Discriminant of the Riemann xi Jensen polynomials

edit · history · discussion · files · long url · Taylor series L-function
Numbers
$d$
$n$ 
$D_{d,n}$
2
0:
0.00003674571928186835960647793248983866464296811574000659531984765735495019750167028049948174333417594369
2
1:
1.439652702461314725815593862420693063797292725109422542705922623967013110936514182379589006377257041e-8
2
2:
5.138555747915446504923946287044233700559920120089117432260811291216183787289355343462949425865733284e-12
2
3:
1.683559043439146291654679509738349036772849857521219614677663258045242797280004884109884231375441769e-15
2
4:
5.097036582901760121721398775516175863411854776080414520100148836778704133582321264328637052047362648e-19
2
5:
1.434282437228248550035821655831738857722839655728399249999072755315022977558704585139337526930069356e-22
2
6:
3.770283536002533202984495719165837200187624339265284438082129495672366966411429212873800525722190606e-26
2
7:
9.299280841771616617677665845644152610268744798946981753874005743819245688158854906389441283726632870e-30
2
8:
2.160420735818203165249950093708370750133910144905845355312389576530384057679647456593318685911918851e-33
2
9:
4.743740337095506698615413072790331754751307965975142800193395698815068229452014248640292063369854918e-37
2
10:
9.874408247140863904512550019604575505898512279322124842329533930102799433108084430912109221271218795e-41
2
11:
1.953811618517250669820772266267991775268482358847193730994021614329866878280068031751689547362871579e-44
2
12:
3.683752581849693433339370332611918954567269417017115198760360196864863608520190595062502022763275362e-48
2
13:
6.632651268921739408669827794637149502511044772969749110207752077335169984019559198728885994731891091e-52
2
14:
1.142714683697683979554879593519658254635469912855464978749110357636906614665061016075428078601660338e-55
2
15:
1.887257931269755881218667231977386206705343013201860422433107772021953902638452665479820972805634346e-59
2
16:
2.992884784091174842519530537883840860598431885875101406325478649982935988918818180505934284668980389e-63
2
17:
4.564342912880365136250401726703322395731182091489536023478617540123621738361805631733504416066330924e-67
2
18:
6.703612951867785550494570192133417907505123460005220725693529889043450512360009614005107985631106293e-71
2
19:
9.494002420676326173759185449223005212624961858734254755450445901189623049773400082052300547056824100e-75
2
20:
1.298154182740530862565520168171794823184737389583374719631761302125008822737423573468973498687458438e-78
3
0:
2.016951585852956169020457818608884110441167187274506164310269434877944571373410729460429850780035438e-13
3
1:
2.489117377061508422402259343014998654385367999273434703530421812684609137252762044779203325252798332e-20
3
2:
2.610029870187666417381082326880187919313992695403100227445262998998805730084359076756330566179184700e-27
3
3:
2.350665054448692847572810469938637849766930778529700595106345866581481220385683233835186810599039562e-34
3
4:
1.836612781662290484347348626379043330918487794065047271145438587105090354059885467883045433503465643e-41
3
5:
1.256141924796778499548423663972812780702153461813474337762247620201756078349429200647818679964972866e-48
3
6:
7.581463985538292506293124897998739579193641422747106432468255817877256879284523992713234262236380059e-56
3
7:
4.067088683135208699737757906285053130892713685173262783415190571935217036638396157393446568284636083e-63
3
8:
1.951739391525173816230031714503357568972946830453128369893475970735575407578591925063111943433558397e-70
3
9:
8.426953009089757419618635969923379206839398426955988248080122522955008962628314654995817369262039724e-78
3
10:
3.290659254045550847353875494397328721893684169023622949148672432075147618993053716360184956567046921e-85
3
11:
1.167603554895461921196664202019998303008643700610958713849536875013643000163745978056112041556829731e-92
3
12:
3.780564493557676221149580299763583096011763223694831334376196236737688607586218304948893746515181243e-100
3
13:
1.121376515311542703166924748138457194921423652831511900745792784104094044678171025385629799718420469e-107
3
14:
3.057886350570031124386588593694202220420199858335293677953192486446404729090533609033035167390123936e-115
3
15:
7.690983638432616590287172086446091004139623752748452467834341734241337353585030818314128860890281230e-123
3
16:
1.789523985568217379521500542572281693146425314946952415659829524567276036656204877333136282494237983e-130
3
17:
3.862728004584282496417624918921252830332265348564915743354037887692369426886002592626379471493185432e-138
3
18:
7.754786487313091658295029443902970744788164139050306589701709428995003337616704103640194111222613413e-146
3
19:
1.451457731421154329785216333065631276721920613757396204765354435307158336437550270865369264777020148e-153
3
20:
2.538441268207897741490673736445098387780138583868492462382161984646254321799337232941934327303265377e-161
4
0:
1.593076901005115938614332949769492260749643185146045382771745037132362784193387136911907229318728610e-25
4
1:
5.218688203103718276644710967338837625887804670250455985765686826346907520581319155848374763964212184e-36
4
2:
1.372898580919099700413987649819418327859912148663870035038880257312283889226077396574743347455283480e-46
4
3:
2.937228864183129370759723585275417540155468411345119995808067059927709539732429239728355501204893911e-57
4
4:
5.171433126870342030729319310237362665312715328219678991518799231422420500133812445315174022045145514e-68
4
5:
7.575362232983931842718967034596135655055240263886436328198548941762088752550489222041608514894165592e-79
4
6:
9.324821748518463003503375637409220725198991946853790069439355399084995176106060911448035739046566348e-90
4
7:
9.733023038188156771006962174777169365920798809569481223232168761120276084940278153373880993347575662e-101
4
8:
8.685303299290997307171513082473678178899315862981679770718992509318133771590601667364943463319258885e-112
4
9:
6.675513059393916039707196626615799900041155999737848723720662223419379588489559044465492937496455738e-123
4
10:
4.449265854292248372688939383590673971424256941739469086918024335226891916339482915671623030560288637e-134
4
11:
2.587501445254105369389226738509457844451016403398339710103655403030860079917560066700735812731957430e-145
4
12:
1.320439946845539037062678876188329366848309030410136990263070294302884341970885601832431023669086832e-156
4
13:
5.943725889100984218499318802925975781962102008422314524540874128295992168322003953592382685370207434e-168
4
14:
2.371258978534551884882334239612352037353515375319249543860442539201071050760787012129702379730738461e-179
4
15:
8.421682798300384195640459403064729868446632274355671421768557570098216478808795604850846168628156492e-191
4
16:
2.673601699635381775284741240645498845843086618836931966300600515425335843262325717654001124458280072e-202
4
17:
7.615953735116032715029882317359032388976889811092416256912691425744519657845202592677005986529939913e-214
4
18:
1.953529476496319994703377005785993117668810165858280174615293875251980305183459736286895753534783228e-225
4
19:
4.527097359429058179769403087081834371856887106904182484507056301799963274380678591788268419016494201e-237
4
20:
9.507529225632336940384549015897022220810482750815757744999719857382806839692020056011493991111308230e-249
5
0:
1.727199275087550179797324140959714621772746164726248827777290326247198472070858289855291737096050096e-41
5
1:
1.302623828189246129705612332708568107292568345610397200872269095844244060044623274474931785868556022e-55
5
2:
7.522070600177092562367878997196183795368807488939745639363105636489453231483967421918788855939918823e-70
5
3:
3.371747846637695098329007786502383983359156095397898637303774610289065276562976420093092888040616707e-84
5
4:
1.188585995642989663454156537872215369797287374769536154255584616993720187347957747805591358550983121e-98
5
5:
3.335360109729781132777420655910780956608545734866184393054398064999183614779865105933292155294451031e-113
5
6:
7.534697446575285999975899901595147267723456711057125061505613104557039519914765424536874467943312623e-128
5
7:
1.384452414267267772268118934656935130011130154157598360962382714538539299965584060583879761552855066e-142
5
8:
2.088746729871851532291796307512091549803963015134957497965812534051185307523329447585906070375276067e-157
5
9:
2.610085417025864080441006398319267092183475016335507529224187064067419683714245066698920874975213272e-172
5
10:
2.722965116840518443191554513059861319476009343616694803420619969120942161234229894890728779066567900e-187
5
11:
2.389063813281948211853848687267489974198832923159085557249485491689295943220034627394233111551400969e-202
5
12:
1.774773594041846780481045916660111502214346352292559924008573798078510999695049370745816231449014237e-217
5
13:
1.123300886440860079321118258479476228705961793115016821405551645005846714858316580424511200642597474e-232
5
14:
6.092503436575670994642899103579338950493011435901758533160028486496693672051287999287394493705906302e-248
5
15:
2.846893248711709000834825367208660633879501488241575428435274880890849058538897937366713399144379945e-263
5
16:
1.151834349924603663325179048017398251455962263406040241470988280922700726642736504667644568442931860e-278
5
17:
4.053912892833986998808758859909951282589620537383255759073753796560706295648937618313182237445000618e-294
5
18:
1.246564537326998714474914950537805905147564325692341038878637119294808952117302350020126215203202322e-309
5
19:
3.362653751337725589884418332268814961749583494105415529043371178173795450919369915622882482686247929e-325
5
20:
7.988019886129355283055308079087783860327601078602002764357947847228412192534023587556643009990071477e-341
6
0:
2.446088827148249837329080422697894632541180986545833674362736514238024954667603463109168199620718289e-61
6
1:
3.756891725557747860095049489499257627718882436732525350090508659633635246278057213039318551457604197e-79
6
2:
4.238627203437916079420721491898227552108541475213317561420290657717547069478821190578139679806270497e-97
6
3:
3.564123368286134047835056316315825385752518461390602615243774453213758647505586641257194060017399676e-115
6
4:
2.264669351462133585571995786172963598746111330491729630702614540327446960698328667033476641978965185e-133
6
5:
1.101582856121388206333592163367774235130205097878606293986814293932246178783670435314537583103938364e-151
6
6:
4.151853137562359617605893619709094006373738668723396420470277032495405797507467433510881472995768368e-170
6
7:
1.226165132593687895382836207903734384510554539926078978853830524083572354996330775141786989382998044e-188
6
8:
2.867096222143402131553144810889320590154491692375440831030095760277573201329755767337665212297699378e-207
6
9:
5.359017530668484328268627895384942824449919415036974283777238217736391703485951326402277342393188557e-226
6
10:
8.078442529856204377703271215839948126080932526383718212380031386814546175505868979566489843460654623e-245
6
11:
9.902251983664954183226986902579195311873173135724142433591034502474327939665510823198039841604976025e-264
6
12:
9.945102521561778253831528959469182636667733144272724887044279712720531527240701167996273572904431390e-283
6
13:
8.241832641166165311461467024417012044312196369890187493978099204758883518659932644999717873143433667e-302
6
14:
5.673293500953266741530298951184121846796133487959314947372444037864190379063079723603651726253147675e-321
6
15:
3.263689072831525946311910516421093563972394450429652012643065621100370031005003857186550984888728389e-340
6
16:
1.578101235481950439305907009516754140910319730884899443727220804513990021235656926581121569281177840e-359
6
17:
6.448301787134074805831848942331038600624681923903539860298941705402238223698135064044901651915868983e-379
6
18:
2.237833405953894446055908932951020340655483787262621552196733843853870715311987061467971956965722580e-398
6
19:
6.627319436330431258873381685093449924486211751914661724445515241504314306670678706412171333705781014e-418
6
20:
1.682330712157044233294405355460767959542423068303179159316459077614898828801686590876516055698334109e-437
7
0:
4.306617230568910168417502231367381629469818671866447255971305720947581402453542290671333944512487143e-85
7
1:
1.208887201351741570603822527065964256582060429116975484526074160834860442244122820975958202688340465e-106
7
2:
2.402831158861954959442820114709841460154515465019200142513551649335646113987156817637307708737860935e-128
7
3:
3.433038307963813244836398869162903391518794591481890894578472590674238691047988723961838805603521077e-150
7
4:
3.576645119565745225596315232849813900225155948582326805074085991084957123660113798307863007952308742e-172
7
5:
2.754209342773263358879883552113064452237465968914951371395870549605163636400638865221148394585797983e-194
7
6:
1.587671205419851677198001334044227770839908382854794294090341871004653774605574403760102238948932067e-216
7
7:
6.932975901949816551715438768873355363061835781003985164631491989516187919708159471966681489346814307e-239
7
8:
2.318853260416138555947588994962208776379605634741297128951692797259870572873239004872879957626006576e-261
7
9:
6.001858715552931470729704815084877671625959731948116892246805192957977712694024007370902149499843252e-284
7
10:
1.213697409463663685664608661917033040566699268576634353367847385965975597846811310623631640503299592e-306
7
11:
1.934699599085850268871452221090763950032421433939886173377461860446396070396816925348699219205825821e-329
7
12:
2.451310656317712823978663613083916780502090776811670347157232653888684002695703561585359802925611849e-352
7
13:
2.487869646394862878398735506712124846057914660825153413301484491809368360479275296613691096153637779e-375
7
14:
2.037251200778749720065748724009132733438427365700273778743546088875594240521239302613788924771351987e-398
7
15:
1.355164809926879217617921954224912948501394741857196143613146118123318457432131639318348088679816989e-421
7
16:
7.369366361088348819147939912151757295874599531057679327138284667723466934742331591372604857381673771e-445
7
17:
3.295728119410903203055898469821858452854557658010329414563645795926397188645826224302605669129857782e-468
7
18:
1.218976824488401622093448546416838969072827897774767439706601445345593729492339860591448873289872761e-491
7
19:
3.748536172212242967087110633553273233620742866277540887618318719099802432356562361761682365661641572e-515
7
20:
9.632093150924490756190834346501253287486882293173988272854253242902541319535884182518754306349028613e-539
8
0:
8.981341734888575624713454750304867632850282878013476308284646274436759659904073751629115505159002479e-113
8
1:
4.181637798478449467507440171903907227314355183192971809822405063718380664435626834658241789357329014e-138
8
2:
1.333822214791369823853904384644055584669908196676574071992021911726382598531002711456543361068155519e-163
8
3:
2.960077511516573351507540219731423591878475900586457626003881719291849257974498743233773293721314835e-189
8
4:
4.638185534760003935344513271257055652910116565093503746764561872131164853249843576869851042651518436e-215
8
5:
5.203416762484858548952612143329621720777424807012731793794222939380957897933592583607431738989871539e-241
8
6:
4.234814553331227458659199616144902248914071000883195171073935128728360068781647815811470245013839046e-267
8
7:
2.531316875669227055496590353649510796456272252325142366521292150665533416635981920429225008890617710e-293
8
8:
1.124204753543683852874544101462785964411913666914753244601086197242362022797759617788390127679237923e-319
8
9:
3.749959435088468398737513947500186455127604233757881389257454621589478164591027135697720861356570679e-346
8
10:
9.490302413773788167768691762288297998851640670462660576703268748061795408320864907916036341556851879e-373
8
11:
1.839550868638353487345716694949337595540068094122298005350055789922240924191455336958869754254125957e-399
8
12:
2.755275403617315471358065635334614651565915282001140216777176661904336306329339236307818599797078485e-426
8
13:
3.215443075653186757636043949871168562141236784873690268527212181953432481102928556341161984071115366e-453
8
14:
2.946577054146093636860786819580039086126619876982188611954229930731838945364173016951134129812993602e-480
8
15:
2.135846575695727943515440630108963393165520213856930826475793636802448432706957184375791135580646124e-507
8
16:
1.233058989502184751452764972558632171712507038845124490107586072151490108534098717077688325905760326e-534
8
17:
5.706539762646719516419045991208392109614601939314755621230364246935609602129334305652982734416872168e-562
8
18:
2.130060143332173639099687736154866332143872842779098203830723287360042388923111080295593268795266310e-589
8
19:
6.449847990540487414395240116190151047645059189067861664506125474254960325746122959474312994667287310e-617
8
20:
1.593013214459702523004323704078093321504759819401909572363550054395088017232776161376027326182889102e-644
Definition
The table holds $D_{d,n}=\operatorname{disc}_X J^{d,n}(X)$, where $J^{d,n}(X)=\sum_{j=0}^d\binom dj\gamma_{n+j}X^j$, $\gamma_m=m!\xi^{(2m)}(1/2)/(2m)!$, and $\xi(s)=\tfrac12s(s-1)\pi^{-s/2}\Gamma(s/2)\zeta(s)$ [1].
Parameters
$d$
—   degree ($d\geq2$)
$n$
—   coefficient shift ($n\geq0$)
Formulas
(1)
$D_{d,n}=\gamma_{n+d}^{2d-2}\prod_{1\leq i<j\leq d}(r_i-r_j)^2$, where $r_1,\ldots,r_d$ are the roots of $J^{d,n}$, counted with multiplicity.
(2)
$D_{d,n}=(-1)^{d(d-1)/2}\gamma_{n+d}^{-1}\operatorname{Res}_X(J^{d,n},\partial_XJ^{d,n})$, with the same convention as the universal polynomial discriminants.
(3)
$D_{2,n}=4(\gamma_{n+1}^2-\gamma_n\gamma_{n+2})$.
(4)
$D_{3,n}=27\left[4(\gamma_{n+1}^2-\gamma_n\gamma_{n+2})(\gamma_{n+2}^2-\gamma_{n+1}\gamma_{n+3})-(\gamma_{n+1}\gamma_{n+2}-\gamma_n\gamma_{n+3})^2\right]$.
(5)
$\operatorname{disc}_X(cJ^{d,n})=c^{2d-2}D_{d,n}$ for $c\neq0$.
Comments
(6)
The expansion $\Theta(z)=\xi(1/2+\sqrt z)=\sum_{m\geq0}\gamma_m z^m/m!$ defines an entire function by the even central series, without a square-root branch choice. The shift $n$ refers to $\Theta^{(n)}$, rather than $\xi^{(n)}(s)$ [1]. The central derivatives and Taylor coefficients of $\xi$ determine $\gamma_m$.
(7)
The factor $\tfrac12$ in $\xi$ agrees with [2], equation (1.1). The sequence in [4], equation (1), is $8\gamma_m$: that normalization leaves the roots unchanged but multiplies $D_{d,n}$ by $8^{2d-2}$. The discriminant here is taken before any monic or affine normalization.
(8)
The ordinary Jensen roots are negative and simple throughout this table, so every recorded discriminant is positive. A positive discriminant alone does not imply that all roots are real in higher degree: $(X^2+1)(X^2+4)$ has discriminant $5184$ and no real roots. This finite table makes no inference about the Riemann hypothesis; [5] discusses the limitations of interpreting fixed-degree behavior.
(9)
The quadratic discriminant is four times the classical Turán expression; the cubic discriminant is 27 times the higher-order Turán expression [3]. Degree one has discriminant $1$ independently of the coefficients and is omitted.
Programs
(P1)
Sage
from math import comb, factorial
import numberdb.sage as numberdb
from sage.rings.complex_arb import ComplexBallField
from sage.rings.polynomial.polynomial_ring_constructor import PolynomialRing


def jensen_discriminant(d, n, bits=896):
    """Return an enclosure of the raw discriminant at degree d and shift n."""
    assert d >= 2 and n >= 0
    C = ComplexBallField(bits)
    P = PolynomialRing(C, 'X')
    s = C(1)/2 + P.gen()
    length = 2*(n+d)+1
    f = (s*(s-1)/2 * ((-s/2)*C.pi().log())._exp_series(length)
         * (s/2)._gamma_series(length) * s._zeta_series(length))
    J = P([comb(d,j)*factorial(n+j)*f[2*(n+j)] for j in range(d+1)])
    value = J.discriminant()
    assert value.imag().contains_zero()
    result = value.real()
    assert not result.is_NaN() and not result.is_infinity()
    assert result.accuracy() >= 350, 'Increase bits for this degree and shift.'
    return result


# Choose a degree and shift; larger indices may need more working bits.
print(jensen_discriminant(3, 0))
References
[1]
Cormac O'Sullivan, Zeros of Jensen polynomials and asymptotics for the Riemann xi function (2020), version 2, equations (1.2) and (1.3). (arXiv)
[2]
M. J. Griffin, K. Ono, L. Rolen, J. Thorner, Z. Tripp and I. Wagner, Jensen polynomials for the Riemann xi-function (2020), version 3, equations (1.1) and (1.2). (arXiv)
[3]
W. Y. C. Chen, D. X. Q. Jia and L. X. W. Wang, Higher Order Turán Inequalities for the Partition Function (2017), version 1, section 1. (arXiv)
[4]
M. Griffin, K. Ono, L. Rolen and D. Zagier, Jensen polynomials for the Riemann zeta function and other sequences (2019), version 2, sections 1 and 4. (arXiv)
[5]
D. W. Farmer, Jensen polynomials are not a plausible route to proving the Riemann Hypothesis (2022), version 2. (arXiv)
Links
Similar tables
Taylor coefficients of the completed Riemann zeta function at 1/2 —   stores the central derivatives and Taylor coefficients that define the sequence $\gamma_m$
Real zeros of the Riemann xi Jensen polynomials —   stores all roots whose squared differences enter this discriminant for the same degree and shift
Discriminants of the general polynomial of degree $n$ —   stores universal discriminant polynomials in formal coefficients through degree five
Zeros of derivatives of the Riemann xi function —   stores zeros of derivatives of the completed function in its complex argument, while this table concerns invariants of finite Jensen polynomials
Real zeros of the Riemann xi Hermite combinations —   stores the roots obtained from the same coefficients by replacing each monomial $X^{d-j}$ in the reciprocal polynomial $X^dJ^{d,n}(1/X)$ with the physicists' Hermite polynomial $H_{d-j}(X)$; $D_{d,n}$ here remains the raw discriminant of the original $J^{d,n}$
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
Table is complete: no (it holds every degree $2\leq d\leq8$ and coefficient shift $0\leq n\leq20$; degrees two and three include the classical Turán expressions, while degrees four through eight cover higher discriminants of both parities, and the consecutive shift prefix follows the first derivatives of $\Theta$ from the central case; these are noncanonical computational cutoffs for two intrinsic discrete indices)
How they were obtained:

Arb ball arithmetic [6] expands the completed-product definition through central Taylor order 56 at 896 bits and computes the Sylvester determinant of each Jensen polynomial and its derivative. The least accurate discriminant enclosure retains 450 relative-accuracy bits. These bounds justify every recorded 100-significant-digit interval.

more

An independent theta-moment computation from [4], section 4, uses rigorous quadrature at 832 bits with explicit bounds for omitted theta terms and the infinite integration tail. It encloses all 29 required coefficients independently of zeta and gamma evaluation. Strict endpoint signs on disjoint real brackets certify all 735 roots needed here; their leading-coefficient-weighted products of squared differences give discriminant enclosures retaining at least 380 bits, each contained in its written decimal interval.

The checks cover known nonzero integral and discriminant controls, all Vieta coefficients, every quadratic and cubic identity, scaling by eight, all 84 available universal-discriminant specializations, a 1024-bit series rerun, and rejection of 294 shifted decimal intervals. The independent checks are repeated on the stored strings. The attached generator, checks, certification, argument-selection note and numerical evidence reproduce the computation and record its finite bounds.