Zeros of derivatives of the Riemann xi function

edit · history · discussion · files · short url · zero L-function
Numbers
$m$
$k$ 
$t_{m,k}$
1
1:
15.58570858982934234459572923552235410570321084893045353723805970178742148874560382569883896278677304
1
2:
22.09797728040090209824605836528433679993218459704255414058463031056337135731248532678240397493680956
1
3:
26.27224735693562437507115403821538455995691887803697148592120502929936085201425946443776391721807822
1
4:
31.23179587100978550891189600646703417140536593022473472755783984375769116417820428150217351698588476
1
5:
34.19331026901138088072151793138329075129491964904604291990073019422451974705504138734815601770231590
1
6:
38.49824076375449072135717451690964015115751137830267043826301767907125747422096865850586962446437698
1
7:
41.73672952241933314273509812849828791761916312947317267211919225487452823424502791046713409634090437
1
8:
44.54170360738099662726923761731964939694854258554890507838410232819063579448117939160801789580613392
1
9:
48.62253268527786584681617292945052958076968355005144795280571686661624256038005257287055434112883925
1
10:
50.83900482281596978281790995688659667944335339478349205819391936324277918795757687653505864161294854
1
11:
53.96872885972243346611174133284769762468065042112049560261988846599545524281016422174743250710651836
1
12:
57.26293411133910251408412069419573547098975212942584327456375940683414017160515753872567406216102233
1
13:
59.93069897372584235218518816326236069053566036485946897616734073000188720660471259326048371089111155
1
14:
62.10990575087130718586589572782300483966502310648734033839511967146069675612628170369632003391603694
1
15:
65.75831930642373734408986067068295158293815601503590921652957475838007694841973969922002227510946018
1
16:
67.92645377105524394624710547909008160329530333868457059361542304154942802815727684620534258464888674
1
17:
70.41840714259490998141489950897364942167896315345379964003063684350507210664903282466001048514904526
1
18:
73.06054352107066754761797648591815997220127784593598763314070567800892844592345996382530003142203337
1
19:
76.22543797061206281267033792021836647585221099798658306128994013080206086277370668954165337433214258
1
20:
77.99787202509317479982068334176771918338446425317313826086398753317472444579812304639778895052035951
2
1:
4.750237876793571908645816574150144401286015376925623929915959848149605770442496128296831272114435968
2
2:
17.03380144196064931975965889881619779875560085745848088850952680641716457676801278438258032417854569
2
3:
23.21376745968233030597151059528989374009165210880031476025897038466493676343015999279972631776616429
2
4:
27.49263058560298204532292593877781162526235531711116863218553464685063923209206008062283608215047738
2
5:
32.13292897662641905981080585719620108315617778383065021644874260872738539517395598969394600120743532
2
6:
35.36822799411390223140330051220604134445802533554612609977044025053180814015417402724000156713050956
2
7:
39.42051105772977734217144982817665043228490995412094462739691918204434298406057617253151333941484880
2
8:
42.63810100821686655387520150653039107785680382655618518176001421764224805057377648349936922991550588
2
9:
45.64947457108094328488226727117254200835009913825531974265681203402108384029722022956788370986522939
2
10:
49.35249438479285297070407182614452437633437970399933650149326664499972286183543951269746800849038872
2
11:
51.84655633426521561157156833914058713792463489899659464329554402697336594324343654497470934860314679
2
12:
54.93212803767992536364731054034996192401395306206541944301411011981222637092146708022774141178520355
2
13:
58.07560370906680580447156763935712216522457651491853052730419295021589288304326754607815382222069443
2
14:
60.70279469612037517077582847944476894555785821181709487895923752189558958370261937378312052190911023
2
15:
63.18796154485931804724604764727420206046849735203068929792767257718461059034443147150047863900859370
2
16:
66.46351352533838675575619201071633286279289580097953160976510029170348521035952901229371150514040089
2
17:
68.77270169401198872919581834110085440180310181686559920936167992084586439454375944482294010554540292
2
18:
71.30233974149441328988754761191814584765031080025499939134309789456518146980596092814101820124781174
2
19:
73.97922443826871861887046007583422699322531451217089896092823431729919534539206024308757004123076529
2
20:
76.84736389203887741456986381535909655253412979315256564623896764032404307927142843157790841356765443
3
1:
8.260708951212404934079462435866324976135610833635641427153855091074054205558289592947944484317506244
3
2:
18.47776275057742445834955082824040330531732389179975957949609419620202315362936225020671588902909453
3
3:
24.35935899825033908110639129881571855935987763528687501319924834061777144007514013344278681818017443
3
4:
28.68406064643707593580037788492777877842466349457718683986688950715451707581988431916183904449233548
3
5:
33.09244450635743355768706004451284887993209287782102385709902531566115796795413991053346922368759722
3
6:
36.49310221016200979688171658296729540754511379261415302798209277368857643624307948328517337306234578
3
7:
40.35731091503940060741051987916191164352501420331954544379553849500733562927459575228285838828498049
3
8:
43.57907942694141960145802557719748050941990762043114821686764722869661613280172000816590648395435883
3
9:
46.69433848897968612966710645476764104484489355714141614794654148063355771407348081701214859232504632
3
10:
50.15261820194628436691904263948677640963552358723010378112426475445435884080237817076594580603112764
3
11:
52.82379602572656470977211719955507135838099252461659282313235037227356853645516347625950725962387577
3
12:
55.87041539380034348405301540227572379523637193107346839742236696877191421348488767835239809918140384
3
13:
58.90001952978890177068779490615046559308271234763068407321642587348492117255930289485217968409121346
3
14:
61.54344696501259955937576754827288471807467296299456062205515491145258714301676145064397975142836703
3
15:
64.17472052511577391101355215176109017284067308122656107428042433340716470200340715292339743505867911
3
16:
67.21376872258563019266260046377763341364543925508896215968623574899459423217447216932018279623614516
3
17:
69.62258220960648473663746492386689424363246588996388389913027360056714376810258653559387928576844614
3
18:
72.18217276270815872849425545560390443283727199032580233279617005030993630908884391447750748185947387
3
19:
74.85213110214703787759136914006406278169749534831116958282046070981963403355923014666862254761959986
3
20:
77.54375805979957850775445129681402207591807254303669342592856059801315522728033454340017338204419378
4
1:
3.651773759322939526285174468336150993002161190118741458990244873786951198222635561663576337135679184
4
2:
11.15049918430823340178425275150502662358419060596125694538873553873428444720135624004832982280203750
4
3:
19.91588790214742389887245853354152730411501563197840995485235284967970426147876470730395199836384509
4
4:
25.52724259691703110735956674711400729229995769834375578360858042340206872688029970963778390725371095
4
5:
29.85529977611256084563383086067786010918524755224531551776253747914756896766705703420015903185877327
4
6:
34.09063290403421850665619401561561388836219175876376804574898882364012781925647799279772587952786434
4
7:
37.58562148072794679428878727979641794901170888336223961375424850540276669378818074630580309435678219
4
8:
41.30884340590701367610602225661983668835542298437471626535605298893874397526094088427552974572052002
4
9:
44.53952223488417733739457595263250022266314015120489706319164664566496904426692549266450398970439520
4
10:
47.70031862984663902646569929782590854007883620432358516678334822390364292010555662930795459952209088
4
11:
50.99935858462437488541225154756280765908612589917180946042021479693824420077811441806154659173143438
4
12:
53.78201662383200937135650197638254574351463553369699913742724455757160027081962431977286511672651636
4
13:
56.79181636579766886583247347616215513183122024813492908279647333267591473331039251347646130243314545
4
14:
59.74038575024492137441920371541732542434684924066235735697539190621104030169018591396938820732509717
4
15:
62.41231203955565378849750590487132430532117384646321971815709577968118245237257072073205948994599600
4
16:
65.10990557381994913023803725010097261927703844652564539239331474885302736483858558838771251172199441
4
17:
67.99773426024578496106717671285087172127320482240165144307056381558516947815297671287509841294847855
4
18:
70.47541635283541227290771472064090024050421046390310690954879053042517093510409595895643366201700899
4
19:
73.05331050110966041205354566889196212587120656430170331357257906117404847340148585958221977442509640
4
20:
75.69879420734841601316261046638221505677380987294863892463642591459315330437967478689332942616518441
Definition
The table holds $t_{m,k}$, the $k$th positive real solution of $\xi^{(m)}(1/2+it)=0$, ordered increasingly with multiplicity, where $\xi(s)=\tfrac12s(s-1)\pi^{-s/2}\Gamma(s/2)\zeta(s)$ is the Riemann xi function [1]. The derivative is taken $m$ times with respect to the complex variable $s$.
Parameters
$m$
—   derivative order ($m\geq1$)
$k$
—   positive critical-line zero index ($k\geq1$, limited to the positive critical-line zeros that exist)
Formulas
(1)
$\Xi^{(m)}(t)=i^m\xi^{(m)}(1/2+it)$, where $\Xi(t)=\xi(1/2+it)$ and the derivative of $\Xi$ is with respect to $t$.
(2)
$\Xi(-t)=\Xi(t)$ and $\Xi^{(m)}(-t)=(-1)^m\Xi^{(m)}(t)$.
Comments
(3)
Only positive ordinates on $\Re(s)=1/2$ are recorded. The origin, which is a zero for odd derivative orders, is excluded. All recorded zeros are simple, and their positive critical-line numbering is certified without assuming the Riemann hypothesis. The general critical-line distribution of derivative zeros is studied in [2].
(4)
Write $\Xi(t)=\xi(1/2+it)$. Its derivatives with respect to the real height $t$ have the same real zeros as the corresponding derivatives of $\xi$ with respect to $s$.
(6)
The real zeros of the Riemann xi Jensen polynomials come from finite polynomials formed from the same completed function. [1], Theorem 1.2, relates low-lying zeros of derivatives of $\xi$ to Jensen hyperbolicity. The central derivatives and Taylor coefficients of $\xi$ are tabulated separately.
Programs
(P1)
Python
import mpmath as mp

mp.mp.dps = 140

def Xi(t):
    s = mp.mpf(1)/2 + 1j*t
    return (s*(s-1)/2 * mp.power(mp.pi, -s/2)
            * mp.gamma(s/2) * mp.zeta(s)).real

def derivative_zero(m, a, b):
    # Supply an isolated real bracket. This returns an approximation.
    return mp.findroot(lambda t: mp.diff(Xi, t, m), (a, b))

# The first positive zero for m=1 lies between 15 and 16.
print(mp.nstr(derivative_zero(1, 15, 16), 100))
References
[1]
M. J. Griffin, K. Ono, L. Rolen, J. Thorner, Z. Tripp and I. Wagner, Jensen polynomials for the Riemann xi-function, version 3 (2020), equation (1.1) and Theorem 1.2. (arXiv)
[2]
I. S. Rezvyakova, Zeros of the derivatives of the Riemann xi-function, Izvestiya: Mathematics 69 (2005), 539–605. (doi)
[3]
M. J. Griffin, K. Ono, L. Rolen and D. Zagier, Jensen polynomials for the Riemann zeta function and other sequences (2019), section 4, Mellin representation. (arXiv)
Links
Similar tables
Real zeros of the Riemann xi Jensen polynomials —   stores real zeros of finite Jensen polynomials associated with the same completed function; the derivative-zero connection is studied in [1], Theorem 1.2
Zeros of the Riemann zeta function —   stores the order-zero ordinates of the same completed function
Taylor coefficients of the completed Riemann zeta function at 1/2 —   stores central derivatives and Taylor coefficients of the completed function
Zeros of the derivative $\zeta'(s)$ of the Riemann zeta function —   stores complex zeros of the derivative of the uncompleted zeta function
Stationary points of the Hardy Z-function —   stores zero ordinates of the derivative of Hardy Z, which has different completion factors
Hardy Z-function derivatives at Riemann zeta zeros —   evaluates derivatives of Hardy Z at zeta zeros, whereas this table locates zeros of derivatives of the completed xi function
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
Table is complete: no (it holds every positive critical-line zero index $1\leq k\leq20$ for derivative orders $1\leq m\leq4$; four successive orders cover both parities and geometry beyond stationary points, while twenty successive roots follow several oscillations; both bounds are noncanonical computational cutoffs chosen to keep complete root isolation and independent checks practical)
How they were obtained:

Arb analytic power series [4] and explicit Cauchy remainder bounds certify a cover of $[0,90]$ for each derivative order at 256 working bits. On every interval, either $\Xi^{(m)}$ excludes zero, or $\Xi^{(m+1)}$ excludes zero and strict endpoint signs count the roots. Parity and a nonzero next derivative handle the excluded origin for odd orders. The cover proves exactly 25 simple positive roots for each order $1\leq m\leq4$, so the first 20 have certified numbering without an assumption of the Riemann hypothesis.

more

Each selected root is refined at 512 bits and enclosed by strict opposite endpoint signs and a nonzero next derivative. The enclosures retain at least 379 relative accuracy bits and justify the stored 100-significant-digit intervals. A separate computation differentiates the theta-integral representation in [3], section 4, and uses 576-bit rigorous quadrature with explicit bounds for both the omitted theta terms and the infinite integration tail. It certifies opposite signs at both endpoints of every written decimal interval.

Known nonzero integral controls run first. The parity and height-derivative identities, simplicity, 640-bit endpoint checks, and rejection of intervals shifted by ten last-place units are tested throughout the selected range. The generator and independent theta checks are repeated on the stored entries. The mpmath program [5] is an approximation recipe; the rigorous bounds come from the attached generator and checks. The attachments certification.md and numerical-evidence.json record the proof and measured results.