Primitive odd modular periods of rational newforms

edit · history · discussion · files · long url · period modular form special values number theory
Numbers
$N$
$k$
$i_f$ 
$\Omega_f^-$
1
12
1:
0.009269276162370163236258034682375285905979558317059194395401490580101129254144363605420065673501171098
1
16
1:
0.01640585888467851721123766833208653557171906647882108379462208025109547335082855407411659459500579777
1
18
1:
-0.1465501420696153409382759425664233885410238644564484270021367879263084754322735122919545166622371876
1
20
1:
0.2549699124513547901333530377648682817534291715074087374925433207735144815412842889626475172699039887
1
22
1:
-0.7346639014266298461367608272099292880078963300193670061450041183833839267331766631342411934235422498
1
26
1:
-40.08330038827614742356987433705108810172563849393776588276273939817998384028239117743043162530472466
3
12
1:
0.04068209863122682019754850689949569352922993064628087598310430674734537671552715833503997254996029836
4
12
1:
-0.03747662171648672949447448992411700799214041936966010133086612121332438690417220755062220235315570844
5
12
2:
-0.007710392255700993298839525696462083113263090783633198784572147529849156922574741535150572827792633560
6
12
1:
0.007314989827744873442591151403864367482505385125360370588554786756762641763468910567563437122174517370
6
12
2:
-0.03679487289368413884100651599675050189337020183421503513050896132141214786209693669936385979071220156
6
12
3:
0.007848130538430375931326254385114034889380739325313437476001410029165410081468703710628250248148919570
8
12
2:
-0.007558970210892552744244547473997386392732151230606089611086324061455085910226750250680000560721494431
9
12
1:
-0.01170467762916705766171065077770025579214167749799322643022828340971166819298754218545757205019116648
9
12
3:
-0.009662443075587115050686866527940989272720497819414552166220630893081136601514712288054667847246739779
10
12
1:
-0.03669371954548145417854182101817401000484040609752431452551576465089618591725024611380777982471279666
10
12
2:
0.001004037542353288068508238330198167269027640731192630888647654066129929235849255421470032950566855111
10
12
3:
-0.003529854969199241318203809014361043843471903993281613322508098812142147163021836953478948162509802659
Definition
For a normalized rational-coefficient newform $f=f_{N,k,i}$ of trivial character, the signed real primitive odd period $\Omega_f^-$ is defined by $r_f^-(X)=\Omega_f^-P_f^-(X)$, where $r_f^-$ is its odd period polynomial and $P_f^-\in\mathbb Z[X]$ is the proportional primitive polynomial with positive leading coefficient [1].
Parameters
$N$
—   exact level ($N\geq1$)
$k$
—   weight ($k\geq4$ is even and $S_k^{\mathrm{new}}(\Gamma_0(N))$ is nonzero)
$i_f$
—   embedded newform index ($1\leq i_f\leq\dim S_k^{\mathrm{new}}(\Gamma_0(N))$, ordered lexicographically by all real embedded Fourier sequences $(a_2,a_3,\ldots)$; the selected form has rational Hecke field and nonzero odd period polynomial)
Formulas
(1)
Let $L(f,s)$ be the analytic continuation of the arithmetic series $\sum_{n\geq1}a_n n^{-s}$, with no completion or conductor factor. For $w=k-2$ and odd $1\leq m\leq w-1$, $[X^{w-m}]r_f^-(X)=\binom wm i^{1-m}\frac{m!}{(2\pi)^{m+1}}L(f,m+1)$ [1], equation (5.7). Here $[X^j]$ denotes the coefficient of $X^j$, and $i^{1-m}=(-1)^{(m-1)/2}$ is real. Consequently $\Omega_f^-=(k-2)L(f,2)/((2\pi)^2[X^{k-3}]P_f^-)$ whenever that primitive coefficient is nonzero.
(2)
For the modular discriminant $\Delta=f_{1,12,1}$, $P_\Delta^-(X)=4X^9-25X^7+42X^5-25X^3+4X$ [2]. Thus $\Omega_\Delta^-=10L(\Delta,2)/(4(2\pi)^2)$; the level-one critical-value table stores the arithmetic L-value.
Comments
(3)
Write $f(\tau)=\sum_{n\geq1}a_n e^{2\pi i n\tau}$ with $a_1=1$, and set $w=k-2$. The identity-coset polynomial is $r_f(X)=\int_0^{i\infty} f(\tau)(\tau-X)^w\,d\tau$, on the upward path, and $r_f^-(X)=(r_f(X)-r_f(-X))/2$. Since $w$ is even, replacing $(\tau-X)^w$ by $(X-\tau)^w$ makes no change [2]. Here $i^2=-1$ denotes the imaginary unit, whereas $i_f$ displays the integer form index whose parameter key is $i$.
(4)
The polynomial $P_f^-$ is stored in Odd period polynomials of rational newforms. Its coefficient gcd is one and its leading coefficient is positive. All factors are retained, with no rescaling of $X$. Rationality and the real phase follow from [1], Proposition 5.11. These conditions fix the sign of $\Omega_f^-$; its absolute value is not substituted.
(5)
No conductor factor is inserted in the integral. A period called a Manin or Shimura period may use another rational scaling; the primitive polynomial here fixes the convention completely. The primitive even period, defined by $r_f^+(X)=i\Omega_f^+P_f^+(X)$ with the analogous primitive even polynomial $P_f^+$, is a separate scalar and does not determine this odd period.
(6)
The index is assigned among all real embeddings before restricting to rational Hecke fields, so gaps are retained. Exact coefficients through a Sturm bound identify and order the forms, rather than software orbit positions [2]. This is the indexing of the primitive odd polynomials; the attached roster records the exact field and Fourier data. At level one it agrees with the ordering of the critical L-values.
(7)
Only the identity-coset polynomial enters this normalization. At higher level a Petersson pairing requires the full coset-valued period data [1], Sections 2 and 3. This odd period alone does not determine a Petersson self-product.
Programs
(P1)
PARI/GP
default(realprecision,160);
f = mfDelta(); mf = mfinit(f,0);
P = mfperiodpol(mf,f,-1);
real(polcoef(P,9))/4  /* Omega^- for (N,k,i)=(1,12,1) */
References
[1]
V. Paşol and A. A. Popa, Modular forms and period polynomials (2013), version 5. (arXiv)
Links
Similar tables
Odd period polynomials of rational newforms —   It stores the exact primitive shape $P_f^-$; multiplying it by $\Omega_f^-$ gives the analytic odd period polynomial.
Primitive even modular periods of rational newforms —   It stores the independent signed even scale $\Omega_f^+$ and its path presentation, using the same form indices and primitive-polynomial normalization.
Special values of the L-functions of level one cusp forms —   Its even critical arithmetic L-values supply the odd period-polynomial coefficients for the level-one forms.
Critical L-values of higher-level newforms —   It uses the same arithmetic L-function normalization at higher level; its current weight selection differs from this one.
Petersson norms of level one cusp forms —   A Petersson self-product is related to a pairing of the even and odd periods, rather than to this odd scalar alone.
Petersson norms of higher-level newforms —   It records the integral and subgroup-index conventions for higher-level self-products; the pairing requires all coset period components.
Zeros of period polynomials of newforms —   For the shared rational-coefficient forms and the same $(N,k,i)$ indices, these are the zeros of $r_f(X)=i\Omega_f^+P_f^+(X)+\Omega_f^-P_f^-(X)$. Here $P_f^+$ and $P_f^-$ are the primitive even and odd shapes. This table restores the odd scale; together with the even scale and both shapes it fixes the relative parity scale omitted by primitive normalization. The zero table has broader coefficient-field coverage.
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
How well the digits are known: heuristic (agreement-checked)
Table is complete: no (it holds all 18 rational-Hecke-field newforms in two finite slices: $N=1$ at every nonempty even weight $k\leq26$ (weights 12, 16, 18, 20, 22 and 26), and $k=12$ at every exact level $2\leq N\leq10$ (twelve forms). These noncanonical bounds recover the missing analytic scales for the complete selected roster of primitive odd shapes, with prime, composite and nonsquarefree level breadth before extending weight. Every rational form in the slices is included with its index among all embeddings. Level 2 has no weight-12 newforms, level 7 has no rational ones, and the weight-24 level-one forms have a degree-two Hecke field. All selected odd parts are nonzero)
How they were obtained:

The 100 significant digits are obtained from PARI's direct odd period-polynomial evaluator at 160 and 220 decimal working digits, with 32 additional working bits, using an exact nonzero coefficient of the primitive shape. The two evaluations define an agreement interval. This is heuristic agreement, not a general certification of PARI's numerical algorithms [7]. Every odd coefficient is consistent with the same signed scale. Reality follows from the defining real Fourier coefficients and path.

more

Exact Sage modular symbols [3] reconstruct all 18 primitive polynomials and match the published shapes. Independent dimension formulas [5] agree in all 21 selected spaces, including empty spaces. Separate Sage and PARI newform constructions agree through the Sturm bounds on all 33 real embedded forms; the retained indices also match the companion roster. For each rational form, the first 600 Fourier coefficients agree exactly. An integer eta-product convolution checks the first 100 coefficients of Delta.

A separate split Mellin computation uses Sage Fourier coefficients, 450 terms at 150 decimal working digits and 600 terms at 190, with ball arithmetic and a Fourier-tail majorant from the normalized-newform coefficient bound [6], Theorem 2.6. The split point is $1/\sqrt N$. The exact Fricke eigenvalue is computed in Sage after dividing its modular-symbol operator by $N^{k/2-1}$ [4], and independently checked with PARI. Every odd coefficient, including forced zeros, is tested against the analytic moments. The stored decimal interval is tested for containment of each nonzero coefficient-derived scale; measured residuals and ball accuracy appear in the attached numerical evidence.

Three nonzero exponential-integral controls, Delta's primitive shape, and deliberately wrong signs and doubled scales test the checker. Nonfinite and excessively wide balls are rejected. The exact roster, executable generator and checks, numerical evidence, argument-selection rationale and coordinated skill manifest are attached. These calculations supply build evidence; independent scientific review is a separate step.