lesson-proposal.md

back to table · edit · history · where entries came from · files · download

1317 bytes, as of the version from 2026-11-17 11:56 (current). Recorded here, not run.

## Exact components need an exact check, not singleton containment of a rounded enclosure

What happened: the independently evaluated expression 5*sqrt(729/25)
straddled 27 by about 1e-191. Containing that numerical enclosure in the exact
singleton stored as 27 failed, despite agreement of the mathematics. The
checker was repaired by simplifying rational c algebraically before ball
evaluation; no stored coefficient changed. It now retains exact27 and checks
containment for all511 values.

What the skill says now: preserve exact values and check the stored interval;
finite narrow balls are required. It does not specifically address this
possible failure of an independent checker at exact singleton entries.

What it should say: when an independently computed enclosure straddles an
exact stored value, resolve exactness by a proved algebraic identity or an
independent exact computation; finite numerical overlap alone cannot prove
an exact singleton, and failure of enclosure containment alone does not
establish a wrong exact value.

Evidence: T737 at (a,b)=(15,30), independent.py's rational-c cancellation,
independent-results.json, readback-results.json. The independent arithmetic
construction and local cube identities fix the positive sign. This is a
proposal for human review, not a live skill edit.