Riemann zeta heat trace

edit · history · discussion · files · long url · integral L-function special values
Numbers
$\alpha$ 
$\Theta(\alpha)$
1/12:
0.6759991689275369994666266284707058891035934033050818276332688076913886846422977247618440532454170095
1/11:
0.5780948002492860744098014790379045554044888580099986045670331719643316902250460104299667180743858142
1/10:
0.4827198651879725016546241894200673935864148032125303666935060542433733545612698381318098156388674632
1/9:
0.3906569574987256343680303535121047499844702333549463132591495333651935170803725169631937588978563025
1/8:
0.3029831013138250443381928658347469557128850412202705657477735902548903249530552249421180445275525706
1/7:
0.2212162296132360775788261135523699938901410274650699522795793833536139292987687242134748699862829706
1/6:
0.1475349522309906597034186247318504739549738027246063791623106101702510854229009691435213747395837471
2/11:
0.1146561229546206934323594982892265792319906732912206071316777525080600005840753277611301108143038912
1/5:
0.08505044508701997131969096032919160396901277044597653053457795176017512606901016180997703429797962117
2/9:
0.05926897350790834622856877454242637007547114700115532451048519055364170457173717566132455319719456142
1/4:
0.03788152473231871455065827091952481508354364277596794328044330716993412434890726918242309089208966100
3/11:
0.02631568156776018114845523918264071302367423009548972130699949484603288435713548907127421897320617698
2/7:
0.02138098426300124917296999251939651017417035249999749403225187991598648737253928148335987962120842210
3/10:
0.01701979959858897196744236267053204729358731970168322548463301919730114261588361779437687464383004717
1/3:
0.01000346159248146852482689868986948527265586951702799464124516756449985361265702911984652331112302791
4/11:
0.006174472462102044535944635263926773861062879318780694328285426175350010892070731264583380675334915195
3/8:
0.005152982406659283512702726115835355926357909245739028385086454848235193595288862543072407198096761145
2/5:
0.003461927260988635997168435892710798093431502024831165285789713421772430644284464501254074150841806218
5/12:
0.002655734192998169642671431172642722431430832950076750694056955611769920372165250474893997373319678441
3/7:
0.002197636442145456396436499775562752150472776032832552274783356179727448473598238329611692868880337304
4/9:
0.001707365844080622757045583903462257911595663695748750674122645354492100492938736670987019293773292658
5/11:
0.001454007834820588048541164515131245297837901897059997846058267556152793497378198590087826010049962378
1/2:
0.0007057870829804345071576992598415224163519302652606462994984911942532207106033128184251843949787823177
6/11:
0.0003426130882940740906324232592331663620462250496840458637663361407911167117078215084182637907147779312
5/9:
0.0002917807985812951402028151349637427539985234886901606103855419461562218739159068536704644402835174753
4/7:
0.0002267016204117768387843082405651281263243819063672481676420780029221269202258012196299518893448197063
7/12:
0.0001876089341978680274988608278682604048202145957462631485136423045000573518535117383346052962131633592
3/5:
0.0001439370035669847136155629159393203512862621663549833152137734087093371062683647759111910331095403987
5/8:
0.00009672787311277777180250240296112423511868921015032345933284188692219659211677718745804935398182355996
7/11:
0.00008073983290812124400222850202709235908987244456246874874595051525988149693327543276041124640038294348
2/3:
0.00004987139306400156773714718878981170839817237436410381456379869168179654161418479761290337864926541919
7/10:
0.00002935566849105757818094146586025940347110843319698094888972684720077267926004824102347221024535923223
5/7:
0.00002339118726776695660800050502720843840490014763237758200410336479999157610642902650581789757478516266
8/11:
0.00001902741689997533346029597276647931898121077622107352397850624046745280009835356162086338137501266083
3/4:
0.00001325724031504615605694148027323927860232288754216057673257061467223933742280304877149336265490087108
7/9:
0.000008524204925786266175890528780269646483118608840881516415997264196141175915572847798045551980230208317
4/5:
0.000005987072448851344776194436646931439021725558612240419044740221469207420924697558280086551795784416153
9/11:
0.000004484078682996516917902492968593451327728722864867634544338219784568857041623067429306722919985233252
5/6:
0.000003524158963910855776969208384854747955476039768781800696394764254319760683827044794512611279097435263
6/7:
0.000002413549442654412649646502157499875624099816448992920275026672834686806643862115152348745440815546688
7/8:
0.000001817007570505925955869487824601992201084787697917806294826566754282693066684868529971817359195476684
8/9:
0.000001456991962749121030507747626790648520046298061864079348697295871120477007260384287404972121372233508
9/10:
0.000001221061371070863029777912070640274559101942121288397009133214037864838002448947693967950351323123402
10/11:
0.000001056736866070603613959985883406563017505013397040233473693595257122644599540924441433907852903996437
11/12:
9.368239775761834579008093420798242011759257521596192408773467622321747647447319500933225105492109934e-7
1:
2.490350842678986577425702029555339717424133765797410841449963887059476450492395562820404096968423152e-7
$\frac{\pi}{6}$:
0.0004849748370342046904716207067632468154846185294161444622400036456244264140421240015183370064206327301
$\frac{\pi}{5}$:
0.00009175670097147148537044691016675658357857825175295413480416584138703931230426792775201578010682496135
$\frac{\pi}{4}$:
0.000007551563131986056259271435299257354974311436585278341337235055279241042216038055864109428292479481004
$\frac{\pi}{3}$:
1.175905235154402526502985203836958092496389800383106427629281116026270114890828914351246278836167404e-7
$\frac{2\pi}{5}$:
4.209599591644702568979403910153998528491222584761482881446418598961127755232620840715669227896481612e-9
$\frac{\pi}{2}$:
2.851303760340005317152427648596873834830158275177547598357514146204469139624669270197846562735906768e-11
$\frac{3\pi}{5}$:
1.931284189145266779040674213003616952771735720113193932935463460502875498694997173178740276976002985e-13
$\frac{2\pi}{3}$:
6.913765586463626866388172136664175648720864274403592118282559919652918386410572978529446148873766177e-15
$\frac{3\pi}{4}$:
1.076589729551361489951852051487373610508867791572590522258314584914995934112153901925623314512572591e-16
$\frac{4\pi}{5}$:
8.860364360447289768506902298134464220820383110683073197214227102463012493851321222827988419603113045e-18
$\frac{5\pi}{6}$:
1.676431506507472453663205454670208612796222627229698090058563902937514089820515321624192172737139214e-18
$\pi$:
4.064966566863944717173600046932676743202752323387480846323085239376613130005237851327861930229483868e-22
$\frac{6\pi}{5}$:
1.864929309621244666054067332467127582005835329924949676293634017469945228615327974812068286557403746e-26
$\frac{5\pi}{4}$:
1.534842172106503207118517574619804280413922577074211338809807694112673727011135898500662946246202559e-27
$\frac{4\pi}{3}$:
2.390007729228436902943345709064207768250907501119427611202632288414846872124087508890098367852175796e-29
$\frac{3\pi}{2}$:
5.795227228877368376780704128502053807899341568259934434867388852487242475182859901772765827103919773e-33
$\frac{5\pi}{3}$:
1.405211298005456827876539495409324698057130815669709990665455067652883668323871794874461158337758449e-36
$2\pi$:
8.261976594860822568556210360970448207701516703089270390373095458364323371436259019260395759512685518e-44
$\frac{5\pi}{2}$:
1.177870246638304405744422842212894164895039651463712214685819113834266537284532476709629055813115018e-54
$3\pi$:
1.679232931716083109849058718479451688311208319561186395359452169556294622156567670070519663526817372e-65
$4\pi$:
3.413012862701401633136887812294598996115265472031365279192640631760643275481149824999003582758058783e-87
$5\pi$:
6.936891589578900256207834034816912265210778957047788998631867883755977090092075047373828600087019659e-109
$6\pi$:
1.409911619479895720147817349528903069548500657902489075470204616505614539560794045381542629953038330e-130
Definition
For $\alpha>0$, let $\Theta(\alpha)=\sum_{\xi(\rho)=0}\exp\!\left(\alpha(\rho-1/2)^2/(4\pi)\right)$, where $\xi(s)=\tfrac12s(s-1)\pi^{-s/2}\Gamma(s/2)\zeta(s)$ is the completed Riemann zeta function. The sum includes all its zeros with their multiplicities [2].
Parameters
$\alpha$
—   Gaussian width ($\alpha>0$)
Formulas
(1)
$\Theta(\alpha)=2e^{\alpha/(16\pi)}-A(\alpha)-P(\alpha)$, where $A(\alpha)=\alpha^{-1/2}\left(\log(4\pi)+\gamma_E+2\int_0^\infty(e^{-\pi x^2/\alpha}-e^{-x/2})\frac{e^{x/2}}{e^x-e^{-x}}\,dx\right)$ and $P(\alpha)=2\alpha^{-1/2}\sum_{n\ge2}\frac{\Lambda(n)}{\sqrt n}e^{-\pi(\log n)^2/\alpha}$. Here $\gamma_E$ is Euler’s constant and $\Lambda(p^k)=\log p$ for prime $p$ and integer $k\ge1$, with $\Lambda(n)=0$ otherwise. The integral’s integrand has removable value $1/4$ at $x=0$. This Gaussian specialization follows from [2], equation (3.3), with heat scaling as in [1], equations (13)–(15) and (25).
Comments
(2)
The defining sum converges absolutely and is real by conjugation symmetry. It includes both signs of the imaginary part of each nontrivial zeta zero; trivial zeta zeros and poles are excluded by the completion.
(3)
With $\widehat\phi(y)=\int_{\mathbb R}\phi(x)e^{-2\pi ixy}\,dx$, the Gaussian $\phi_\alpha(x)=\alpha^{-1/2}e^{-\pi x^2/\alpha}$ has transform $e^{-\pi\alpha y^2}$. The ordinary heat time is $t=\alpha/(4\pi)$; $\alpha=1$ is the self-dual Gaussian [1]. This self-duality concerns the Gaussian, not an asserted identity $\Theta(\alpha)=\Theta(1/\alpha)$.
(4)
Under the Riemann hypothesis, $\Theta(\alpha)=2\sum_{n\ge1}e^{-\alpha\gamma_n^2/(4\pi)}$, where $\gamma_n>0$ are the ordinates in Zeros of the Riemann zeta function. This identity with real ordinates is conditional; the defining complex-zero sum and the prime formula are unconditional. No unconditional self-adjoint spectral realization is asserted [1] [2].
(5)
The function is defined for every positive real width. The entries cover two finite reference selections: short rational Gaussian widths $\alpha=a/b$, and short rational multiples $\alpha=(a/b)\pi$, which give rational heat times $t=a/(4b)$. The second selection is motivated by the ordinary heat-time convention, not by rational angles [1]. Both height cutoffs are noncanonical exploratory choices; neither selection exhausts the domain. The Gaussian satisfies the weighted integrability and variation conditions of the Weil explicit formula [3].
Programs
(P1)
Sage
import numberdb.sage as numberdb
from generate import HeatTrace
trace = HeatTrace()
trace.value({'alpha': '1/13'}, 100)
trace.value({'alpha': 'pi/3'}, 100)
[(params, trace.value(params, 100)) for params in trace.enumerate()]
References
[1]
A. Connes, Heat expansion and zeta (2024), arXiv version 1, Sections 2-4, equations (13)-(15), (17) and (25). (arXiv)
[2]
M. Suzuki, On the Hilbert space derived from the Weil distribution, Canadian Journal of Mathematics (published online 2025), Section 3.1, equation (3.3). See [6].
[3]
H. L. Montgomery and R. C. Vaughan, Multiplicative Number Theory I: Classical Theory, Cambridge University Press (2007), Theorem 12.13, pp. 410-411. See [7].
[4]
E. Hasanalizade, Q. Shen and P.-J. Wong, Counting zeros of the Riemann zeta function, Journal of Number Theory 235 (2022), 219-241, Corollary 1.2, equation (1.5). (arXiv) (doi)
Links
Similar tables
Zeros of the Riemann zeta function —   Positive ordinates of the zeros used in the conditional real-ordinate heat sum and in finite certified controls.
Reciprocal-zero moments of the completed zeta function —   The reciprocal moments are a different transform of the same nontrivial zero divisor.
Keiper-Li coefficients —   The Li coefficients are another transform of the same nontrivial zero divisor.
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
Table is complete: no (it contains all 46 reduced rational widths $\alpha=a/b$ with $1\le a\le b\le12$, and all 23 widths $\alpha=(a/b)\pi$ with coprime $1\le a,b\le6$. The first selection retains the self-dual Gaussian width $1$ and the original smaller widths $1/12\le\alpha\le1$; the second gives short rational heat times $t=a/(4b)$ and covers $\pi/6\le\alpha\le6\pi$, including $\pi$, $2\pi$ and $4\pi$. The height bounds are noncanonical reference cutoffs, not a claim that other positive arguments are less meaningful)
How they were obtained:

The attached generator uses Sage 10.9 and FLINT 3.4.0 ball arithmetic at 512 bits. For the 46 retained rational widths it evaluates the unconditional prime/archimedean formula, including prime powers, rigorous quadrature with an analytically removed endpoint singularity, and explicit integral and prime tails. All original decimal strings are retained and checked against the recomputation.

more

For the 23 rational multiples of $\pi$, it uses 138 rigorously isolated and consecutively counted zeros below height $T=300$, with the next zero above $300$ [5]. For $\alpha=q\pi$, the heat time $t=q/4$ is evaluated as an exact rational. The critical strip and the zero-count estimate of [4] give the unconditional two-sided tail bound $2e^{t/4-tT^2}(T^2+1/t)$: use $N(u)\le u^2$ for $u\ge T$ and integrate by parts. This bound includes possible off-critical-line zeros above the certified prefix. No global RH is assumed. Input, finite-zero and rounding errors are propagated.

All 69 enclosures support more than 135 significant decimal digits before conversion to 100-significant-digit decimal intervals. The zero-based checker validates all 69 stored intervals; this is independent mathematics for the prime-generated rational slice, but not for the new zero-generated slice. For the latter, check_pi_values.py independently recomputes all 23 values using mpmath at 160 and 200 decimal digits and the 29 zeros below $100$; this supplies an agreement check, not a second certification. The prime formula also cross-checks $\pi/6$, $\pi/3$ and $\pi/2$. All new arguments and three old checkpoints are recomputed at 640 bits. Known-answer, wrong-normalization and missing-multiplicity controls are included. The two certified routes share Arb/FLINT; the mpmath check does not. See numerical-evidence.md and the attached executable checks for exact scope, bounds and limitations.