976105229883719889969289336491866398330812854581164912465997135
61:
21.18633369199479886261955109554162075478776268558516661398973578526311113174240404568626636599666819
62:
44.87065548923419110932671629650977565010547624019497416664810235927530538475374562006164694865782138
63:
9.854734877727697550192782501545560816032606119852147904322300124733699331690023557611826176314959782
64:
141.0394072279144840883828864477697019694059423499619594304603000101068605173516410824253079517903070
65:
17.15029908733273408851468721722820084883922014770661213400755180439884414385932349320158910233091267
66:
22.04753301385343243958828588296049508952741051507783399918156438230942720594812033337940525182104819
67:
27.69208765674935674846820389373848787509995267777907528027761118483756232514687472092928097636603317
68:
16.52291798346472133057011165560612118200985456217771166464493759944563124446220175417131459071387821
69:
30.53730828807626879329212874433406070132400870885139178439298028758614041264376484537379213298643486
70:
107.2900477204351148959679280802489798374965638871159596187024390022813469305131855721846791766990121
71:
10.65769490845690429733102173936261434924211629856543281277637578227001961796709571550097675651488443
72:
29.76085095528279114251485803902255002904943098559087997933054296495135523046025489350298181315433939
73:
28.00679668086018090805275370619266778157799708487378198884014204976498270822913892201995033342650855
74:
64.41862401464835040988576629460774191746006214499716557921703510298673231842815590764053156589155497
75:
12.59086702805045390022776867186117111318032618341441587823771324842549829902808117540875584069049125
76:
41.69205889288545451895420684004143178638806602690583760637688196414842507149734662465057093934752214
77:
25.15745144759376029760348575244171002301297013799050841119624218969849774013230227367234022141255325
78:
12.19243006648264524910891754582035067050449894828475718785966646840316480520211178114713913005986994
79:
105.1752159699512580813753218250517125380653380297865103721038449278987492346659125673397157683138783
80:
16.30563234103393541960341655453159561525250302801354299247107459874685490964224062356373921173196936
81:
28.85286840247709648215784625586006672683106177230920521699511022080975601418820175367714631676968355
82:
13.27454137753421047285949776796086451735846628603142784273901765722529322001260282856221415610115682
83:
47.66115508533018473426954109295170883522571777474400730104676227319346467700361647065305425914881662
84:
19.74896503489003674087823827736599689168302061169591902521478602151713082242684150369554252402854988
85:
34.24737629160973892045432356206289662050438051230065599880469886485240221538630726332559434523062444
86:
27.59366133492254358731220640999130861253847610999204539104429409888044068860835950569900725293946998
87:
14.88834070520303509997463681748844865234344229267310768347040488309503138524025585718652236467857567
88:
19.67985053016057033369709333429010150224642069099374956741665153029251522074605082482543298295156885
89:
64.65404887245841316861807001241342350892479567528025554935484782769002189258250397160493124423195128
90:
43.97386813922862546007468936836687714256070062328992299706556684695898488731334564916019605507764798
91:
9.970378290761823105158187903403375173061976826378927841661864413698354911198347312573916040522345486
92:
99.88291934638887136019809391149825470162590571342567137084705768301904203564991101537269927350611453
93:
11.28658878681093416902733836967061154116827674127771739316744746550129490704894268063780647419055763
94:
49.40446945865242285473414144051741691547035994947446834908705258846547898127067370937186092296641490
95:
27.53743502139776597021892249091179058696195147770301283543200142373282727942787955914224886023547758
96:
56.20301799200338885066935205401260237283639579744040802643937635452565025409588614333879293682185391
97:
10.48592079172926556196233232233147477858800244118794453171326408414527396315803077446046181598905975
98:
31.88266690142640071194989376141306275184267675201937646900266288798426111750883771087031379362076580
99:
69.86146240176259749731526320771939411542979211777127599579748590626974701370850471031310506942445771
100:
15.94003328829732689226308316339658807068812466385638842729530256127519174510381393906166929783322527
6707:
102.3510409451831121676329228069431304289270827213856378656622824935148816778465293312129011038476116
6708:
2941.831715741986584561787860319632051694078965480289160902254422533162779868912617707669510473090186
6709:
8.013874657211648655900894717314645028439778305790588998629955019733917878098203851538218378688515500
6710:
7596.579892852209821045540740024950039913212255489576318893075354460446540687971432157373062853785835
6711:
51.09235562551568229809821703694967153474793403900709196423734158631433464113085770988394683653655233
Definition
The table holds $S_n=\Delta_n^2(-Q_\Xi(\gamma_n)-Q_\Xi(\gamma_{n+1}))$, where $\gamma_n,\gamma_{n+1}$ are consecutive positive simple zeros of $\Xi(t)=\xi(1/2+it)$, $\Delta_n=\gamma_{n+1}-\gamma_n$, and $Q_f(t)=(f^{\prime\prime}/f^{\prime})^{\prime}(t)=f^{\prime\prime\prime}(t)/f^{\prime}(t)-(f^{\prime\prime}(t)/f^{\prime}(t))^2$ [1], equation (9).
Parameters
$n$
—   lower positive zero index ($n\geq1$, with both $\gamma_n$ and $\gamma_{n+1}$ simple.)
Formulas
(1)
$S_n=\Delta_n^2\displaystyle\sum_{t\in\{\gamma_n,\gamma_{n+1}\}}\left[-\frac{\Xi^{\prime\prime\prime}(t)}{\Xi^{\prime}(t)}+\left(\frac{\Xi^{\prime\prime}(t)}{\Xi^{\prime}(t)}\right)^2\right]$ [1].
(2)
Write $Z(t)=e^{i\theta(t)}\zeta(1/2+it)$, with $\theta(t)=\operatorname{Im}\log\Gamma(1/4+it/2)-(t/2)\log\pi$, using the analytic log-gamma branch real at $1/4$. Then $\Xi(t)=a(t)Z(t)$, where $a(t)=-\tfrac12(t^2+1/4)\pi^{-1/4}|\Gamma(1/4+it/2)|$. If $\ell=a^{\prime}/a$ and $r=Z^{\prime\prime}/Z^{\prime}$, product differentiation at a simple zero gives $-Q_\Xi=-Q_Z+\ell r-3\ell^{\prime}+\ell^2$. Thus the xi condition is not a fixed rescaling of the Hardy Z pre-Schwarzian condition.
Comments
(3)
The Riemann xi function is $\xi(s)=\tfrac12s(s-1)\pi^{-s/2}\Gamma(s/2)\zeta(s)$ [1], §2. All derivatives of $\Xi$ and $Q_\Xi$ are with respect to the real height $t$. The ordinates $\gamma_n$ enumerate the positive real zeros of $\Xi$, counted with multiplicity from one; see the nontrivial zeta-zero ordinates. The finite range computed here has certified agreement with the usual nontrivial-zero numbering, without assuming RH.
(4)
Under the Riemann Hypothesis, Stopple calls the pair strong when $S_n<42/5$ and proves that this condition implies it is a Lehmer pair [1], §4, Theorem 1. The same expression is restated in [2], §4. The table stores the left-hand side for every selected pair, including failures of the inequality. Its finite numerical definition requires only the selected simple zeros; it does not establish RH or a value of the de Bruijn–Newman constant.
(5)
Stopple writes $Pf=f^{\prime\prime}/f^{\prime}$ and $Pf^{\prime}=(f^{\prime\prime}/f^{\prime})^{\prime}$, with $P$ taking priority over the prime [1], §4. Here $Q_f$ makes this derivative explicit.
Programs
(P1)
Python
import mpmath as mp
mp.mp.dps = 165

def minus_q(t):
    s = mp.mpf(1)/2 + mp.j*t
    d1, d2, d3 = [mp.zeta(s, derivative=k) for k in (1, 2, 3)]
    u = 1/s + 1/(s-1) - mp.log(mp.pi)/2 + mp.digamma(s/2)/2
    up = -1/s**2 - 1/(s-1)**2 + mp.polygamma(1, s/2)/4
    v, w = d2/d1, d3/d1
    return w - v*v - u*v + 3*up - u*u

def strong_pair_lhs(n):
    a, b = [mp.im(mp.zetazero(k)) for k in (n, n+1)]
    s = (b-a)**2 * (minus_q(a)+minus_q(b))
    assert abs(mp.im(s)) < mp.mpf('1e-140')
    return mp.re(s)

print(mp.nstr(strong_pair_lhs(101), 100))
# Approximation only; this program supplies no rigorous error bound.
References
[1]
J. Stopple, Lehmer pairs revisited, Experimental Mathematics 26 (2017), 45–53. (arXiv)
[2]
A. Simonič, Lehmer pairs and derivatives of Hardy’s Z-function, Journal of Number Theory 189 (2018), 451–460. (arXiv)
Links
Similar tables
Zeros of the Riemann zeta function —   The indexed zero ordinates determine the adjacent pair and its gap.
Hardy Z-function derivatives at Riemann zeta zeros —   Signed height derivatives combine with the gamma envelope to compute the xi derivative ratios.
Zeros of derivatives of the Riemann xi function —   Roots of xi derivatives, rather than derivative ratios evaluated at zeta zeros.
Hardy Z derivative condition for Lehmer pairs —   A different published sufficient condition on the same selected adjacent pairs.
Hardy Z pre-Schwarzian condition for Lehmer pairs —   The corresponding Hardy Z condition differs by explicit gamma-envelope and signed derivative-ratio terms.
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
digits: 100 (Unknown key)
Table is complete: no (contains $n=1,\ldots,100$ and $n=6707,\ldots,6711$: a consecutive low-zero reference prefix, the published first and historical examples $n=34,6709$, and the noncanonical exploratory window of two neighboring gaps on each side of the historical example; the prefix cutoff is practical, and every selected pair is retained regardless of the inequality)
How they were obtained:

FLINT's certified numbered zeta-zero enclosures [4] and Hardy Z Taylor jets [3] are evaluated at 533 working bits. The entire root enclosure propagates through the first three signed height derivatives, the gamma-envelope logarithmic derivatives, the gap and both ratios. Taylor coefficient $k$ is multiplied by $k!$. Both $Z^{\prime}$ and $\Xi^{\prime}=aZ^{\prime}$ exclude zero at every selected endpoint. All 105 outputs are finite and retain at least 504 relative accuracy bits. Each stored 100-significant-digit decimal interval contains both the 533-bit ball and its 599-bit recomputation.

more

The finite-indexing input retains 6712 certified, distinct critical-line root enclosures from a preceding computation, with its source hashes and provenance in the attached finite-prefix-origin.json. This build checks their ordering, all 107 selected endpoint overlaps, counts immediately before and after those endpoints, and the total count $N(T)=6712$ at an exact rational height $T$ between roots 6712 and 6713 [5]. Since $N(T)$ counts all nontrivial zeros with positive ordinate at most $T$, with multiplicity, these inputs exhaust that finite range and establish simplicity and numbering without assuming RH. The input computation is shared; a companion table is not an independent numerical oracle.

All 105 values lie inside their stored intervals when checked with the independent mpmath zeta derivatives and gamma logarithmic derivatives at 130 and 165 decimal digits [6]. The check differentiates $\xi=h\zeta$ in the complex variable $s$, using the full factor $h(s)=\tfrac12s(s-1)\pi^{-s/2}\Gamma(s/2)$, and explicitly bounds the numerical imaginary discrepancy. It uses mpmath root refinement seeded from certified root centers, so the finite-indexing inputs are shared.

A second derivative construction uses Cauchy contour extraction on the analytic function $\Xi$, scaled by a fixed nonzero factor to avoid tiny gamma-envelope amplitudes. It checks $n=1,34,100,6707,6708,6709,6710,6711$ with 96 points at 130 digits and 128 points at 165 digits, radius $1/4$ in height. All 16 comparisons lie inside the stored intervals. These agreements supplement the ball bounds; the contour discretization is not asserted to be a rigorous remainder bound.

Exact polynomial controls give $8$ for $f(t)=t(t-1)$ and $82/9$ for $f(t)=t(t-1)(t-3)$ at the pair $0,1$. The gamma-envelope product rule is separately checked with an exact nonconstant polynomial envelope. Wrong Taylor factorials, a perturbed decimal and a wrong pair index are rejected. Attached executable checks and numerical evidence record the complete comparisons, finite radii, dependencies and selection.