audit-assessment.md

back to table · edit · history · where entries came from · files · download

1393 bytes, as of the version from 2026-11-18 12:45 (current). Recorded here, not run.

# Builder assessment of T751 authenticated audit

The final raw audit is audit.json. Its only remaining finding is the heuristic
warning that the categorical lattice parameter might conceal three named
quantities. It is not a mechanical validity error or a numerical discrepancy.

The parameter identifies three graphs, each carrying the identical physical
quantity R_eff/R0 with the same infinite-periodic limit, common edge units,
source/sink convention, cubic signed-permutation symmetry and joint vertex
coordinate indices. The value header r_L(l,m,n) applies to every row. This is
analogous to one effective-resistance quantity indexed by named graphs, rather
than a selector between different functions or quantities of one graph. The
family coverage plan explicitly authorizes this boundary. Keeping the three
networks together is mathematically justified; the warning is retained rather
than hidden through parameter renaming, tag deletion or a boundary change.

The generator installation-command finding was genuine and was repaired with
an explicit `sage -pip install numberdb` instruction. The final audit no longer
reports it. Grouping the four labels preserves the requested shell order and
readability; the categorical warning remains and was not bypassed.

This is a builder's assessment for the independent critic, not an independent
scientific or argument-selection verdict.