Hardy Z pre-Schwarzian condition for Lehmer pairs

edit · history · discussion · files · short url · inequality L-function special values number theory
Numbers
$n$ 
$\widehat{\widehat g}_n$
1:
7.348347410196778467931613019268926570214801338100354264860876945392695812281080398973186944633467935
2:
2.831085364004392650939245332015347967668631406306765202904491055366048175574780109874366915519037504
3:
11.51413023737375003046907588568928617853736538080359443366003951683513773830667369032126477631972837
4:
1.846735116672828441915054880736123570711364085008073786296783385853558086588330218614594803193126746
5:
10.34089492211521348437307452549856970123833603081680591246603158337878677482715927211609404456249793
6:
4.987462537749233338229606599741818019352305465611689172464112664906791111723073866713158211239242462
7:
2.361901560557380377139565053834288877220467992383972678502707314064179756594709774895946423412670809
8:
18.86261912282261485937394641720075771763574908808436473619369874226115924547914460342949211717338438
9:
1.638875941641724935218448204724299638708967245183287228349952037076474549096499001187622985736736269
10:
7.476385418764240668103214437957413449070999669619501688101024525030401900790450912390579427574218542
11:
6.703544194665969577960889248705996440153752664347509849282332193207485754914060026703041982691814656
12:
7.708886681453425645810794340955436480891908524719551312447231668928025468046451294957628797540353760
13:
1.503682068315677006437129241788041633996674986015803249190805225427017597445246306614589381255835773
14:
23.08850318291787372498653356134603298491954227125207218186580784291504280357166891181937106603561805
15:
2.484189765263220750942819635350945838202172274128357257426053028124426579297085197087268121158251034
16:
4.822969840721753898649260526468717174446903878703498247610331082836189799825962666022070647053376513
17:
4.119818658525241813121290623735443242065310298662962498145761845940419053786316109308407072735961237
18:
15.88917533179086550194554912863802114097642232245101832002162642871806022760060557884281444996662879
19:
1.779305360938994901278352489679076445576470957626887691764774951138211256702809179384066276926472412
20:
5.113773271619221277978968146091056124361872879247517633798321718027468330197449298360974130816406371
21:
13.47289297625813103776343628134688816896604554274408725319867451351314990421207677222581952133655405
22:
2.401300938477771375549055259652958636078781028434499881082302796857463649596076164614512347686767530
23:
9.577834586289940159966223177858403264187095448561689776593010228609039970265365333228390192193118591
24:
1.635324843705138721995210351823437767851465925359069939199739026848749445291790151995843413361945855
25:
19.35971295213739929755929057023883852537637755293802990700257341133533790924320980603477773884417255
26:
6.376387342043628889802503134766049640869162019333304861554881357227862336447180274201793738858074538
27:
1.579966388408805458450155434734181104881401452557510367891249663727694695597325387100528720149502104
28:
13.31385521170662632873688928938131906253821837111945258106741086665400695727744632690505101504208757
29:
4.945442847339048801373086186044640326756478253543199824523899723816729608958176629027266453062917142
30:
6.154737944898368292783677295124351779076707456994716700020897001951118886217010733856117632325000041
31:
3.166719981828446860743812459177656429055848489882973261647707899147650858233403821117798407453589644
32:
3.088761880963011387411898069078857458481708350765347506068759822156187963713627364303766955374591571
33:
43.32044666118083837679136065783585320301147014925489364979425095326747170780462810041855420494014615
34:
1.080202880460168414429433430155556349019113757846164702256643152755889679515929192917107521928817433
35:
14.78366887143652586705219843553464449879419582630249117388834116449083836154398608490820287903127909
36:
3.332078878350366084866622224899552697515243681776666633703882604489593569694359750966978839024106708
37:
6.619652568882931135054088412164896124219076893264543107644506608004290679009267044133058933798668540
38:
8.305989784801296721848552441374862004470238993242199307611089909139125181784542966441636656843982515
39:
3.532824020939422775791152447569962063626496051051623168292003986022975678451995271378055313510795010
40:
2.245436700757165633533022008355628970667443551142599439493411461379181754932360125694685561660825875
41:
17.94860738432603449382588181217797972425219358266669760765858767390568977527814148092501474151915383
42:
5.095195453417896902979417163638349495817448460082664407100750997487036376452531952428218109279805315
43:
2.480845126681087675071810337368194372652947465050617486437415539508354264191358087460485119657350874
44:
10.29078508693944675389924793626607970933961596603699957327493329686993176661041221897959509806290423
45:
1.714459363596689036630100091902703393181416174138282990084381061991114427729491106917588065094862804
46:
22.02693687672215246667479718135803141520003154772971141310523773559804869374536915004018080463573332
47:
3.686084767528264836588684037730855793139679234265368761837678312222513137622803822323314134098210581
48:
2.631566155750827462300660057604830498466758838692468848519153364668713351483124877299462457299221806
49:
5.597229043942971848160842989991764727708161203805023803151739610085307010463960519859398404122680350
50:
12.72518522004755619715604407829780676841511805453590829472010801168683254430934735805318272734728390
51:
2.072892851383617430100230746317174686919006065126707711094589504450181247184511961812049827415741944
52:
19.67918496320084489408948548211634552958497863085850917312745442140849142982600872817693235634939343
53:
1.241884370311156153763245340542375432353842988239489178510529708954148556048104220591806318824797968
54:
10.69422503391160773387688441803570680593478033630213027831854995043683495006889759210286928597953949
55:
15.45155894602569321366545416369316989079800427989040821784592497104984865657437471380583147311276220
56:
3.568497481052168414793919266089727059485912432963558479090009402472406988477266831292728113952329784
57:
2.345678244309003909993388692485361465079547344276888209790201025637647132663685978118734652241207545
58:
9.791820227094485599006611828948213618301607373474193794630232099606443320659560455613460015749246008
59:
3.516048357565645963797798703678411459676010860340282632643973084302316860513850874259392849536573137
60:
8.903822521875711478330608609949487577633351106731326440228057063167333679684108333862594248750204282
61:
3.369863849177424598282473020719383898819764393710412286266241424093250932504037594583401402767674902
62:
10.10346387357044225630344139501350456434442019812930017014546586123846479713759316532079152717313317
63:
1.237134194126769598614846973156681995832322730915320829077285889732087315493260263247685474280684824
64:
44.05304089469185471139276549315309339745780300197014253253609008531282416731347754707564109491640481
65:
2.405900724030043223444250525338284332771011545787885703600063954128955767348521731205614024814612390
66:
4.498504446458689583699243932035448164343086214772371668213804435576223857554373719090473934423616212
67:
5.829371653607405162185747610932266253893798518467560464741077099753360510797830481717424690205662286
68:
2.928868776646162008333426773423041492201861145662126321149519728327913533818481150245297156619606239
69:
7.132809671787005242619966517114738626540528338860582433202826970959408401724190999821802070517561569
70:
25.71452973996923079653520510558942946750882947473721441905337095420365705252318337403752858946336050
71:
1.193080124751299463149609675420919945821683607546434337307905303329600959881100209750967266089064775
72:
8.713178176341037728112162435611411392348505440624066606889241212342192018159802008632561472894384997
73:
6.949615669785169225016717783799028063922229529041636017880294120811456436951940956185624277694432676
74:
14.35987782213565101452790434814323086584534578147442001721690923734978903697008345785327353342310317
75:
1.584991339099636718826032029893578376769293052514688459143260977902508538084863531657476155271402240
76:
10.66010050134432908894691023366283086039405981110670741773969333417516806167670035026043356155006928
77:
4.753962715618802626686920821389341212083723255507633112087120388224027481728656025328449482834969462
78:
2.006392449595158270083261501862222865440654662173350273794207811404388284591821909162868875316852747
79:
29.23146041485425772752729986178401720299573360065705914547432318999794902724405510048367409255527293
80:
2.264280455784690344279377931538074628758077179598021987187331150217394740816699599342222917113649271
81:
6.317357336962936720235860555917878252906030515444722788871923959034263102480762684920122795161120291
82:
2.239354357528755033391145200050732456304579463016882796669825059586612705976578318608077974167290790
83:
12.97158604087279460672916396503448295847386688496059039521185284651533071873888240122504529551420221
84:
3.279274529171492350192957807937168119162654187214711091780908952760652205399388757335108142993229811
85:
7.087828255782768969039770233717205909918669363756916856702480972805793886509720718273888306161103769
86:
5.143542787861968653387705586639624208920994025159701765855283461335266934303182747431367412726332246
87:
2.455626023059521842172805570099041499246398099341331461787687286621253895860244640747012384168442075
88:
4.840597624991294337393451671670538071228644959759038236616287833047517269537280080020658325137214520
89:
15.90091648606607196179296343286225927376076809554783041078468054886596419246539678401793659434736499
90:
9.295750986072378550846557676393470188971122488650837784336138652158991468934172435820234575717082936
91:
1.189277288215817237017057969745398893594525673675212040867655251970232153126100080671755336571902893
92:
30.77060523686920980073366636569758170991592134096805239006431027717278748608463351282647974847235311
93:
1.466530927215370854553995496190222566920511812899541492751129528171480888451502100797385998541616243
94:
14.20340552026557511233550633851637391017306075327413981868966083380081514399626551499658547728830080
95:
4.970640761031826846955703037159316319397300664019556655527418758246558585389829923238699663214928390
96:
12.73835195633254634838383475039502844448801613598351567192575908071422205041753698106281868905977408
97:
1.268640147376162613094867368448256245774226205178006679463307341604821485473894624260029414977745875
98:
9.907689237795530164992773139236496688975841795189927958458292352134247907940717537563889048302981814
99:
17.51645108032968874749157187910369103166969189112449286768195779392072042347210547016048763855440246
100:
2.263372717185322204997026804083895328914882615390423732697508823114282673823433564194670393683892815
6707:
34.22429352683558509969112166113154700598114661567460684873813467498112522302834173386250390954685990
6708:
963.9733204405334458285421868340735046755445550305976152198488120286882218173396210209593003995828043
6709:
0.6718782139239942204656657891576845398611499221552129919845973366171222394096578471099759158631031852
6710:
2567.401302181258254381451853827850877000024846316563295622883885453916842146858721038359914858068549
6711:
12.60226702077845383879505718714519180332010185942060543127310363604361857729410930593604867981648441
Definition
The table holds $\widehat{\widehat g}_n=\tfrac13\Delta_n^2(-Q_Z(\gamma_n)-Q_Z(\gamma_{n+1}))-2$, where $\gamma_n$ and $\gamma_{n+1}$ are consecutive positive simple zeros of the Hardy $Z$-function, $\Delta_n=\gamma_{n+1}-\gamma_n$, and $Q_Z(t)=(Z^{\prime\prime}/Z^{\prime})^{\prime}(t)=Z^{\prime\prime\prime}(t)/Z^{\prime}(t)-(Z^{\prime\prime}(t)/Z^{\prime}(t))^2$ [1], §4.
Parameters
$n$
—   lower positive zero index ($n\geq1$, with both $\gamma_n$ and $\gamma_{n+1}$ simple)
Formulas
(1)
Under the Riemann hypothesis, $\widehat{\widehat g}_n<\tfrac45-3\Delta_n^2(\gamma_n^{-2}+\gamma_{n+1}^{-2})$ is sufficient for $(\gamma_n,\gamma_{n+1})$ to be a Lehmer pair [1], equation (15).
(2)
Let $\widehat g_n$ denote the Hardy Z derivative condition, defined by $\widehat g_n=\tfrac13\Delta_n^2\sum_{t\in\{\gamma_n,\gamma_{n+1}\}}[-Z^{\prime\prime\prime}(t)/Z^{\prime}(t)+\tfrac34(Z^{\prime\prime}(t)/Z^{\prime}(t))^2]-2$. Direct subtraction gives $\widehat{\widehat g}_n-\widehat g_n=\tfrac1{12}\Delta_n^2\sum_{t\in\{\gamma_n,\gamma_{n+1}\}}(Z^{\prime\prime}(t)/Z^{\prime}(t))^2\geq0$.
Comments
(3)
The Hardy Z-function, also called the Riemann-Siegel Z-function, is $Z(t)=e^{i\theta(t)}\zeta(1/2+it)$, where $\theta(t)=\operatorname{Im}\log\Gamma(1/4+it/2)-(t/2)\log\pi$. The log-gamma branch is analytic on the right half-plane and real at $1/4$, so $\theta(0)=0$. All derivatives are with respect to the real height $t$ [1].
(4)
The positive real zeros of $Z(t)$ are ordered increasingly from $n=1$, with multiplicity. They agree with the usual positive nontrivial-zeta-zero ordinates throughout the computed range: finite zero isolation and counting certify that every nontrivial zero there is simple and on the critical line. The parameter chooses an adjacent pair, not two independently selected endpoints.
(5)
The entries are the real values in Simonič’s Hardy Z pre-Schwarzian condition, rather than indicators that a pair passes. His notation $PZ^{\prime}$ means $Q_Z=(Z^{\prime\prime}/Z^{\prime})^{\prime}$, the derivative of the logarithmic derivative of $Z^{\prime}$. The sufficient Lehmer-pair implication in Formulas assumes the Riemann hypothesis [1], equation (15). The numerical definition only requires the selected two zeros to be simple.
(6)
The indices $n=34$ and $n=6709$ give the first Lehmer pair and Lehmer’s historical pair in [1], Tables 1–2. The neighboring high indices are comparison gaps, and ordinary low-height gaps are retained even when the sufficient condition fails.
(7)
The pre-Schwarzian quantity connects the pair to the stationary points of Hardy Z. The local stationary-point asymptotic in [1], equation (17), assumes both RH and his additional hypothesis (16), and its unspecified error term is not a numerical error bound for this table. T585 counts two positive stationary points before the first zeta zero, so its index is not the lower zero index $n$.
Programs
(P1)
Python (mpmath)
from mpmath import mp
mp.dps = 130
def ghat2(n):
    a, b = (mp.im(mp.zetazero(j)) for j in (n, n+1))
    def minus_Q(t):
        d1, d2, d3 = (mp.siegelz(t, derivative=k) for k in (1,2,3))
        return -d3/d1 + (d2/d1)**2
    return (b-a)**2*(minus_Q(a)+minus_Q(b))/3 - 2
# Approximate an additional index; this program gives no rigorous error bound.
print(mp.nstr(ghat2(101), 100))
References
[1]
Aleksander Simonič, Lehmer pairs and derivatives of Hardy’s Z-function (2017), arXiv version 2, §4 definition and equation (15), §5 equation (19) and Tables 1–2. (arXiv)
Links
Similar tables
Hardy Z derivative condition for Lehmer pairs —   stores the distinct derivative criterion with coefficient 3/4 in the squared derivative ratio; the difference identity relates the two quantities
Hardy Z-function derivatives at Riemann zeta zeros —   stores the signed first three derivatives at individual endpoints used by this nonlinear pair quantity
Zeros of the Riemann zeta function —   stores the zero ordinates whose adjacent gaps enter this quantity
Stationary points of the Hardy Z-function —   stores stationary locations relevant to the pre-Schwarzian interpretation, with a different indexing origin
Data properties
Entries are of type: real number
digits: 100 (Unknown key)
Table is complete: no (it holds all lower pair indices $1\leq n\leq100$ and $6707\leq n\leq6711$; the low-height prefix supplies consecutive reference coverage including comparison gaps, and the higher window contains the historical pair and two neighboring gaps on each side; the prefix cutoff and comparison window are noncanonical cost-bounded reference choices)
How they were obtained:

FLINT's certified numbered zeta-zero enclosures and Hardy Z Taylor jets [2] are computed in ball arithmetic at 533 working bits. The full root enclosures propagate through the three signed height derivatives, the adjacent gap, both ratios and the final subtraction. Taylor coefficient $k$ is multiplied by $k!$, and $Z^{\prime}$ excludes zero at every selected endpoint. All 105 output balls are finite and retain at least 503 relative accuracy bits. Every stored 100-significant-digit decimal interval contains both the original ball and its 599-bit recomputation.

more

A reused certified FLINT prefix contains 6712 distinct critical-line roots. This build rechecks their strict ordering, overlap with all 107 freshly enclosed selected endpoints, and the total count $N(T)=6712$ at an exact rational height $T$ strictly between the 6712th and 6713th root enclosures. Here $N(T)$ counts every nontrivial zero with $0<\operatorname{Im}(s)\leq T$, with multiplicity. The finite certificate establishes numbering, consecutiveness and simplicity without assuming RH. Counts immediately before and after all selected endpoints are also checked; the attached prefix-provenance.json identifies the reused input evidence.

All 105 values agree within their stored intervals with independent mpmath roots and Hardy Z derivatives at 130 and 165 decimal digits [3]. Analytic Cauchy contour extraction [1], equation (19), checks the eight lower indices $1,34,100,6707,6708,6709,6710,6711$ at 130 and 165 digits using 96 and 128 contour points, respectively. These numerical comparisons supplement the ball bounds; they are not certified contour remainder estimates. All 101 overlapping roots agree with the stored zeta ordinates, and all 306 overlapping signed derivatives agree with the stored endpoint derivatives.

The difference identity in Formulas passes on every entry. Exact polynomial controls give $2/3$ for $f(t)=t(t-1)$ and $28/27$ for $f(t)=t(t-1)(t-3)$ at the pair $0,1$. Zero-count and nonzero-origin controls, the coarse published pair values $1.08$ and $0.67$, and deliberate wrong-coefficient, wrong-factorial, perturbed-value and wrong-index controls pass. The attached checks and numerical-evidence.json record methods, uncertainties, source hashes and the scope of the comparisons.