Two-loop sunrise integrals with arbitrary masses

edit · history · discussion · files · long url · Feynman integrals integral period physics special values
Numbers
$a$, $b$, $c$
$t$ 
$S(a,b,c;t)$
1, 1, 1
0:
2.343907238689458890601562288872277069095403009635856260666300188900660953954854654278608712496629583
1, 1, 1
1:
2.467401100272339654708622749969037783828424851810197656603337344055011205604801310750443350929638058
1, 1, 2
0:
1.386294361119890618834464242916353136151000268720510508241360018986787243939389431211726653992837375
1, 1, 2
4:
1.571323728368605807321201028513058626218039832056353440709808420025516205925930154394775376527308807
1, 1, 3
0:
0.9587249911413924688537584035785543927079219013845477408409673868226408449803883394281759112562698549
1, 1, 3
1:
0.9766280161206078710839842870301154454564179206816067752776250787086087308145227726160869635402623263
1, 1, 3
9:
1.166018611220332787684781158681497404468964422655174403513143587748335540644068274652382944901402409
1, 2, 2
0:
0.8799990601213629784090979727477745779610236449833386502511579252623526507485034559819222176419295552
1, 2, 2
1:
0.8960773719037338473874217214559791576103850197538442158935289240294949996788711563556679744023292510
1, 2, 2
9:
1.065688552926572573780777416896579814150573869789675381795874636810065422728949602931280151061368817
1, 1, 4
0:
0.7177322730288830382289406414440649193198081131497280710510036894847847412484794393154601077317684169
1, 1, 4
4:
0.7576179854717349315332613277175941785186078664163304711487100813873793549295124106104610552097023953
1, 1, 4
16:
0.9307736455083348952052078634748854636795604585908392426215934595611762588213619249952829110914512180
1, 2, 3
0:
0.6365141682948128184504238226170746592638238015825792823209076606418985452388124898030402034827862971
1, 2, 3
4:
0.6708016745318262073904569125253827367019034963144889344974644229760575181062659960386173956255477679
1, 2, 3
16:
0.8188833135089303644366762545561107685061191091882401458432463676210582879570604000123882509214783706
1, 1, 5
0:
0.5646137464670656541023964538402965470795501673935187649479629594149258640111940318083193326237224943
1, 1, 5
9:
0.6203846620173181566370689786798841817619612163902815590032834542849923609264186234020863568213065086
1, 1, 5
25:
0.7760854740337936018736783705945365596609722126262604386733534035372610357271724570566947607742260131
1, 2, 4
0:
0.4918865030694889124562878766225952690995117892978263413315552477751099346803340154275054189243704719
1, 2, 4
1:
0.4965206819397021717428814556734732555941432519622372710583419470234556555615094557086884591171768648
1, 2, 4
9:
0.5387264794117737786761243382396080288292804295211512277387318960013533317293458512553850649766382994
1, 2, 4
25:
0.6685425960143726268833900303104607767241667407530263942703360559635007870108856828195184403954886079
1, 3, 3
0:
0.4744849303688661292142275283726935433702407688911217234941768212735532663346569872808687678042300631
1, 3, 3
1:
0.4789154556278936487876340079645277847499854785516240342224146416216719297591325991812459557183562967
1, 3, 3
25:
0.6430830062893280952003143688085664363983276144700466447174049060014367943028816747471742301991495418
2, 2, 3
0:
0.4378152284094220407947933186145902308809401487408503229506266124626956480860237419066276499072815951
2, 2, 3
1:
0.4418174768918031972288042332898792600665749903104255838519494803427351277648970501695054675420416979
2, 2, 3
9:
0.4782008355815966743927868333015323822487600659333237883572043717228772754157331118602144164811998778
1, 1, 6
0:
0.4596808354538913549818413725182176226439848207168913301571804808471873086597829594885164648768495052
1, 1, 6
16:
0.5260007967714658026021467165776524654672833952606698561264125922214193733523778802230463864299606058
1, 1, 6
36:
0.6662587180267054579955049341816050752328903589410057178747899733138451739170619514539376921923144165
1, 2, 5
0:
0.3963254839045058665247445215199895939069924513238121808847785289527656325283720341115863434876894646
1, 2, 5
4:
0.4082448251438841517010804260832289948497462498408613932191791880235453229901265789083955551518268611
1, 2, 5
16:
0.4512423198377271531663812045484450361451379203203784826030811147520560394240473728075620806735762935
1, 2, 5
36:
0.5663212299375076855535351360707176388650105207330489552030288813096949903720000667148792412100384950
1, 3, 4
0:
0.3748900964125389001920202101496392384435882335689656129602261791724443493502884707043432252550255390
1, 3, 4
4:
0.3860090238451598148351954141779946217669097556212340128783943062102156353466569722803679482824811537
1, 3, 4
36:
0.5329979522370618478068873067256530354912326149366336055475372564815702205619159797244938796354814345
2, 3, 3
0:
0.3346367173485931716353898458055585447213831750227144056474945470300802719170443737467496014739080756
2, 3, 3
4:
0.3442661978425165438434207500214802123607148846700754305105747429621264597858673250566000338286794749
2, 3, 3
16:
0.3788727222092728294846824275993907880295172611511207125099475435563616939266911247742778834555914877
1, 1, 7
0:
0.3838651630341668175911536638422855381521405523561079615235747631476967930533250043237095231917634729
1, 1, 7
25:
0.4569617414211449584118274336300090378316014738133582848819967884803145919059285854887230453261763883
1, 1, 7
49:
0.5840902517203749482224256882200987007020852066375679914044410414538820311462815434562314604429356936
1, 2, 6
0:
0.3288104873095598955853550550483877982404563011377799455453767762073872227058626781135028681763791612
1, 2, 6
9:
0.3472369680030313517412885380232487673723361143433443127984315367977791151945895784318215209654603917
1, 2, 6
25:
0.3887765434618647009692370026954996488153071876702268608507801375303325059897346895094959256495251814
1, 2, 6
49:
0.4919376811663723596416539985995841848050148039253345776542333337616663203156014873017957532494889448
1, 3, 5
0:
0.3072892699717556942094840562710131748889810254424630623074013063402033879556823715095447607273200693
1, 3, 5
1:
0.3090465725114268284863978386714609363832266900516688064942443844127596077662678312716624447478858228
1, 3, 5
9:
0.3242163729863809771853722563553688444189647956942186368392683879801266180725239039916867340212798419
1, 3, 5
49:
0.4565579888852541836796517153927332473002907820146935137308551343424896991802515020423244022766845197
1, 4, 4
0:
0.3012127226162557252895516479122499369980931132775804491001058755347655310695400513117959736711171981
1, 4, 4
1:
0.3029269046278349321491035115096334282346519673142595856800752124663293439810387303799387643733678110
1, 4, 4
49:
0.4466375526442714961657311496746745263336299709567624671664555903786736266312492064289082395079185511
2, 2, 5
0:
0.2845385999082803170885939508535054619762978170903609427740220632824727780884900387540540538958340621
2, 2, 5
1:
0.2861328060480604419895387584433721800359284983732718252922874044225698619376190107174213074862755533
2, 2, 5
25:
0.3343315471951351558332832734705466810331497364482128646500293526535045353249525674800578075493590160
2, 3, 4
0:
0.2695163282078878083967015872405952869444328515486814984696062892146618671494314088009047198788387291
2, 3, 4
1:
0.2710057453838106726352608666186837983712384744237403421139996357980500419039560555694041362998005192
2, 3, 4
9:
0.2838469133297960661683817393923827705420905022503815725924575337827395257808250059934486966251496936
2, 3, 4
25:
0.3159699273021559310681092272436607599834559743578378160338335630848027342828009893499026573153194563
1, 1, 8
0:
0.3268908290834102634290170520760704708349219554779842625741596404200054026088427628435236818999307930
1, 1, 8
36:
0.4041941802746845385247403184975869569176655892546970079122955223516440741649717206939175032105351737
1, 1, 8
64:
0.5202215061901456915428572041349599088014229160336197922245350798954494735085160906182918563065095816
1, 2, 7
0:
0.2788203896768615725635268916734888989162287899277605349397069358095337922619845883092838655570969262
1, 2, 7
16:
0.3024371623071649075943765871649769648674454049385426981846683242303659023450964420867160455124029262
1, 2, 7
36:
0.3418270316119742744841645908446399131708361070776282040266934117615060953626271172609261370766306576
1, 2, 7
64:
0.4352250487824673140028382804187049215968686914033524586964674584077953449095337125641014594492570725
1, 3, 6
0:
0.2584808089849843113151439620071204641087017690946884251127304733030203234403657098291137443290024706
1, 3, 6
4:
0.2634067614484479916284471385983406398104301351777704433792338762833962313229136012210828209852830125
1, 3, 6
16:
0.2799510529531838915138801975509246674309847689354749908276164355274373257838751276561095093433657132
1, 3, 6
64:
0.4000120709762876610335590842330648194158360158713009390702118517102482240351753382025901828706954697
1, 4, 5
0:
0.2502012117690939397665939694465525653024005696460546576597799381423745962780731098303762774494548554
1, 4, 5
4:
0.2549314446584762053842207721498763613298358075511958267429826324777482644455843820416543138831651840
1, 4, 5
64:
0.3858133549405194478293138463972580305961891594055580607360276387348579864044455807069444701631513817
2, 3, 5
0:
0.2243372223364188119989064474964671965023023219435886497411864291647749876628714994212063648021242942
2, 3, 5
16:
0.2422629160308161015943575423983988611737660923471413443512330948593544719061962811219054746797973255
2, 3, 5
36:
0.2719362009448777547462647422059177871004090029422978906875860582915083750507240320448364185171059470
3, 3, 4
0:
0.2127251674195983003521424599858611479683408292192639631194595387369909154104319401893042136258920326
3, 3, 4
4:
0.2165774844042816272048142496440778858729461128394565366640535001314772149838383990167249461792443644
3, 3, 4
16:
0.2294806728574339883744511696803748922818033873494108744342101250571263782722247543205592139348982734
1, 1, 9
0:
0.2827496182742709677309478536562061957290596709836644645493121135921285493651348013353772807404517977
1, 1, 9
49:
0.3625120477553581094724054066365277466314168704214552106756001435790042653186387290786786564895022956
1, 1, 9
81:
0.4691085875683632339233696014845815418640415259707512231175193633440313202059941860894060178180275320
1, 2, 8
0:
0.2404876869631475146552003153171476484627580697043275450058017748114663496379954617664717399384261401
1, 2, 8
25:
0.2680851153231904950634821487267125946079085438164768648554923015484922550541732197858409054978286886
1, 2, 8
49:
0.3051939642690848834231700587898484086454725658335310066222897733184212400707289925342960397949328817
1, 2, 8
81:
0.3904769329495284454504932617604373237178911244848760181163177402329857353378220675192280431167157442
1, 3, 7
0:
0.2216892912887989499346137249638543068469661219030072997977595609367683403964795170706205219841483231
1, 3, 7
9:
0.2298108847731363680188988879848858440292399275816284039385529327160717197541103741493020478772386648
1, 3, 7
25:
0.2465917780078154405334456241378930429541375983063348017118170124736557562721177286569466691285990806
1, 3, 7
81:
0.3563260973439348919915602121816368351748602027903663921864266899692154278675508433807151256698962929
1, 4, 6
0:
0.2127579401676407277074959931868508839077283456454563103388626227004279469355920819735581034360444899
1, 4, 6
1:
0.2135776092282338844137437739392519556622537907463794828565592008410917352266516916788020656906197895
1, 4, 6
9:
0.2204733447808938018593157914855359889840518461543631184288945983867794149807882773540641334610283449
1, 4, 6
81:
0.3402894767483365176589506181775625920202575253248260527732365756618921254283967294784447626703809017
1, 5, 5
0:
0.2100681408920166783569762688953451548969947280528081293047102066767431861413798905867250579884323944
1, 5, 5
1:
0.2108749660751422600097707293930785538703977280978186239679815340847434465147480672434825795976292101
1, 5, 5
81:
0.3354842335879102088093553883037860201822753226095863085781857364364727721014087585204576424617153398
2, 2, 7
0:
0.2058220662469345366773935151824200078704513557731224789582783576055912667144112198130602685104770126
2, 2, 7
9:
0.2132112355478086044549452500238052719549707757315824240541258195918359837225632997159118002674287151
2, 2, 7
49:
0.2586910173920703685055467153809315821639672519838223529581342103269339174258113758777185768454422536
2, 3, 6
0:
0.1911130370799376052495001356912455366757789517472616316452921081310893741135102839944919700834928280
2, 3, 6
1:
0.1918286261614960070409879405322213161926674383883251367033218167647383724273608601908594218075429803
2, 3, 6
25:
0.2117134886929767814465785703760498533082372021398347500907505886992733311369787573245940635931087448
2, 3, 6
49:
0.2391568781700102650834219590475240291649203128294271394494660347460570364731401500190198159555052785
2, 4, 5
0:
0.1851174751415797359413708449619840550245155824027221494080737565403046431191606404381709120145320796
2, 4, 5
1:
0.1858051151026438055768845992007557624286996031832888724800663770202607767399149737852912802712917578
2, 4, 5
9:
0.1915849056802751874743246260857644659295825816295007468775338674169495299030198225194004678655650263
2, 4, 5
49:
0.2312311078261678163254325772970267405390685389632230194886611663131318361130544393987731454848685692
3, 3, 5
0:
0.1790984894929823421756357646543349854146278342397225812478214932078926293911166936031582231848998648
3, 3, 5
1:
0.1797580045290369711185310679860375990559229438351553814834695725501383121320351166098159817803191169
3, 3, 5
25:
0.1980636024694223810299259581603920962384795337888762347200399472111400499244216234262302446251061174
3, 4, 4
0:
0.1756990647720698536043839342176071714098336086417627068043063340215900719967706437840000003632570208
3, 4, 4
9:
0.1817528438546226207436526219811314050229340879522887349996794322853754893285754641378480112200414030
3, 4, 4
25:
0.1942075994543070622745980207469861211894073428549774394064589159494550095661208029036420759489167439
1, 1, 10
0:
0.2477059063177114237708957348324523318183758921326024256589945609455047879310937628924799369645913431
1, 1, 10
64:
0.3287305931326497493478912900113135349918547638915749592317304948173735707986771845872688662428973891
1, 1, 10
100:
0.4272517822244069441535129001364668347957069553633056670211373863512337544661937045677196946367990504
1, 2, 9
0:
0.2102808980289667408363359848031504963280112598708018528872704149983702928366444212045771158816115307
1, 2, 9
36:
0.2408752171085810300326653549477252744402959896042529682186854500906453806567655314455821458040067962
1, 2, 9
64:
0.2757817850771770125450116724211677515149992344561296997584722330808594385792398839347096490755986724
1, 2, 9
100:
0.3542261314582811750301562683571459407101201892948331604266218128610966485196474315106907663145498872
1, 3, 8
0:
0.1930502844228685811495398695686257279691409288040884048897545824125715548661466526194072590435525662
1, 3, 8
16:
0.2039974130153070519016289175023931391965426142309566575521426601339306379344208234576594073804908722
1, 3, 8
36:
0.2205036926959356024365794914168588230372042898559252226775171213305359485123992784609317578569386756
1, 3, 8
100:
0.3214807818692590451506192008345309930239253908474184087111237281778232340819681204805157516544566247
1, 4, 7
0:
0.1841381161536099857188047578308712049247829946515086667643680487235950961902490774931706713237231887
1, 4, 7
4:
0.1865720255699092062295651888089456884412484637591541564507746369630655667143048072893759302520654646
1, 4, 7
16:
0.1944569341028487910579837471244829411236355082996446435993948371015945571917909681835692813540833598
1, 4, 7
100:
0.3047741167123319697666585646855634411595064229359523898551613376450425031131686923815661479646114366
1, 5, 6
0:
0.1802244835465218754580711656102183625806624921170293083712671067609621701727688847817470066930004403
1, 5, 6
4:
0.1825942972488235698022002075640766771087149422212543899046472227147288198409418463527215798387426873
1, 5, 6
100:
0.2974885417968119285931774121511552736586353175506030475896189728725562176902472990077871223907791816
2, 3, 7
0:
0.1656745701260565111739724733185185147495828177554386670176437784647948408063032014911270392946055007
2, 3, 7
4:
0.1678033510666198402259557344744840264592359193667755824231698740710855629706266663169216863161015260
2, 3, 7
36:
0.1882394463280699263990546388185809491399233400081776010611009169074550860755532997226318646191626621
2, 3, 7
64:
0.2137027374371798933706698101817395971742591305934438077762859975627877403782278483551123510716128494
2, 5, 5
0:
0.1571558834210540144891652983791518945391682830025756211436601238501285867378816086346734126231226497
2, 5, 5
4:
0.1591486728593327751084412765232608757325352339138266666706381161574977057960076946700308626365685956
2, 5, 5
64:
0.2020211115204913133441843833240441805321633892685393797981874528881312954742167010022133693814558471
3, 4, 5
0:
0.1492823062077196569376094968116330492075970347669548947234669195351782302791671001507044487566987378
3, 4, 5
4:
0.1511497450082372440055637724190035176004901472681641030489713884692787249129975037375274603562127135
3, 4, 5
16:
0.1571872048415906821962345328387121894044225317836040198344613448900410990763316107732040677292255161
3, 4, 5
36:
0.1690362343797025502135838159630070783886554354336435459841937560158564589314372874455647276998003625
Definition
The scalar two-loop sunrise integral in two spacetime dimensions is $S(a,b,c;t)=\int_{x,y\geq0,\,x+y\leq1}\!\bigl[(a^2x+b^2y+c^2z)(xy+xz+yz)-txyz\bigr]^{-1}\,dx\,dy$, where $z=1-x-y$ [1].
Parameters
$a$
—   smallest internal mass ($a>0$)
$b$
—   middle internal mass ($a\leq b$)
$c$
—   largest internal mass ($b\leq c$)
$t$
—   Minkowski momentum squared ($0\leq t<(a+b+c)^2$)
Formulas
(1)
In the projective chart $z=1$, $S(a,b,c;t)=\int_0^\infty\!\int_0^\infty \bigl[(a^2x+b^2y+c^2)(xy+x+y)-txy\bigr]^{-1}\,dx\,dy$ [1].
(2)
The Bessel representation is $S(a,b,c;t)=4\int_0^\infty rI_0(\sqrt t\,r)K_0(ar)K_0(br)K_0(cr)\,dr$, where $I_0$ and $K_0$ are the standard order-zero modified Bessel functions on the positive real axis and $\sqrt t\geq0$ [3]. The factor four is part of the normalization.
(3)
For $\lambda>0$, $S(\lambda a,\lambda b,\lambda c;\lambda^2t)=\lambda^{-2}S(a,b,c;t)$. Permuting the three masses leaves $S$ unchanged.
(4)
The controls are $S(1,1,1;0)=3L(2,\chi_{-3})$ and $S(1,1,1;1)=\pi^2/4$ [2], where $\chi_{-3}(n)$ is $0,1,-1$ for $n\equiv0,1,2\pmod3$, respectively. Here $L(2,\chi_{-3})$ is in the Dirichlet $L$-value table and $\pi$ is in Pi.
(5)
Direct integration at the degenerate vacuum gives $S(1,1,2;0)=\int_0^\infty\log((x+4)(x+1)/x)/(x+2)^2\,dx=2\log2$.
Comments
(6)
The masses $a,b,c$ are measured in one fixed common unit; $t$ is measured in its square. Each propagator has power one and the source scale is $\mu=1$ in that unit. This is the positive Feynman normalization of [1], with no subtraction or finite part. The ordinary integral is finite and positive on the stated real subthreshold domain.
(7)
The vacuum is $t=0$. The three proper pseudothresholds are $(a+b-c)^2$, $(a-b+c)^2$ and $(-a+b+c)^2$; coincident values are listed once. The normal threshold $(a+b+c)^2$ is excluded [1]. A pseudothreshold is a degeneration of the graph curve, not a singularity of this positive integral in the stated domain [4].
(8)
The equal-mass specialization agrees with equal-mass banana Feynman integrals: $S(1,1,1;t)=F_3(t)$. Unequal masses change the graph polynomial and cannot be absorbed into one common rescaling.
(9)
The graph is also called the sunset diagram [5].
Programs
(P1)
Python
import mpmath as mp
mp.mp.dps = 60
a, b, c, t = map(mp.mpf, ('1', '2', '4', '9'))
def kernel(x):
    A = b*b*(x+1)
    B = (a*a*x+c*c)*(x+1)+(b*b-t)*x
    C = x*(a*a*x+c*c)
    D = B*B-4*A*C
    if D == 0:
        return 2/B
    if D > 0:
        q = mp.sqrt(D)
        return 2*mp.log((B+q)/(2*mp.sqrt(A*C)))/q
    q = mp.sqrt(-D)
    return 2*mp.atan2(q, B)/q
print(mp.quad(kernel, [0, 1, 4, 16, mp.inf]))
# Reference slice: primitive ordered integer masses a+b+c<=12,
# at vacuum and each distinct proper pseudothreshold square.
References
[1]
L. Adams, C. Bogner and S. Weinzierl, The two-loop sunrise graph in two space-time dimensions with arbitrary masses in terms of elliptic dilogarithms, Journal of Mathematical Physics 55 (2014), 102301, section 2, equations (1)–(9). (arXiv) (doi)
[2]
D. H. Bailey, J. M. Borwein, D. Broadhurst and M. L. Glasser, Elliptic integral evaluations of Bessel moments, Journal of Physics A 41 (2008), 205203, equations (62), (71) and (73). (arXiv) (doi)
[3]
S. Groote and J. G. Körner, Coordinate space calculation of two- and three-loop sunrise-type diagrams, elliptic functions and truncated Bessel integral identities (2018), equations (1)–(4) and section 4; convert Euclidean momentum squared to -t. (arXiv)
[4]
S. Bloch and P. Vanhove, The elliptic dilogarithm for the sunset graph, Journal of Number Theory 148 (2015), 328–364, sections 2–3. The graph definition and degeneration loci are used; the degenerate-vacuum prefactor in v2 HTML equation (3.13) is not used. (arXiv) (doi)
Links
Similar tables
Equal-mass banana Feynman integrals —   The n=3 positive Feynman specialization equals S(1,1,1;t).
Bessel moments —   The equal-mass vacuum and t=1 controls equal four times IKM(0,3;1) and IKM(1,3;1), respectively.
Values of modified Bessel functions of the first kind —   Its order-zero function I_0 is the momentum factor in the Bessel representation.
Values of modified Bessel functions of the second kind —   Its order-zero function K_0 supplies the three mass-dependent factors.
Values of Dirichlet L-functions at positive integers —   The equal-mass vacuum is three times L(2,chi_-3), at identity (3,2,2).
Pi —   The equal-mass pseudothreshold value is pi^2/4.
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
How well the digits are known: heuristic (agreement-checked)
How they were obtained:

The Feynman-parameter y integral is evaluated analytically, including its removable discriminant-zero limit; mpmath tanh-sinh quadrature evaluates the remaining x=q/(1-q) integral at 150 and 200 working decimal digits. All arguments are exact integers. The two results are combined with heuristic guard widths, retaining at least 138 relative decimal digits before serialization to 100 significant digits. This agreement does not certify the quadrature error.

more

An independent direct-r Bessel representation, including the factor four, checks all 147 values by Sage complex Arb quadrature with analytic branch guards and explicit small-r and large-r tail bounds. Its minimum measured relative accuracy is 185 bits (about 56 decimal digits); this is a lower precision independent check of the whole selection. A secondary parameter implementation checks all entries at 60 working digits and 25 entries at 135 digits, with shared analytic reduction and quadrature method. The secondary parameter implementation is a branch/implementation check, not a second mathematical representation.

Eight known-answer controls at 170 working digits use trigamma for the equal-mass vacuum, pi squared at the equal-mass pseudothreshold, and an independently derived elementary logarithmic formula for all six degenerate vacua. Wrong normalization, momentum sign, mass interpretation and scale invariance, as well as NaN and vacuous enclosures, are rejected. The actual source, two-precision results, checkpoints, independent Bessel checks, argument-selection rationale and matching archived skill manifest are attached. Stored decimal intervals are checked with their full last-place uncertainty.

Table is complete: no (it contains every primitive ordered positive integer mass triple with $a+b+c\leq12$, at $t\in\{0,(a+b-c)^2,(a-b+c)^2,(-a+b+c)^2\}$ with duplicates removed: 44 vacuum and 103 positive pseudothreshold values. The mass ratios form a noncanonical low-height exploratory reference slice covering strict, degenerate and hierarchical mass triangles; the momentum fibers are intrinsic. The natural masses and momentum are continuous.)